text: Although the bagels we got from Gotham were pretty tasty our experience with them as a whole was incredibly disappointing My husband and I had them the Mifflin St location cater a few simple breakfasts during our wedding weekend Although all they had to do was deliver two dozen bagels literally a quarter mile they were over an hour late on two of the three days and brought all the wrong kinds of bagels on the third day Moreover the service was shockingly bad when my husband placed the initial order and they never brought a final receipt to show how much we would be charged When I called a week or so after the wedding to ask about the final charge and to offer some comments on the service I was told the owner would call me back within two hours He never did And when I called back a second time a few days later I was assured that the owner would call me just as soon as he returned You can guess how that turned outI never heard back I will certainly never give Gotham Bagels my business again and I would recommend you stay away as well