+------------+------------------------------------------+-------------+
| !          | #                                        | ![](me      |
| [](media/i |                                          | dia/image2. |
| mage1.png) | #                                        | png){width= |
|            | United States Department of the Interior | "0.76319444 |
|            |                                          | 44444444in" |
|            | ##                                       | height="    |
|            |                                          | 0.998611111 |
|            | ## NATIONAL PARK SERVICE                 | 1111111in"} |
|            |                                          |             |
|            | ##### Cedar Breaks National Monument     |             |
|            |                                          |             |
|            | **2390 W Hwy 56, Suite 11**              |             |
|            |                                          |             |
|            | **Cedar City, UT 84720**                 |             |
+------------+------------------------------------------+-------------+

IN REPLY REFER TO: L76

July 30, 2008

Norman R. Elrod

Federal Aviation Administration

Air Transportation Division

135 Air Carrier Operations Branch, AFS-250

800 Independence Ave., SW

Washington, DC 20591

**Subject: Cedar Breaks National Monument Comment on Docket No.
FAA-2008-0713**

Dear Mr. Elrod:

This letter is in reference to the Federal Register Notice published
Tuesday, July 8, 2008 regarding a **Notice of Interim Operating
Authority Granted to Commercial Air Tour Operators over National Parks
and Tribal Lands Within or Abutting National Parks \[Vol. 73, No. 131,
paged 39073-39074\] \[Docket No. FAA-2008-0713\]**.

The National Park Air Tour Management Act (the Act) of 2000 \[49 USC
4012\] states:

> *(2) The Federal Aviation Administration has the authority to
> preserve, protect, and enhance the environment by minimizing,
> mitigating, or preventing the adverse effects of aircraft overflights
> on public and tribal lands*.
>
> *(3) The National Park service has the responsibility of conserving
> the scenery and natural and historic objects and wildlife in national
> parks and of providing for the enjoyment of the national parks in ways
> that leave the national parks unimpaired for future generations.*
> \[Sec. 802\]

The Act clearly articulates the intent of Congress for the Federal
Aviation Administration (FAA) and the National Park Service (NPS) to
work together to preserve, protect and enhance the natural environment
for the enjoyment visitors and to conserve the natural and cultural
resources in national parks.

The Act provides a process to grant interim operating authority (IOA) to
commercial air tour companies if they were "an existing commercial air
tour operator." The Act also addresses new applications (new entrants)
for IOA (not an existing operator) with the following:

> *(A) In general.\--**The Administrator, in cooperation with the
> Director**, may grant interim operating authority under this paragraph
> to an air tour operator for a national park or tribal lands for which
> that operator is a new entrant air tour operator if the Administrator
> determines the authority is **necessary to ensure competition in the
> provision of commercial air tour operations over the park** or tribal
> lands.*
>
> *(B) Safety limitation.\--The Administrator may not grant interim
> operating authority under subparagraph (A) if the Administrator
> determines that it would create a safety problem at the park or on the
> tribal lands, or the Director **determines that it would create a
> noise problem at the park** or on the tribal lands.* \[Sec. 803 §
> 40128 (c)(3)\]

Again the Act reiterates the intent of Congress for the FAA and the NPS
to cooperate on issues relating to commercial air tour operations over
national parks and monuments. This is especially important in
determining when, and if, to grant interim operating authority to a new
entrant. Further, Congress through the Act, provides clear direction on
when it is appropriate to grant IOA to new entrants.

The FAA should describe, in the Federal Register, how they determined
that adding another operator would "ensure the **necessary**
competition." This is the key justification the Act gives to grant IOA
to new entrants. The FAA must demonstrate how they arrived at this
determination. There are currently 6 companies with IOA for Cedar Breaks
National Monument; with a total of 69 flights per year. Six air tour
operators over a 6,154 acre monument **do** ensure ample competition.

Adding an additional 120 air tour flights per year over the monument
would contribute to the growing noise problem. We continue to receive
complaints from visitors about the noise made by air craft over and in
the vicinity of the monument.

The monument is over 70 percent recommended wilderness and is managed as
such. Two of the key components of the wilderness experience, as stated
in the Wilderness Act of September 3, 1964 are that the lands retain:

> *...its primeval character and influence, without permanent
> improvements or human habitation, which is protected and managed so as
> to preserve its natural conditions and which (1) generally appears to
> have been affected primarily by the forces of nature, with the imprint
> of man\'s work substantially unnoticeable; (2) has outstanding
> opportunities for solitude or a primitive and unconfined type of
> recreation;...*

The opportunities for solitude are impaired by aircraft overflights,
especially low flying scenic overflights. If the Director determines
that adding additional flights "would create a noise problem at the
park" the Act states that the Administrator may not grant interim
operating authority. We believe this is the case.

The Act also requires that Air Tour Management Plans (ATMPs) be prepared
for any national park unit for which a plan is not in effect whenever a
person applies for authority to conduct commercial air tours over that
park unit. To date the FAA has not begun the plan for Cedar Breaks. The
Act outlines the objectives of the ATMPs:

> *...shall be to develop acceptable and effective measures to mitigate
> or prevent the significant adverse impacts, if any, of commercial air
> tour operations upon the natural and cultural resources, visitor
> experiences, and tribal lands .*\[Sec. 803 § 40128 (b)(1)(B)\]

The section goes on to say that ATMPs:

> *...may prohibit commercial air tour operations in whole or in part;*
>
> *may establish conditions for the conduct of commercial air tour
> operations, including commercial air tour routes, maximum or minimum
> altitudes, time-of-day restrictions, restrictions for particular
> events, maximum number of flights per unit of time, intrusions on
> privacy on tribal lands, and mitigation of noise, visual, or other
> impacts;....*\[Sec. 803 § 40128 (b)(3)(A)&(B)\]

The National Park Service Organic Act established the National Park
Service in 1916 with the following:

> *...which purpose is to conserve the scenery and the natural and
> historic objects and the wildlife therein and to provide for the
> enjoyment of the same in such manner and by such means as will leave
> them unimpaired for the enjoyment of future generations...*

NPS Management Policies 2006 \[1.4.5\] defines impairment that is
prohibited by the Organic Act as:

> *...an impact that, in the professional judgment of the responsible
> NPS manager, would harm the integrity of park resources and values,
> including the opportunity that would otherwise be present for the
> enjoyment of those resources and values...*

It is premature to grant IOA to new entrants for air tour operations
before the ATMP is completed. Granting this authority to a new entrant
precludes any type of adequate analysis of the impacts of such an
operation. This prevents the NPS from identifying mitigation to prevent
significant impacts caused by the operation which could constitute an
"impairment" to park resources and visitor experience.

The Act states that the ATMP planning process could conclude that air
tour operations are inappropriate for a particular park or monument. The
ATMP could prohibit commercial air tour operations in whole or in part.

Cedar Breaks National Monument strongly objects to granting IOA to any
new entrants at this time. We believe that a full analysis of the
impacts of the existing operations, through the ATMP process, must occur
before any new entrants are authorized.

If you have any questions, please contact me at 435-586-9451 or
paul_roelandt@nps.gov.

Sincerely,

*Paul Roelandt* /s/

Paul Roelandt

Superintendent