Video Quality Experts Group

May 7 -- 11, 2007

Paris, France

Draft Participants List

  --------------------------- -------------------------- -----------------
  **Aygen**                   **Arman**                  **Genista**

  **Bourret**                 **Alex**                   **BT**

  **Brunnström**              **Kjell**                  **Acreo**

  **Dhondt**                  **Yves**                   **Ghent Univ.**

  **Ferguson**                **Kevin**                  **Tektronix**

  **Ford**                    **Carolyn**                **NTIA/ITS**

  **Horita**                  **Yuukou**                 **Toyama Univ.**

  **Huynh-Thu**               **Quan**                   **Psytechnics**

  **Juric**                   **Pero**                   **SwissQual**

  **Kurita**                  **Takaaki**                **NTT**

  **Le Callet**               **Patrick**                **IRCCyN**

  **Lee**                     **Chulhee**                **Yonsei Univ.**

  **Miyamoto**                **Yoshihiro**              **NEC**

  **Okamoto**                 **Jun**                    **NTT**

  **Pinson**                  **Margaret**               **NTIA/ITS**

  **Sazzad**                  **Z.M.Parvez**             **Toyama Univ.**

  **Schmidmer**               **Christian**              **Opticom**

  **Sugimoto**                **Osamu**                  **KDDI R&D**

  **Takahashi**               **Akira**                  **NTT**

  **Watanabe**                **Keishiro**               **NTT**

  **Webster**                 **Arthur**                 **NTIA/ITS**

  **Winkler**                 **Stefan**                 **Genista**

  **Yamada**                  **Toru**                   **NEC**

  **Corriveau (phone)**       **Phil**                   **INTEL**
  --------------------------- -------------------------- -----------------

### Agenda

**Video Quality Experts Group**

**May 7-11, 2007 - Meeting**

**Paris, France**

**www.vqeg.org**

(Note: The ITU-T JRG-MMQA met coincident with the Multimedia Sessions of
the VQEG Meeting)

**Draft Agenda**

**Monday, September 25**

8:00 Start / Designate Note Taker (Webster/Speranza)

Introductions

Meeting Logistics

Updates (Maximum 15 minutes - each Group)

Independent Lab Group (ILG)(Brunnstrom)

RRNR-TV (Bourret/ Lee)

Multimedia (Brunnstrom)

HDTV (Pinson)

Tools and Subjective Labs Setup Group (Le Callet)

POC for Source and HRC Sequence collection (Lee)

10:00 Begin MM/JRG-MMQA

11:30-1:00 Lunch

1:00 MM and JRG-MMQA

5:00 End of Day

**Tuesday, May 8**

8:00 Start / Designate Note Taker

Review Monday's Decisions (Webster/Speranza)

MM Continues

5:00 End of Day

**Wednesday, May 9**

8:00 Start / Designate Note Taker

Review Tuesday's Decisions (Webster/ Speranza)

Review MM Decisions

RRNR-TV Discussion

Final Review of RRNR-TV Decisions

5:00 End of Day

**Thursday, May 10**

8:00 Start / Designate Note Taker

Review Wednesday's Decisions (Webster/Corriveau)

11:30-1:00 Lunch

1:00 -- 5:00 HDTV -- Continued

5:00 End of Day

**Friday May 11**

8:00 Start / Designate Note Taker

Review Thursday's Decisions (Webster/Corriveau)

Final Review of HDTV decisions (if needed)

10:00 Review and Documentation of VQEG Decisions

Review action items

11:00 Other Business

Next Meeting

11:30-1:00 Lunch

1:00-3:00 Write Liaison statements to ITU etc.

3:00 Close VQEG meeting

# VQEG meeting minutes - Monday 7 May 2007 

## Introduction of meeting attendees

Agenda and logistics review (Monday lunch hosted and Wednesday dinner
hosted by KDDI).

Updates from the different ad-hoc groups:

-   ILG: KB said he would wait for more info to come in from FS, GC and
    PC.

    -   

-   RRNR-TV:

    -   

-   MM:

    -   

-   HDTV:

    -   

-   Tools and subjective lab set-up:

    -   

-   SRCs:

    -   

Decision:

## MM discussion

### Subjective testing display

### Data analysis

[Decision reached]{.underline}: For each proponent subjective test, no
more than 50% of test sequences may be derived from a single proponent.
This does not apply to PVSs created by the ILG or to common sequences.

**De-interlacing:**

Proposal from ILG: Modify section 6.1.4 to allow other de-interlacing
mechanisms, e.g., proprietary algorithms and hardware de-interlacing.

[Agreement reached to modify Section 6.1.4 to]{.underline}:

De-interlacing will be performed when original material is interlaced,
using the de-interlacing function "KernelDeint" in Avisynth. If the
deinterlacing using KernelDeint results in source sequence that has
serious artifacts, the Blendfield or Autodeint may be used as
alternative

**Tuesday notes VQEG Tokyo May 8, 2007**

**Thanks to M.Pinson for taking Tuesday notes**

**Filippo's MM ILG update**