*{Use this Shell for P01s for Jan 2009 NCAB round and after) {Keep ONLY
headings needed for application, indicating Project(s) or Core(s) with
issues; otherwise, delete}*

**BIOHAZARD**

**BUDGETARY OVERLAP**

**CHIMPANZEES**

**COMMITTEE BUDGET RECOMMENDATIONS**

**FOREIGN INSTITUTION**

**INCLUSION OF CHILDREN PLAN UNACCEPTABLE**

**INCLUSION OF MINORITIES PLAN UNACCEPTABLE**

**INCLUSION OF WOMEN PLAN UNACCEPTABLE**

**PROTECTION OF HUMAN SUBJECTS UNACCEPTABLE**

**REVISED**

**SCIENTIFIC REVIEW OFFICER\'S NOTES**

**VERTEBRATE ANIMAL CONCERN**

**RESUME AND SUMMARY OF DISCUSSION:** {Begin text here}

.

**TABLE OF CONTENTS**

*{delete headings needed for application}*

[**DESCRIPTION 3**](#__RefHeading___Toc162327801)

[OVERALL PROGRAM CRITIQUE 3](#__RefHeading___Toc162327802)

[PROGRESS DURING THE CURRENT FUNDING PERIOD
3](#__RefHeading___Toc162327803)

[PROGRAM LEADERSHIP 3](#__RefHeading___Toc162327804)

[PROGRAM AS AN INTEGRATED EFFORT 3](#__RefHeading___Toc162327805)

[PROJECT AND CORE SUMMARIES OF DISCUSSION
3](#__RefHeading___Toc162327806)

[HUMAN SUBJECTS (Resume) 3](#refheading___toc162327809)

[VERTEBRATE ANIMALS (Resume) 3](#__RefHeading___Toc162327810)

BIOHAZARD
COMMENT................................................................................................\...\...

[BUDGETARY OVERLAP 3](#__RefHeading___Toc162327808)

[COLLABORATING INSTITUTIONS 3](#__RefHeading___Toc162327807)

[FOREIGN INSTITUTION 4](#__RefHeading___Toc162327811)

[REVISION NOTE 4](#__RefHeading___Toc162327812)

[**SCIENTIFIC REVIEW OFFICER'S NOTES**
............................................................................4](#__RefHeading___Toc162327813)

INDIVIDUAL PROJECTS AND CORES

[PROJECT 1: Title of Project 5](#project-1-title-of-project)

[PROJECT 2: Title of Project 5](#project-2-title-of-project)

[PROJECT 3: Title of Project 6](#project-3-title-of-project)

[PROJECT 4: Title of Project 7](#project-4-title-of-project)

[CORE A: Core Title 8](#core-a-core-title)

[CORE B: Core Title 9](#core-b-core-title)

[CORE C: Core Title 10](#core-c-core-title)

[COMMITTEE BUDGET RECOMMENDATIONS 12](#committee-budget-recommendations)

**SPECIAL EMPHASIS PANEL ROSTER**

[]{#__RefHeading___Toc162327801 .anchor}**DESCRIPTION (provided by
applicant):** *Insert overall description here*

**CRITIQUE:**

[]{#__RefHeading___Toc162327802 .anchor}**OVERALL PROGRAM CRITIQUE:**

*Insert overall critique from discussion leader here*

[]{#__RefHeading___Toc162327803 .anchor}**PROGRESS DURING THE CURRENT
FUNDING PERIOD:** *(DELETE this heading FOR TYPE 1 APPLICATIONS)*

*Insert Progress critique from assigned reviewer here*

[]{#__RefHeading___Toc162327804 .anchor}**PROGRAM LEADERSHIP:**

*Insert PL critique from assigned reviewer here*

[]{#__RefHeading___Toc162327805 .anchor}**PROGRAM AS AN INTEGRATED
EFFORT:**

*Insert PIE critique from assigned reviewer here*

# 

[]{#__RefHeading___Toc162327806 .anchor}**PROJECT AND CORE SUMMARIES OF
DISCUSSION:**

*For [each]{.underline} project and core, use the following format:*

**Project #, Title of Project, will be led by Project Leader Name,
degree(s).** *Insert summary paragraph for project sent to SRO by
reviewer*

**Core #, Title of Core, will be directed by Core Leader Name,
degree(s).** *Insert summary paragraph for core sent to SRO by reviewer*

**THE FOLLOWING RESUME SECTIONS WERE PREPARED BY THE SCIENTIFIC REVIEW
OFFICER TO SUMMARIZE THE OUTCOME OF DISCUSSIONS OF THE REVIEW COMMITTEE
ON THE FOLLOWING ISSUES**:

**HUMAN SUBJECTS (Resume);** (Add TOC reference for
**[THIS]{.underline}** heading, not "Protection of HS" below. *Delete
all HS headings if overall application does NOT have HS; keep all HS
headings if any project or core has HS)*

[]{#refheading___toc162327809 .anchor}**PROTECTION OF HUMAN SUBJECTS
(Resume):**

**DATA SAFETY AND MONITORING PLAN (Resume):**

**INCLUSION OF WOMEN PLAN (Resume):**

**INCLUSION OF MINORITIES PLAN (Resume):**

**INCLUSION OF CHILDREN PLAN (Resume):**

[]{#__RefHeading___Toc162327810 .anchor}**VERTEBRATE ANIMALS (Resume):**
(*Delete if overall application does NOT have animals; keep if any
project or core has animals)*

**BIOHAZARD COMMENT:** *(ADD TOC link for this heading if needed; delete
if not needed)*

**BUDGETARY OVERLAP:** *(if no budgetary overlap noted, state None Noted
and delete section below)*

The following grants should be examined for possible overlap of support
and/or over-commitment of effort with this application:

[Investigator]{.underline} [Grant Number]{.underline}

xxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx

**COLLABORATING INSTITUTIONS:** *(List collaborating institutions or
state None)*

[]{#__RefHeading___Toc162327811 .anchor}**FOREIGN INSTITUTION:**
*(delete if not needed)*

[]{#__RefHeading___Toc162327812 .anchor}**REVISION NOTE:** *(delete if
not needed)*

[]{#__RefHeading___Toc162327813 .anchor}**SCIENTIFIC REVIEW OFFICER'S
NOTES:** *(delete if not needed)*

# INDIVIDUAL PROJECTS AND CORES

# PROJECT 1**:** Title of Project

(Name of the project leader and degree(s))

(Consortium agreement with Institution) (OR-Includes Subcontract with
Institution)

**DESCRIPTION (provided by the applicant):** *Insert description here*

**CRITIQUE: The written critiques of individual reviewers are provided
in essentially unedited form in the "Critique" section below. Please
note that these critiques were prepared prior to the meeting and may not
have been revised subsequent to any discussions at the review meeting.
The "Resume and Summary of Discussion" and "Overall Program Critique"
sections above summarize the final opinions of the committee.**

**CRITIQUE 1**:

*Insert Reviewer 1 Critique Here*

**CRITIQUE 2:**

*Insert Reviewer 2 Critique Here*

**CRITIQUE 3:**

*Insert Reviewer 3 Critique Here*

**HUMAN SUBJECTS:** (*Delete all HS headings if overall application does
NOT have HS)*

Protection of human subjects from Research Risk:

Data and Safety Monitoring Plan:

Inclusion of Women:

Inclusion of Minorities:

Inclusion of Children:

**VERTEBRATE ANIMALS:** (*Delete if overall application does NOT have
animals)*

**AVERAGE MERIT RATING:**

**COMMITTEE BUDGET RECOMMENDATION:**

# PROJECT 2**:** Title of Project

(Name of the project leader and degree(s))

(Consortium agreement with Institution) (OR-Includes Subcontract with
Institution)

**DESCRIPTION (provided by the applicant):** *Insert description here*

**CRITIQUE: The written critiques of individual reviewers are provided
in essentially unedited form in the "Critique" section below. Please
note that these critiques were prepared prior to the meeting and may not
have been revised subsequent to any discussions at the review meeting.
The "Resume and Summary of Discussion" and "Overall Program Critique"
sections above summarize the final opinions of the committee.**

**CRITIQUE 1:**

*Insert Reviewer 1 Critique Here*

**CRITIQUE 2:**

*Insert Reviewer 2 Critique Here*

**CRITIQUE 3:**

*Insert Reviewer 3 Critique Here*

**HUMAN SUBJECTS:** (*Delete all HS headings if overall application does
NOT have HS)*

Protection of human subjects from Research Risk:

Data and Safety Monitoring Plan:

Inclusion of Women:

Inclusion of Minorities:

Inclusion of Children:

**VERTEBRATE ANIMALS:** (*Delete if overall application does NOT have
animals)*

**AVERAGE MERIT RATING:**

**COMMITTEE BUDGET RECOMMENDATION:**

# **PROJECT 3:** Title of Project

(Name of the project leader and degree(s))

(Consortium agreement with Institution) (OR-Includes Subcontract with
Institution)

**DESCRIPTION (provided by the applicant):** *Insert description here*

**CRITIQUE: The written critiques of individual reviewers are provided
in essentially unedited form in the "Critique" section below. Please
note that these critiques were prepared prior to the meeting and may not
have been revised subsequent to any discussions at the review meeting.
The "Resume and Summary of Discussion" and "Overall Program Critique"
sections above summarize the final opinions of the committee.**

**CRITIQUE 1**:

*Insert Reviewer 1 Critique Here*

**CRITIQUE 2:**

*Insert Reviewer 2 Critique Here*

**CRITIQUE 3:**

*Insert Reviewer 3 Critique Here*

**HUMAN SUBJECTS:** (*Delete all HS headings if overall application does
NOT have HS)*

Protection of human subjects from Research Risk:

Data and Safety Monitoring Plan:

Inclusion of Women:

Inclusion of Minorities:

Inclusion of Children:

**VERTEBRATE ANIMALS:** (*Delete if overall application does NOT have
animals)*

**AVERAGE MERIT RATING:**

**COMMITTEE BUDGET RECOMMENDATION:**

# PROJECT 4: Title of Project

(Name of the project leader and degree(s))

(Consortium agreement with Institution) (OR-Includes Subcontract with
Institution)

**DESCRIPTION (provided by the applicant):** *Insert description here*

**CRITIQUE: The written critiques of individual reviewers are provided
in essentially unedited form in the "Critique" section below. Please
note that these critiques were prepared prior to the meeting and may not
have been revised subsequent to any discussions at the review meeting.
The "Resume and Summary of Discussion" and "Overall Program Critique"
sections above summarize the final opinions of the committee.**

**CRITIQUE 1:**

*Insert Reviewer 1 Critique Here*

**CRITIQUE 2:**

*Insert Reviewer 2 Critique Here*

**CRITIQUE 3:**

*Insert Reviewer 3 Critique Here*

**HUMAN SUBJECTS:** (*Delete all HS headings if overall application does
NOT have HS)*

Protection of human subjects from Research Risk:

Data and Safety Monitoring Plan:

Inclusion of Women:

Inclusion of Minorities:

Inclusion of Children:

**VERTEBRATE ANIMALS:** (*Delete if overall application does NOT have
animals)*

**AVERAGE MERIT RATING:**

**COMMITTEE BUDGET RECOMMENDATION:**

*Follow same pattern for additional projects, if needed, adding a TOC
reference for Project \# and Title*

# CORE A: Core Title

(Core Director's Full Name, Degree(s))

(Consortium agreement with Institution) (OR-Includes Subcontract with
Institution)

**DESCRIPTION (provided by the applicant):** *Insert description here*

**CRITIQUE: The written critiques of individual reviewers are provided
in essentially unedited form in the "Critique" section below. Please
note that these critiques were prepared prior to the meeting and may not
have been revised subsequent to any discussions at the review meeting.
The "Resume and Summary of Discussion" and "Overall Program Critique"
sections above summarize the final opinions of the committee.**

**CRITIQUE 1:**

*Insert Reviewer 1 Critique Here*

**CRITIQUE 2:**

*Insert Reviewer 2 Critique Here*

**HUMAN SUBJECTS:** (*Delete all HS headings if overall application does
NOT have HS)*

Protection of human subjects from Research Risk:

Data and Safety Monitoring Plan:

Inclusion of Women:

Inclusion of Minorities:

Inclusion of Children:

**VERTEBRATE ANIMALS:** (*Delete if overall application does NOT have
animals)*

**RATING:**

**COMMITTEE BUDGET RECOMMENDATION:**

# CORE B: Core Title

(Core Director's Full Name, Degree(s))

(Consortium agreement with Institution) (OR-Includes Subcontract with
Institution)

**DESCRIPTION (provided by the applicant):** *Insert description here*

**CRITIQUE: The written critiques of individual reviewers are provided
in essentially unedited form in the "Critique" section below. Please
note that these critiques were prepared prior to the meeting and may not
have been revised subsequent to any discussions at the review meeting.
The "Resume and Summary of Discussion" and "Overall Program Critique"
sections above summarize the final opinions of the committee.**

**CRITIQUE 1:**

*Insert Reviewer 1 Critique Here*

**CRITIQUE 2:**

*Insert Reviewer 2 Critique Here*

**HUMAN SUBJECTS:** (*Delete all HS headings if overall application does
NOT have HS)*

Protection of human subjects from Research Risk:

Data and Safety Monitoring Plan:

Inclusion of Women:

Inclusion of Minorities:

Inclusion of Children:

**VERTEBRATE ANIMALS:** (*Delete if overall application does NOT have
animals)*

**RATING:**

**COMMITTEE BUDGET RECOMMENDATION:**

# CORE C: Core Title

(Core Director's Full Name, Degree(s))

(Consortium agreement with Institution) (OR-Includes Subcontract with
Institution)

**DESCRIPTION (provided by the applicant):** *Insert description here*

**CRITIQUE: The written critiques of individual reviewers are provided
in essentially unedited form in the "Critique" section below. Please
note that these critiques were prepared prior to the meeting and may not
have been revised subsequent to any discussions at the review meeting.
The "Resume and Summary of Discussion" and "Overall Program Critique"
sections above summarize the final opinions of the committee.**

**CRITIQUE 1**:

*Insert Reviewer 1 Critique Here*

**CRITIQUE 2**:

*Insert Reviewer 2 Critique Here*

**HUMAN SUBJECTS:** (*Delete all HS headings if overall application does
NOT have HS)*

Protection of human subjects from Research Risk:

Data and Safety Monitoring Plan:

Inclusion of Women:

Inclusion of Minorities:

Inclusion of Children:

**VERTEBRATE ANIMALS:** (*Delete if overall application does NOT have
animals)*

**RATING:**

**COMMITTEE BUDGET RECOMMENDATION:**

*Follow same pattern for additional cores, if needed, adding a TOC
reference for Core \# and Title..*

# COMMITTEE BUDGET RECOMMENDATIONS {#committee-budget-recommendations .Style-Heading-1Heading-1-+-Arial-11-bold-+-Centered}

The table below summarizes the estimated effects on the original amounts
requested by the applicant of implementing the budgetary changes
recommended by the reviewers and summarized in the Budget section(s) of
the Summary Statement above. The table below does not take into account
additional information that may be provided by applicants in response to
administrative requests for updates, or additional administrative
changes required to meet Institute funding policies, either or both of
which may result in a significantly different final recommended budget
figure. Consequently, applicants should make no inferences from these
figures about what the final budget might be, should an award be
possible. The details of the recommended reductions are articulated
under the Committee Budget Recommendations for each component.

+-----------------------+----------------------+-----------------------+
|                       | > First Year         | > First Year          |
|                       | > Requested Direct   | > Recommended Direct  |
|                       | > Costs              | > Costs               |
+-----------------------+----------------------+-----------------------+
| > Project 1           |                      |                       |
+-----------------------+----------------------+-----------------------+
| > Project 2           |                      |                       |
+-----------------------+----------------------+-----------------------+
| > Project 3           |                      |                       |
+-----------------------+----------------------+-----------------------+
| > Project 4           |                      |                       |
+-----------------------+----------------------+-----------------------+
| > Project 5           |                      |                       |
+-----------------------+----------------------+-----------------------+
| > Project 6           |                      |                       |
+-----------------------+----------------------+-----------------------+
| > Core A              |                      |                       |
+-----------------------+----------------------+-----------------------+
| > Core B              |                      |                       |
+-----------------------+----------------------+-----------------------+
| > Core C              |                      |                       |
+-----------------------+----------------------+-----------------------+
| > Core D              |                      |                       |
+-----------------------+----------------------+-----------------------+
| > Core E              |                      |                       |
+-----------------------+----------------------+-----------------------+
|                       |                      |                       |
+-----------------------+----------------------+-----------------------+
| > Total Direct Cost   |                      |                       |
+-----------------------+----------------------+-----------------------+