+-------------------+--------------------------------------------------+
| yaUºesaº          | **sËInar ³CanabaIna krnao vaalao´**              |
| iDpaT-maoMT       |                                                  |
|                   | **tqaa Anya**                                    |
| Aa\^f             |                                                  |
| T/aMsapaoTo-Sana  | **isa@yauirTI AiQakairyaaoM ko ilayao            |
|                   | maaga-dSa-na**                                   |
| **foDrla          |                                                  |
| eivaeSana**       |                                                  |
|                   |                                                  |
| **e               |                                                  |
| DimainasT/oSana** |                                                  |
+-------------------+--------------------------------------------------+

**paT---- 108 eyarËaFT Aa\^proTsa- tqaa paT- 129 eyar kOiryar
Aa\^proTsa- ko saBaI inayaimat AaOr ka\^nTo/@T pr kaya- krnao vaalao
kma-caairyaaoM tqaa Anya saBaI saurxaa AiQakairyaaoM¸ jaao ik
yaai\~yaaoM tqaa \]nakI phÐuca ko Andr AanaovaalaI sampi\<a kI sËIinaMga
krto hOM yaa \]saka inarIxaNa krto hOM¸ ko maaga-dSa-na hotu
inamnailai#at jaanakarI dI jaa rhI hO ³jaOsao ik sËInasa- AaOr sËInar
sauprvaayajar´. \[samaoM vao AiQakarI BaI Saaimala hOMÊ jaao eyarpaoT-
sauivaQaaAaoM pr isa@yauirTI D\\yaUTI ko ilayao saIQao ijammaodar hOM
tqaa ijanaka sampk- yaai\~yaaoM sao saIQaoo haota hOM³jaOsao ik
pOsaonjar saiva-sa psaao-naolaÊ laaokla sToSana maOnaojarÊ eyarpaoT-
AaproTr tqaa LEO´Ê prntu yah kovala \]na tk hI saIimat nahIM hO.**

**[pRYzBaUimaÁ]{.underline}** 11 isatmbar 2001 kI duÁ#ad GaTnaaAaoM ko
baad \]na laaogaaoM kao jaao id#anao maoM ArbaÊ maQyapUva- yaa dixaNa
eiSayaa\[- maUla ko AaOrÀyaa mausalamaana lagato hOM yaa vaastva maoM
\[namaoM sao iksaI maUla ko hOMÊ kao Dranao yaa tMga krnao kI GaTnaaAaoM
pr icanta baZ,I hO. yahaÐ yah daohranaa punaÁ AavaSyak hO ik
saMvaodnaSaIla D\\yaUTI inaBaato samaya AiQakarI Wara eosaa Baraosaa
krnaa galat haogaa ik AamaÊ ek jaOsao id#anaoo yaa AadtaoM ko karNaÊ yaa
\]nakI AasqaaÊ iksaI BaI jaaitÊ saByataÊ Qaaima-k yaa maUla raYT/ ko
haonao ko karNa iksaI vyai@t kI p\`vaRi\<a AvaOQaainak kaya- krnao kI
haogaI. ivaSaoYa taOr pr eyarpaoT- AaOr eyar kOiryar ko AiQakairyaaoM
Wara isa#aaoM tqaa Arba Amaoirkna laaogaaoM ko saaqa AnauicatÊ
AsaMvaodnaSaIla ZMga sao jaaÐca­pD,tala krnao ko maamalao \]Bar kr Aayao
hOM. hmaoM yah Qyaana r#anaa hO ik yaa\~a krnao vaalaI janata kI saurxaa
ko ilayaoÊ yaUºesaº ko kanaUna ko tht ApnaI saurxaa kaya-vaaihyaaoM maoM
ApnaI BaUimaka kao inaBaanaa AaOr ApnaI janata ko naagairk AiQakaraoM
tqaa saMivaQaana kI rxaa krnao ko hmaaro daiya%va ko baIca Tkrava nahIM
haonaa caaihyao. iksaI ko saaqa jaaitÊ rMgaÊ raYTI/ya maUlaÊ Qama-Ê
ilaMga yaa pUva-jaaoM ko AaQaar pr iksaI BaI eyar kOiryar yaa \]sako
kma-caarI Wara BaodBaava krnaa fODrla kanaUna maoM AvaOQaainak hO.

**[GaTnaaAaoM tqaa kaya-vaaihyaaoM ko \]dahrNaÁ]{.underline}** iksaI BaI
saurxaa yaa isa@yauirTI ko ilayao #atra banao vyai@t yaa sampi\<a kao
phcaananao maoM saBaI \]plabQa saccaa\[\`-yaaoM AaOr pirisqaityaaoM kao
AaQaar banaanaa AavaSyak hO. halaaÐik kaya-vaahI kBaI­kBaI iksaI vyai@t
kao tMga krnao vaalaI lagatI haogaIÊ prntu kuC pirisqaityaaoM maoM
saurxaa AiQakairyaaoM Wara Aitir@t savaala pUCnaaÊ jaaÐca yaa CanabaIna
krnaa naIcao idyao saurxaa karNaaoM kI vajah sao nyaayasaMgat zhrayao
jaa sakto hMO. saurxaa AiQakarI kI ApnaI kaya-vaaihyaaÐ nyaayasaMgat hO
yaa nahIM yah tya krnao ko ilayao \]sao \'baTÀf\^ar\' ³AgarÀtao ´ vaalaI
prIxaa ko ZMga kI madd laonaa caaihyao.\' Agar \[sa vyai@t kI jaaitÊ
vaMSa prMpraÊ yaa Qaaima-k Jaukava kuC AaOr haotIÊ tao \@yaa maMO \[sa
vyai@t kao Aitir@t saurxaa yaa isa@yauirTI sËIinaMga ko ilae baaQya krta
Æ \' yaid \[saka \]saka \]\<ar \"naa\" maoM hao tao kI jaanao vaalaI
kaya-vaahI nyaayasaMgat nahIM hO tqaa naagairk AiQakaraoM ka \]llaGaMna
krtI hO.

**[GaTnaa naM. 1Á]{.underline}** maOTla iDTo@Tr sao saflatapUva-k
gaujarnao ko baad BaI saurxaa AiQakarI Wara ek isa#a vyai@t kaoÊ sabako
saamanao ApnaI pgaD,I hTanao ka AaOr \]sako koSaaoM kao #aaola kr
inarIxaNa krvaanao ko ilayao AadoSa idyaa gayaa.

**[kaya-vaahIÁ]{.underline}** isa#a laaoga ApnaI pgaD,IÊ jaao SarIr ko
Ait inajaI AaOr vyai@tgat AMga kao ZktI hOÊ kao \[-Svar ko saaqa sampk-
ka mah%vapUNa- ihssaa maanato hOMÊ tqaa \[saI p\`kar pgaD,I ka \]taro
jaanaa ek Ait AitËmaNa vaalaa AklpnaIya kaya- maanaa jaata hO. isa#a kI
pgaD,I ek TaopI ko samaana nahIM haotI hOÊ vah kpDo, ka ek lambaa saa
TukD,a haota hO jaao k\[- gaja lambaa haota hOÊ tqaa punaÁ baaÐQanao
maoM kafI samaya lagata hO. saurxaa AiQakarI ka AnauraoQa ekdma
AavaMaiCt qaa \@yaaoMik vyai@t ko jaaÐca maoM sao gaujarnao pr maOTla
iDTo@Tr ka Alaama- nahI bajaa AaOr dUsara eosaa kao\[- karNa yaa
samauicat saMdoh nahIM qaa ijasako ilayao eosaI kaya-vaahI kI jaatI. AtÁ
isa#a sao ApnaI pgaD,I kao ³yaa \[saI p\`kar Qaaima-k \$p sao AavaSyak¸
ibanaa kTo koSaaoM kao #aaolanaa´ hTanao ko ilayao khnaa jabaik Anya
saBaI yaai\~yaaoM ijanhaoMnao maOTla iDTo@Tr kao saflatapUva-k par
ikyaaÊ \]namaoM sao iksaI sao BaI jaaÐca ko ilayao vas\~aMo kao hTanao
ko ilayao na kha gayaa hao tao yah Asamaana vyavahar hO AaOr \[sao
AvaSya band krnaa hO. yaid saurxaa AaOr isa@yauirTI karNaaoM sao ifr BaI
jaaÐca va inarIxaNa AavaSyak hao ³jaOsao ik isa#a vyai@t kI jaaÐca maoM
maOTla iDTo@Tr ka Alaama- bajata hO AaOr haqa vaalao maOTla iDTo@Tr sao
Aitir@t isa@yauirTI sËIinaMga yaa haqa sao qapqapa kr kI jaanao vaalaI
jaaÐca \[sa baat kao isaw krnao maoM Asamaqa- hO ik kao\[- inaiYaw vastu
lao jaayaI jaa rhI hO´ tao eosao maoM isa#a kao ekant maoM yaa sabako
saamanao jaaÐca kranao ko baIca caunaava krnao ka Avasar donaa caaiheÊ
\@yaaoMik saava-jainak CanabaIna Apmaanajanak tqaa naIcaa id#aanao
jaOsaI lagatI hO Aqavaa vyai@t kI Qaaima-k Aasqaa ka \]llaMGana kr saktI
hO.

**[GaTnaa naM. 2Á]{.underline}** ek s\~I kovala \[sailayao caunaI jaatI
hO \@yaaoMik \]sako baala Zko hOM yaa vah bauka- phnao hO yaa pu\$Ya
kovala \[sailayao caunaa jaata hO \@yaaoMik \]sako lambaI daZ,I hO yaa
vah baalaaoM kao Zko hO.

**[kaya-vaahIÁ]{.underline}** Qama- yaa raYT/Iya maUla ko AaQaar pr
BaodBaava maoM yah BaodBaava BaI saimmailat hO ik ijasaka AaQaar kovala
\]sa vyai@t ka phnaavaa yaa id#aavaa iksaI ivaiSaYT raYT/Iya maUla yaa
Qama- sao jauD,a hao. \[saI p\`karÊ caunaava kovala \[sailayao na hao
\@yaaoMik vyai@t ArbaIÊ farsaI yaa Anya ivadoSaI BaaYaa baaola sakta hO
yaa kovala \[sailayao hao ik \]nakI baaolacaala ka lahjaa iksaI kao yah
ivaSvaasa idlaayao ik vao ArbaÊ maQya pUva-Ê dixaNa eiSayaa\[- AaOrÀyaa
mausalamaana hMO. \[sa karNa yao trIko nahIM Apnaanaa caaihyao.

**[GaTnaa naM. 3Á]{.underline}** ek bauko- vaalaI s\~I ApnaI phcaana ko
ilayao faoTao phcaana p\~ id#aatI hO prntu sËIinaMga krnao vaalaa yah
inaiScat nahI kr pata ik yah s\~I vahI hO jaao faoTao maoM hOÊ \@yaaoMik
bauka- caohro ka AiQakaMSa Baaga Zko huyao hO. \]sao ek maihlaa AiQakarI
Wara nama\`ta sao bauka- \]tarnao ko ilayao kha jaata hO tqaa \]sao
ekant maoM Aqavaa sabako saamanao jaaÐca ko baIca caunaava ka maaOka
idyaa jaata hOÊ prntu \]sao yah Apmaana lagata hO. vah s\~I batatI hO ik
bauka- hTanaa \]sako Qaaima-k AiQakaraoM ka hnana hO.

**[kaya-vaahIÁ]{.underline}** caUÐik vyai@t kI phcaana kI puiYT krnaa
\]na samaana pirisqaityaaoM maoM AaOr saBaI yaai\~yaaoM ko ilayao
isa@yauirTI kI AavaSyakta hO tqaa caÐUik iksaI Anya p\`kar sao
isa@yauirTI kI yah AavaSyakta pUrI nahIM hao saktI AtÁ vah kaya-vaahI
nyaayasaMgat hO. jaba BaI samBava hao bauko-vaalaI s\~I kI jaaÐca­pD,tala
ekant maoM Aqavaa kovala iksaI maihlaa AiQakarI kI \]pisqait maoM hao
taik \]sakI Qaaima-k maanyataAaoM ka hnana na hao.

**[GaTnaa naM. 4Á]{.underline}** ek raojamara- ko sTa\^p pr Ktrnaak
pdaqaao-M sao Baro T/k ka D/ayavar Apnao yaunaayaToD sToT\\sa maoM janma
haonao kI phcaana tao id#aata hOÊ prntu vah AMga\`ojaI ibalakula nahIM
baaola pata hO AaOr eosaa lagata hO ik \]sao isaf- ArbaI AatI hO.

**[kaya-vaahIÁ]{.underline}** \[sa GaTnaa maoM isa@yauirTI AiQakarI ko
pasa Sak ka karNa hO AaOr \]sakI Aitir@t jaaÐca AaOr CanabaIna \[%yaaid
krnaa nyaayasaMgat zhrayaa jaa sakta hO. ³halaaÐik yahaÐ yah BaI Qyaana
r#anaa hO ik iksaI Kasa lahjao maoM AMga\`ojaI na baaola panao yaa
ATk­ATk kr AMga\`ojaI baaolanao kao eosaa nahIM kha jaa sakta hO ik \]sao
AMga\`ojaI baaolanaa nahIM Aata hO´

**[GaTnaa naM. 5Á]{.underline}** ek vyai@t jaao ik pgaD,I yaa isar pr
kpD,a baaÐQao hOÊ caok pa\^\[nT pr jaaÐca ko samaya \]sako isar ko pasa
maOTla iDTo@Tr Alaama- bajaa dota hOÊ AaOr Alaama- ka karNa pta krnao ko
ilayao dUsarI FAA Wara svaIkaya- ZMga ³yaaina haqa sao qapqapa kr kI
ga\[- jaaÐca´ sao pta krnao ko baad AaOr AiQak jaaÐca ko ilayao vyai@t
sao pgaD,I \]tarnao kao kha jaata hO.

**[kaya-vaahIÁ]{.underline}** caUÐik saBaI laaogaaoM kI yah sËIinaMga kI
jaatI hO AaOr sËInaraoM ko ilayao yah AavaSyak hO ik p\`%yaok Alaama- ka
samaaQaana \]nakI santuiYT ko hd tk haonaa caaihyaoÊ \]sako baad hI
vyai@t kao saurixat xao\~ maoM jaanao doM. isa@yauirTI AiQakarI Wara
nama\`ta sao pgaD,I \]tarnao ka AnauraoQa krnaa jaba ik vyai@t ko saaqa
sammaanapUNa- vyavahar hao rha hO tqaa \]sao Akolao maoM yaa sabako
saamanao jaaÐca kranao ko baIca caunaava ka Avasar idyaa jaa rha hO tao
vah kaya-vaahI nyaayasaMgat haogaI. isa@yauirTI AiQakarI Aama janata kao
id#aayaI na donao vaalao sqaana maoM yaa ekant sqaana maoM \]sa vyai@t
kao pgaD,I baaÐQanao ka Avasar dogaa. yaid samBava hao tao¸ SaISaa BaI
idyaa jaayaogaa.

**[GaTnaa naM. 6Á]{.underline}** ek isa#a vyai@t kao prMpragat \$p sao
r#aI jaanao vaalaI tlavaar yaa *kRpaNa* ko saaqa payaa jaata hO AaOr
isa@yauirTI AiQakarI Wara \]sao sammaanapUva-k batayaa jaata hO ik FAA
ko inayama iknhI BaI Qaardar vastuAaoM yaa caakU kao ivamaana maoM saaqa
lao jaanao sao inaiYaw krta hO AaOr AiQakarI batata hO ik \]sao Apnao
caok ikyao baOgaoja maoM kRpaNa r#anao kI \[jaajat hO.

**[kaya-vaahIÁ]{.underline}** isa@yauirTI AiQakarI Wara kI ga\[-
kaya-vaahI \]icat hO. kvaca ko saaqa prMpra ko \$p maoM isa#aaooM Wara
phnao jaanao vaalaI tlavaar jaao *kRpaNa* ko \$p maoM jaanaI jaatI hOÊ
Qaaima-k ivaSvaasa kI Ainavaaya- vastu hO. kRpaNa p\`ayaÁ dao sao caar
\[Mca lambaI haotI hO. yaid kRpaNa kao caok ikyao huyao baOgaoja maoM
nahIM r#aa jaa sakta hO Aqavaa \]nako samaUh maoM iksaI eosao vyai@t
Wara ÌpaNa kao eyarpaoT- ko baahr nahIM lao jaayaa jaa sakta hao jaao
saurixat xao\~ maoM nahI jaa rha hOÊ tao kRpaNa kao AvaSya hI jabt krnaa
caaihyao. ³naaoTÁ CaoTI kRpaNa kao naoklaosa ko samaana galao maoM phnaa
jaa sakta hO . caaho \]sao XarIr ko iksaI BaI AMga pr \@yaaoM na phnaa
jaae pr yaid vah caakU ko samaana id#aa\[- dotI haoÊ jaOsao ik \]samaoM
Qaardar blaoD hO tao \]sao caok ikyao baOgaoja maoM r#aa jaa sakta hO¸
laoikna sËIinaMga pa\^\[nT ko Aagao ÌpaNa kao nahIM lao jaayaa jaa
sakta´. jaba tk \]sao vaapsa nahIM ilayaa jaata tba tk kRpaNa kao
isa@yauirTI AiQakairyaaoM Wara \]sao saurixat sqaana pr r#aa jaanaa
caaihyao. AiQakaMSa isa#a Aba FAA kI \]sa AavaSyakta sao Avagat hO ik
vaayauyaana maoM caakU AaOr Qaardar hiqayaaraoM kao caok ikyao huyao
saamaana ko Andr r#a kr lao jaayaa jaa sakta hO prntu saaqa maoM nahIM.