July 13, 1999

[Ex Parte Presentation]{.underline}

Magalie Roman Salas, Esq.

Secretary

Federal Communications Commission

445 12^th^ Street, S.W.

Washington, D.C. 20554

> RE: In the Matter of Applications for Consent to the Transfer of
> Control of Licenses and Section 214 Authorizations from Ameritech
> Corporation, Transferor, to SBC Communications Inc., Transferee.
>
> CC Dkt. No. 98-141

Dear Ms. Salas:

On July 24, 1998, SBC Communications Inc. ("SBC") and Ameritech
Corporation ("Ameritech") filed joint applications under sections 214
and 310(d) of the Communications Act of 1934, as amended, requesting
Commission approval of the transfer of control of licenses and
authorizations now controlled or requested by Ameritech or its
affiliates or subsidiaries to SBC. After lengthy negotiations with the
Commission staff to formulate a set of conditions that address concerns
raised by Chairman Kennard in a letter to SBC and Ameritech dated April
1, 1999, SBC and Ameritech filed an [ex parte]{.underline} with the
Commission on July 1, 1999 setting forth the proposed conditions. On
July 8, 1999, at the suggestion of the Commission staff, SBC and
Ameritech filed another [ex parte]{.underline} summarizing certain of
the conditions, setting forth a timetable for implementation, and
submitting errata to the July 1, 1999 submission.

Included in the July 8, 1999 submission was a change to paragraph 2.a.
of the proposed conditions identifying four Federal Performance Parity
Plan ("FPPP") performance measurements -- Measurements 2b, 3b, 4c, and
5b -- that SBC intends to implement in California and Nevada using the
business rules applicable in those states. To assist commenters, the
Commission staff has requested that SBC and Ameritech place the relevant
California and Nevada business rules in the public record of this
proceeding. SBC and Ameritech therefore are providing as Attachment A
hereto the California and Nevada business rules. For comparison
purposes, Measure 8 correlates to FPPP Measure 4c; Measure 11 correlates
to FPPP Measurement 2b; Measure 13 correlates to FPPP 5b; and Measure 16
correlates to FPPP Measurement 3b.

Please let us know if you have any questions about these materials.

Yours Sincerely,

\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_
\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_

Richard Hetke Paul K. Mancini

Senior Counsel General Attorney

Ameritech Corporation and Assistant General Counsel

> SBC Communications Inc.

**ATTACHMENT A**

***[Provisioning]{.underline}* Measure 8**

***Title:*** Percent Completed Within Standard Interval

+-------------+------------------+------------------+------------------+
| ***Area***  | ***Requirement   |                  |                  |
|             | Description***   |                  |                  |
+-------------+------------------+------------------+------------------+
| ***Desc     | Measures of      |                  |                  |
| ription:*** | orders completed |                  |                  |
|             | within the       |                  |                  |
|             | standard         |                  |                  |
|             | interval of      |                  |                  |
|             | receipt of       |                  |                  |
|             | valid,           |                  |                  |
|             | error-free       |                  |                  |
|             | service request. |                  |                  |
+-------------+------------------+------------------+------------------+
| ***Method   | Sum (Total New,  |                  |                  |
| of          | Move and Change  |                  |                  |
| Calc        | Orders Completed |                  |                  |
| ulation:*** | Within the       |                  |                  |
|             | Standard         |                  |                  |
|             | interval of      |                  |                  |
|             | Receipt of       |                  |                  |
|             | Valid,           |                  |                  |
|             | Error-free       |                  |                  |
|             | Service Request) |                  |                  |
|             | / (Total New,    |                  |                  |
|             | Move and Change  |                  |                  |
|             | Orders)          |                  |                  |
+-------------+------------------+------------------+------------------+
| ***Report   | Monthly          |                  |                  |
| Period:***  |                  |                  |                  |
+-------------+------------------+------------------+------------------+
| ***Report   | Individual CLEC, |                  |                  |
| St          | CLECs in the     |                  |                  |
| ructure:*** | aggregate, by    |                  |                  |
|             | ILEC (if analog  |                  |                  |
|             | applies), and    |                  |                  |
|             | ILEC Affiliates  |                  |                  |
+-------------+------------------+------------------+------------------+
| ***Reported | By service group |                  |                  |
| By:***      | type excluding   |                  |                  |
|             | services with    |                  |                  |
|             | flexible due     |                  |                  |
|             | dates.           |                  |                  |
+-------------+------------------+------------------+------------------+
| **          | Region (PB),     |                  |                  |
| *Geographic | Statewide (GTE)  |                  |                  |
| Level:***   |                  |                  |                  |
+-------------+------------------+------------------+------------------+
| **          | **Parity for     | ## Pac           | **GTE Retail**   |
| *Measurable | Resale is Retail | ific Bell Retail |                  |
| S           | for Pacific Bell |                  | Dispatch         |
| tandard:*** | and GTE.**       | POTS - Business  | Designed         |
|             |                  | (Assured)        | Services         |
|             | **Parity for UNE |                  |                  |
|             | measured**       | ISDN(BRI)        | Dispatch         |
|             |                  |                  | Designed         |
|             | **for the        | ADSL             | Services         |
|             | following        |                  | Dispatch         |
|             | UNEs:**          | ISDN(PRI)/DS1    | Designed         |
|             |                  |                  | Services         |
|             | 2/4w (5.5 db)    | POTS - Business  |                  |
|             | assured analog   | (fielded)        | Dispatch         |
|             | loop             |                  | Designed         |
|             |                  | CENTREX          | Services         |
|             | 2w digital       |                  |                  |
|             | loop(ISDN        | CENTREX          | CentraNet        |
|             | capable)         |                  | --Simple         |
|             |                  | DS1/ISDN(PRI)    |                  |
|             | 2w digital       |                  | CentraNet        |
|             | loop(xDSL        | PBX DID          | --Complex        |
|             | capable)         |                  |                  |
|             |                  | HICAP            | CentraNet        |
|             | 4w digital loop  |                  | --Complex        |
|             | (1.544Mbps       | Analogous Retail |                  |
|             | capable/HDSL)    | Service          | CentraNet        |
|             |                  |                  | --Complex        |
|             | UNE Port--Basic  | ILEC Dedicated   |                  |
|             | Analog/Coin      | Trunks           | CentraNet        |
|             |                  |                  | --Complex        |
|             | UNE              |                  |                  |
|             | Port--CENTREX    |                  | HICAP Designed   |
|             |                  |                  |                  |
|             | UNE Port--ISDN   |                  | N/A              |
|             | (BRI)            |                  |                  |
|             |                  |                  | ILEC Dedicated   |
|             | UNE              |                  | Trunks           |
|             | Po               |                  |                  |
|             | rt--DS1/ISDN-PRI |                  |                  |
|             |                  |                  |                  |
|             | (incl. DS1 line  |                  |                  |
|             | port)            |                  |                  |
|             |                  |                  |                  |
|             | UNE Port--PBX    |                  |                  |
|             | DID              |                  |                  |
|             |                  |                  |                  |
|             | UNE Dedicated    |                  |                  |
|             | Transport        |                  |                  |
|             |                  |                  |                  |
|             | (incl. DS1 and   |                  |                  |
|             | DS3)             |                  |                  |
|             |                  |                  |                  |
|             | UNE Platform (PB |                  |                  |
|             | only)            |                  |                  |
|             |                  |                  |                  |
|             | *                |                  |                  |
|             | *Interconnection |                  |                  |
|             | Trunks**         |                  |                  |
+-------------+------------------+------------------+------------------+
| ***Business | Excludes         |                  |                  |
| Rules:***   | customer         |                  |                  |
|             | requested due    |                  |                  |
|             | dates greater    |                  |                  |
|             | than the         |                  |                  |
|             | standard         |                  |                  |
|             | interval, and    |                  |                  |
|             | orders delayed   |                  |                  |
|             | for customer     |                  |                  |
|             | reasons.         |                  |                  |
|             |                  |                  |                  |
|             | Excludes         |                  |                  |
|             | services with    |                  |                  |
|             | flexible due     |                  |                  |
|             | date i.e., Basic |                  |                  |
|             | Exchange         |                  |                  |
|             | services/POTS    |                  |                  |
|             |                  |                  |                  |
|             | (PB), and B1/R1  |                  |                  |
|             | Service (GTE)    |                  |                  |
+-------------+------------------+------------------+------------------+
| *           | Incorporation of |                  |                  |
| **Notes:*** | the results for  |                  |                  |
|             | Projects is      |                  |                  |
|             | currently under  |                  |                  |
|             | study by the     |                  |                  |
|             | ILECs. Parties   |                  |                  |
|             | have agreed to   |                  |                  |
|             | study projects   |                  |                  |
|             | for "up to 50    |                  |                  |
|             | lines".          |                  |                  |
|             |                  |                  |                  |
|             | Availability of  |                  |                  |
|             | ILEC Affiliate   |                  |                  |
|             | data for review  |                  |                  |
|             | will be          |                  |                  |
|             | determined by    |                  |                  |
|             | the CPUC.        |                  |                  |
|             |                  |                  |                  |
|             | -   ADSL was     |                  |                  |
|             |     selected as  |                  |                  |
|             |     the analog   |                  |                  |
|             |     for resale   |                  |                  |
|             |     services and |                  |                  |
|             |     UNE DSL      |                  |                  |
|             |     2-wire loop  |                  |                  |
|             |     because it   |                  |                  |
|             |     currently is |                  |                  |
|             |     the most     |                  |                  |
|             |     relevant     |                  |                  |
|             |     analog.      |                  |                  |
+-------------+------------------+------------------+------------------+

***[Provisioning]{.underline}* Measure 11**

***Title:*** Percent of Due Dates Missed

+-------------+------------------+------------------+------------------+
| ***Area***  | ***Requirement   |                  |                  |
|             | Description***   |                  |                  |
+-------------+------------------+------------------+------------------+
| ***Desc     | Measures the     |                  |                  |
| ription:*** | percent of new,  |                  |                  |
|             | move and change  |                  |                  |
|             | orders where     |                  |                  |
|             | installation was |                  |                  |
|             | not completed by |                  |                  |
|             | the due date.    |                  |                  |
+-------------+------------------+------------------+------------------+
| ***Method   | (Total Number of |                  |                  |
| of          | Missed Due Dates |                  |                  |
| Calc        | Due to ILEC      |                  |                  |
| ulation:*** | Reasons for New, |                  |                  |
|             | Move and Change  |                  |                  |
|             | Orders / Total   |                  |                  |
|             | Number of New,   |                  |                  |
|             | Move and Change  |                  |                  |
|             | Orders) x 100    |                  |                  |
+-------------+------------------+------------------+------------------+
| ***Report   | Monthly          |                  |                  |
| Period:***  |                  |                  |                  |
+-------------+------------------+------------------+------------------+
| ***Report   | Individual CLEC, |                  |                  |
| St          | CLECs in the     |                  |                  |
| ructure:*** | aggregate, by    |                  |                  |
|             | ILEC (if analog  |                  |                  |
|             | applies), and by |                  |                  |
|             | ILEC Affiliates  |                  |                  |
+-------------+------------------+------------------+------------------+
| ***Reported | By service group |                  |                  |
| By:***      | type and Field   |                  |                  |
|             | Work/No Field    |                  |                  |
|             | Work as          |                  |                  |
|             | appropriate      |                  |                  |
+-------------+------------------+------------------+------------------+
| **          | Region (PB),     |                  |                  |
| *Geographic | Statewide (GTE)  |                  |                  |
| Level:***   |                  |                  |                  |
+-------------+------------------+------------------+------------------+
| **          | **Parity for     | **Pacific Bell   | **GTE Retail**   |
| *Measurable | Resale is Retail | Retail**         |                  |
| S           | for Pacific Bell |                  | B1 Dispatch      |
| tandard:*** | and GT**E        | POTS - Business  | Non-Designed     |
|             |                  | (fielded)        |                  |
|             | **Parity for UNE |                  | Dispatch         |
|             | measured**       | POTS - Business  | Designed         |
|             |                  | (Assured)        | Services         |
|             | **for the        |                  |                  |
|             | following        | ISDN(BRI)        | Dispatch         |
|             | UNEs:**          |                  | Designed         |
|             |                  | ADSL             | Services         |
|             | 2/4w (8db)       |                  | Dispatch         |
|             | analog loop      | ISDN(PRI)/DS1    | Designed         |
|             |                  |                  | Services         |
|             | (incl.           | POTS - Business  |                  |
|             | Coin/analog PBX) | (fielded)        | Dispatch         |
|             |                  |                  | Designed         |
|             | 2/4w (5.5 db)    | CENTREX          | Services         |
|             | assured analog   |                  |                  |
|             | loop             | CENTREX          | CentraNet        |
|             |                  |                  | --Simple         |
|             | 2w digital       | DS1/ISDN(PRI)    |                  |
|             | loop(ISDN        |                  | CentraNet        |
|             | capable)         | PBX DID          | --Complex        |
|             |                  |                  |                  |
|             | 2w digital       | HICAP            | CentraNet        |
|             | loop(xDSL        |                  | --Complex        |
|             | capable)         | Analogous Retail |                  |
|             |                  | Service          | CentraNet        |
|             | 4w digital loop  |                  | --Complex        |
|             | (1.544Mbps       | ILEC Dedicated   |                  |
|             | capable/HDSL)    | Trunks           | CentraNet        |
|             |                  |                  | --Complex        |
|             | UNE Port--Basic  |                  |                  |
|             | Analog/Coin      |                  | HICAP Designed   |
|             |                  |                  |                  |
|             | UNE              |                  | N/A              |
|             | Port--CENTREX    |                  |                  |
|             |                  |                  | ILEC Dedicated   |
|             | UNE Port--ISDN   |                  | Trunks           |
|             | (BRI)            |                  |                  |
|             |                  |                  |                  |
|             | UNE              |                  |                  |
|             | Po               |                  |                  |
|             | rt--DS1/ISDN-PRI |                  |                  |
|             |                  |                  |                  |
|             | (incl. DS1 line  |                  |                  |
|             | port)            |                  |                  |
|             |                  |                  |                  |
|             | UNE Port--PBX    |                  |                  |
|             | DID              |                  |                  |
|             |                  |                  |                  |
|             | UNE Dedicated    |                  |                  |
|             | Transport        |                  |                  |
|             |                  |                  |                  |
|             | (incl.DS1 and    |                  |                  |
|             | DS3)             |                  |                  |
|             |                  |                  |                  |
|             | UNE Platform (PB |                  |                  |
|             | only)            |                  |                  |
|             |                  |                  |                  |
|             | *                |                  |                  |
|             | *Interconnection |                  |                  |
|             | Trunks**         |                  |                  |
+-------------+------------------+------------------+------------------+
| ***Business | Excludes         |                  |                  |
| Rules:***   | customer misses. |                  |                  |
|             |                  |                  |                  |
|             | Due date is      |                  |                  |
|             | defined as       |                  |                  |
|             | either original  |                  |                  |
|             | due date or      |                  |                  |
|             | final due date   |                  |                  |
|             | if the original  |                  |                  |
|             | due date was     |                  |                  |
|             | missed due to    |                  |                  |
|             | customer         |                  |                  |
|             | reasons.         |                  |                  |
+-------------+------------------+------------------+------------------+
| *           | Availability of  |                  |                  |
| **Notes:*** | ILEC Affiliate   |                  |                  |
|             | data for review  |                  |                  |
|             | will be          |                  |                  |
|             | determined by    |                  |                  |
|             | the CPUC.        |                  |                  |
|             |                  |                  |                  |
|             | When results are |                  |                  |
|             | less than parity |                  |                  |
|             | for a reporting  |                  |                  |
|             | period, ILECs    |                  |                  |
|             | will provide     |                  |                  |
|             | disaggregation   |                  |                  |
|             | by Missed        |                  |                  |
|             | Appointment      |                  |                  |
|             | reason codes as  |                  |                  |
|             | diagnostic data. |                  |                  |
|             |                  |                  |                  |
|             | -   ADSL was     |                  |                  |
|             |     selected as  |                  |                  |
|             |     the analog   |                  |                  |
|             |     for resale   |                  |                  |
|             |     services and |                  |                  |
|             |     UNE DSL      |                  |                  |
|             |     2-wire loop  |                  |                  |
|             |     because it   |                  |                  |
|             |     currently is |                  |                  |
|             |     the most     |                  |                  |
|             |     relevant     |                  |                  |
|             |     analog.      |                  |                  |
+-------------+------------------+------------------+------------------+

# 

***[Provisioning]{.underline}* Measure 13**

# 

# *Title:* Delay Order Interval to Completion Date (For Lack of Facilities)

+--------------+------------------+------------------+------------------+
| ***Area***   | ***Requirement   |                  |                  |
|              | Description***   |                  |                  |
+--------------+------------------+------------------+------------------+
| ***Des       | Measures the     |                  |                  |
| cription:*** | average calendar |                  |                  |
|              | days from due    |                  |                  |
|              | date to          |                  |                  |
|              | completion date  |                  |                  |
|              | on company       |                  |                  |
|              | missed orders    |                  |                  |
|              | due to lack of   |                  |                  |
|              | ILEC facilities. |                  |                  |
+--------------+------------------+------------------+------------------+
| ***Method of | Sum (Completion  |                  |                  |
| Cal          | Date --          |                  |                  |
| culation:*** | Committed Order  |                  |                  |
|              | Due Date (for    |                  |                  |
|              | orders missed    |                  |                  |
|              | due to lack of   |                  |                  |
|              | ILEC             |                  |                  |
|              | facilities)) /   |                  |                  |
|              | (Number of       |                  |                  |
|              | Orders Missed    |                  |                  |
|              | due to Lack of   |                  |                  |
|              | ILEC Facilities  |                  |                  |
|              | in the Reporting |                  |                  |
|              | Period)          |                  |                  |
+--------------+------------------+------------------+------------------+
| ***Report    | Monthly          |                  |                  |
| Period:***   |                  |                  |                  |
+--------------+------------------+------------------+------------------+
| ***Report    | Individual CLEC, |                  |                  |
| S            | CLECs in the     |                  |                  |
| tructure:*** | aggregate, by    |                  |                  |
|              | ILEC (if analog  |                  |                  |
|              | applies), and by |                  |                  |
|              | ILEC Affiliates  |                  |                  |
+--------------+------------------+------------------+------------------+
| ***Reported  | By service group |                  |                  |
| By:***       | type             |                  |                  |
|              |                  |                  |                  |
|              | Disaggregated by |                  |                  |
|              | 1-30 days, 31-90 |                  |                  |
|              | days and \>90    |                  |                  |
|              | days             |                  |                  |
+--------------+------------------+------------------+------------------+
| *            | Statewide        |                  |                  |
| **Geographic |                  |                  |                  |
| Level:***    |                  |                  |                  |
+--------------+------------------+------------------+------------------+
| *            | **Parity for     | **Pacific Bell   | **GTE Retail**   |
| **Measurable | Resale is Retail | Retail**         |                  |
| Standard:*** | for Pacific Bell |                  | B1 Dispatch      |
|              | and GTE**        | POTS - Business  | Non-Designed     |
|              |                  | (fielded)        |                  |
|              | **Parity for UNE |                  | Dispatch         |
|              | measured**       | POTS - Business  | Designed         |
|              |                  | (Assured)        | Services         |
|              | **for the        |                  |                  |
|              | following        | ISDN(BRI)        | Dispatch         |
|              | UNEs:**          |                  | Designed         |
|              |                  | ADSL             | Services         |
|              | 2/4w (8db)       |                  | Dispatch         |
|              | analog loop      | ISDN(PRI)/DS1    | Designed         |
|              |                  |                  | Services         |
|              | (incl.           | HICAP            |                  |
|              | Coin/analog PBX) |                  | Dispatch         |
|              |                  | Analogous Retail | Designed         |
|              | 2/4w (5.5 db)    | Service          | Services         |
|              | assured analog   |                  |                  |
|              | loop             | ILEC Dedicated   | HICAP Designed   |
|              |                  | Trunks           |                  |
|              | 2w digital       |                  | N/A              |
|              | loop(ISDN        |                  |                  |
|              | capable)         |                  | ILEC Dedicated   |
|              |                  |                  | Trunks           |
|              | 2w digital       |                  |                  |
|              | loop(xDSL        |                  |                  |
|              | capable)         |                  |                  |
|              |                  |                  |                  |
|              | 4w digital loop  |                  |                  |
|              | (1.544MBPS       |                  |                  |
|              | capable/HDSL)    |                  |                  |
|              |                  |                  |                  |
|              | UNE Dedicated    |                  |                  |
|              | Transport        |                  |                  |
|              |                  |                  |                  |
|              | UNE Platform     |                  |                  |
|              |                  |                  |                  |
|              | *                |                  |                  |
|              | *Interconnection |                  |                  |
|              | Trunks**         |                  |                  |
+--------------+------------------+------------------+------------------+
| ***Business  |                  |                  |                  |
| Rules:***    |                  |                  |                  |
+--------------+------------------+------------------+------------------+
| ***Notes:*** | Availability of  |                  |                  |
|              | ILEC Affiliate   |                  |                  |
|              | data for review  |                  |                  |
|              | will be          |                  |                  |
|              | determined by    |                  |                  |
|              | the CPUC.        |                  |                  |
|              |                  |                  |                  |
|              | -   ADSL was     |                  |                  |
|              |     selected as  |                  |                  |
|              |     the analog   |                  |                  |
|              |     for resale   |                  |                  |
|              |     services and |                  |                  |
|              |     UNE DSL      |                  |                  |
|              |     2-wire loop  |                  |                  |
|              |     because it   |                  |                  |
|              |     currently is |                  |                  |
|              |     the most     |                  |                  |
|              |     relevant     |                  |                  |
|              |     analog.      |                  |                  |
+--------------+------------------+------------------+------------------+

***[Provisioning]{.underline}* Measure 16**

***Title:*** Percentage Troubles in 30 Days for New Orders

+-------------+------------------+------------------+------------------+
| ***Area***  | ***Requirement   |                  |                  |
|             | Description***   |                  |                  |
+-------------+------------------+------------------+------------------+
| ***Desc     | Measures the     |                  |                  |
| ription:*** | percent of       |                  |                  |
|             | network customer |                  |                  |
|             | trouble reports  |                  |                  |
|             | received within  |                  |                  |
|             | 30 calendar days |                  |                  |
|             | of service order |                  |                  |
|             | completion.      |                  |                  |
|             |                  |                  |                  |
|             | *Note: This      |                  |                  |
|             | measure is for   |                  |                  |
|             | all PB services  |                  |                  |
|             | and designed GTE |                  |                  |
|             | services.*       |                  |                  |
+-------------+------------------+------------------+------------------+
| ***Method   | (Total Number of |                  |                  |
| of          | Customer Trouble |                  |                  |
| Calc        | reports received |                  |                  |
| ulation:*** | within 30        |                  |                  |
|             | calendar days of |                  |                  |
|             | service order    |                  |                  |
|             | completion /     |                  |                  |
|             | Total Number of  |                  |                  |
|             | new, move and    |                  |                  |
|             | change completed |                  |                  |
|             | orders) x 100    |                  |                  |
+-------------+------------------+------------------+------------------+
| ***Report   | Monthly          |                  |                  |
| Period:***  |                  |                  |                  |
+-------------+------------------+------------------+------------------+
| ***Report   | Individual CLEC, |                  |                  |
| St          | CLECs in the     |                  |                  |
| ructure:*** | aggregate, by    |                  |                  |
|             | ILEC (if analog  |                  |                  |
|             | applies), and by |                  |                  |
|             | ILEC Affiliates  |                  |                  |
+-------------+------------------+------------------+------------------+
| ***Reported | By service group |                  |                  |
| By:***      | type (including  |                  |                  |
|             | PNP)             |                  |                  |
+-------------+------------------+------------------+------------------+
| **          | Region (PB),     |                  |                  |
| *Geographic | Statewide (GTE)  |                  |                  |
| Level:***   |                  |                  |                  |
+-------------+------------------+------------------+------------------+
| **          | **Parity for     | **Pacific Bell   | **GTE Retail**   |
| *Measurable | Resale is Retail | Retail**         |                  |
| S           | for Pacific Bell |                  | B1 Dispatch      |
| tandard:*** | and GTE**        | POTS -- Business | Non-Designed     |
|             |                  | (fielded)        |                  |
|             | **Parity for UNE |                  | Dispatch         |
|             | measured**       | POTS -- Business | Designed         |
|             |                  | (Assured)        | Services         |
|             | **for the        |                  |                  |
|             | following        | ISDN(BRI)        | Dispatch         |
|             | UNEs:**          |                  | Designed         |
|             |                  | ADSL             | Services         |
|             | 2/4w (8db)       |                  | Dispatch         |
|             | analog loop      | ISDN(PRI)/DS1    | Designed         |
|             |                  |                  | Services         |
|             | (incl.           | POTS -- Business |                  |
|             | Coin/analog PBX) | (fielded)        | Dispatch         |
|             |                  |                  | Designed         |
|             | 2/4w (5.5 db)    | CENTREX          | Services         |
|             | assured analog   |                  |                  |
|             | loop             | CENTREX          | CentraNet        |
|             |                  |                  | --Simple         |
|             | 2w digital       | DS1/ISDN(PRI)    |                  |
|             | loop(ISDN        |                  | CentraNet        |
|             | capable)         | PBX DID          | --Complex        |
|             |                  |                  |                  |
|             | 2w digital       | HICAP            | CentraNet        |
|             | loop(xDSL        |                  | --Complex        |
|             | capable)         | Analogous Retail |                  |
|             |                  | Service          | CentraNet        |
|             | 4w digital loop  |                  | --Complex        |
|             | (1.544Mbps       | ILEC Dedicated   |                  |
|             | capable/HDSL)    | Trunks           | CentraNet        |
|             |                  |                  | --Complex        |
|             | UNE Port--Basic  | **(Issue still   |                  |
|             | Analog/Coin      | to be            | HICAP Designed   |
|             |                  | resolved)**      |                  |
|             | UNE              |                  | N/A              |
|             | Port--CENTREX    |                  |                  |
|             |                  |                  | ILEC Dedicated   |
|             | UNE Port--ISDN   |                  | Trunks           |
|             | (BRI)            |                  |                  |
|             |                  |                  | **(Issue still   |
|             | UNE              |                  | to be            |
|             | Po               |                  | resolved)**      |
|             | rt--DS1/ISDN-PRI |                  |                  |
|             |                  |                  |                  |
|             | (incl. DS1 line  |                  |                  |
|             | port)            |                  |                  |
|             |                  |                  |                  |
|             | UNE Port--PBX    |                  |                  |
|             | DID              |                  |                  |
|             |                  |                  |                  |
|             | UNE Dedicated    |                  |                  |
|             | Transport        |                  |                  |
|             |                  |                  |                  |
|             | (incl. DS1 and   |                  |                  |
|             | DS3)             |                  |                  |
|             |                  |                  |                  |
|             | UNE Platform (PB |                  |                  |
|             | only)            |                  |                  |
|             |                  |                  |                  |
|             | *                |                  |                  |
|             | *Interconnection |                  |                  |
|             | Trunks**         |                  |                  |
|             |                  |                  |                  |
|             | **PNP (Port      |                  |                  |
|             | out)**           |                  |                  |
+-------------+------------------+------------------+------------------+
| ***Business | Excludes CPE and |                  |                  |
| Rules:***   | IEC/CLEC caused  |                  |                  |
|             | troubles.        |                  |                  |
|             |                  |                  |                  |
|             | Excludes         |                  |                  |
|             | troubles         |                  |                  |
|             | associated with  |                  |                  |
|             | inside wire.     |                  |                  |
|             |                  |                  |                  |
|             | Excludes Trouble |                  |                  |
|             | Reports Received |                  |                  |
|             | on the Due Date  |                  |                  |
|             | (which instead   |                  |                  |
|             | are reported in  |                  |                  |
|             | the              |                  |                  |
|             | "Provisioning    |                  |                  |
|             | Troubles"        |                  |                  |
|             | measure).        |                  |                  |
|             |                  |                  |                  |
|             | Excludes         |                  |                  |
|             | Subsequent       |                  |                  |
|             | reports.         |                  |                  |
|             |                  |                  |                  |
|             | Excludes Message |                  |                  |
|             | Reports (circuit |                  |                  |
|             | reports for      |                  |                  |
|             | which ILEC has   |                  |                  |
|             | no records).     |                  |                  |
|             |                  |                  |                  |
|             | Excludes ILEC    |                  |                  |
|             | employee         |                  |                  |
|             | generated        |                  |                  |
|             | reports.         |                  |                  |
+-------------+------------------+------------------+------------------+

+-------------+--------------------------------------------------------+
| *           | Availability of ILEC Affiliate data for review will be |
| **Notes:*** | determined by the                                      |
|             |                                                        |
|             | CPUC.                                                  |
|             |                                                        |
|             | When results are less than parity for a reporting      |
|             | period, ILECs will provide disaggregation by           |
|             | Maintenance Disposition codes as diagnostic data.      |
|             |                                                        |
|             | -   ADSL was selected as the analog for resale         |
|             |     services and UNE DSL 2-wire loop because it        |
|             |     currently is the most relevant analog.             |
|             |                                                        |
|             | ```{=html}                                             |
|             | <!-- -->                                               |
|             | ```                                                    |
|             | -   The parties will work to define measurable         |
|             |     standard for PNP results. Recommendation will be   |
|             |     submitted to CPUC by July 1, 1999.                 |
+-------------+--------------------------------------------------------+