text: I want to like Bar Smith and I actually very much do Butthe stars were inevitable after my lunch here a few weeks agonnFirst off let me say that I really do like everything about this place the ambiance the vibe the menu the service the pricesit is all great Seriously But I just cannot justify giving a fourth star because my food was not very wellprepared nnI ordered the Blackened Mahi Mahi which came with a Pineapple Relish Mixed Greens and a Cajun Remoulade Dressing very excellent concept for a dish and the flavors were really lovely togetherthis dish made me believe that a pineapple relish may be the only way to eat mahi mahi However as I am sitting there enjoyed the dish I start getting closer to middle of the mahi filet and I realize that it is not cookednnNot even remotely Yeah the edges were cooked but most of it was cold and raw NOT how I like my mahi mahi I very kindly asked the waitress if they could cook it more and she very kindly had the kitchen do so They got it right the second time around although it was not quite the same but it makes me wonder if whoevers back in the kitchen knows what they are doingnnI want to go back I want to try it again because I have the feeling it was a fluke I HOPE it was a fluke But as for now I have no other choice but to give them starsdespite how much I really do like this place