text: I was really disappointed by my experience at craftsteak Ate here with of my dearest oldest friends for my bachelorette weekend Huge fan of top chef and when I discovered tom collichio owned this place I just had to try it for our big saturday night meal We are all big foodies And no I was not wearing a veil and tiara or any blinking jewelry We are all in our late s early s and were well behaved at least til the end of the night when we had consumed several martinis and bottles of vino We may have been laughing loudly but we never got rowdyand we were practically in a PDR for chrissake so I could have mooned the table next to me and only about a dozen or so people might see Not that I would Just sayin we were hidden away All that being saidservice was freaking awful Our server was an older gentleman and he was downright rude If gratuity had not been tacked on I honestly might have gone which I NEVER do being a former server and bartender myselfI have maybe done this once in my life I ordered the surf turf a splurge but usually one of my favorite things to eat The filet was a tad undercooked for medium rare but I kind of like it in between rare and med rare so it was fine by me One of my friends could not handle it The lobster was so rubbery and chewy and coldish and flavorlessdid it come out of the fridge Side dishes bored me and everyone My opening salad was good but only because we shared a ton of starters and I mixed the mozzarella salad with the tomato salad to make my own caprese I think one of my friends enjoyed her short ribs Nobody raved about anything Except maybe the hot sticky buns that come out in the beginning Truly sad we did not enjoy it Should have eaten elsewhere Will not return