text: Really hit or missnnWe got a gift card for Elephant Bar some time ago so we have been there twice to use it up The first time we ordered the chicken marsala and cream of asparagus soup FABULOUS Also Elephant Bar has extraordinary iced tea The second time my fiancue duplicated his original order and I got a weeeeeeeeird salad with basil leaves in it His order which was so great the time before was super bland and the sauce was really lumpy My salad was utterly disgusting More than half the salad was basil leaves rather than lettuce Sure I expected the basil but as a complement to the salad itself not that the basil itself was the saladnnThe people who gave us the gift card have some notion that Elephant Bar is our favorite restaurant not sure why so I bet we will be getting another gift card for the next major occasion It is a very Seinfeldish of situation That is the only reason I would likely return I really value consistency when I dine out it is a major bummer when you come back for something like my fiancues chicken marsala only to feel like you are eating a completely different dish