the public. Intelligibility begins with consistency. Content owners, however, have tried to substitute rhetoric of ?theft? and ?piracy? for intelligible rules. This will surely fail. Public understanding of the rules depends on precision and consistency in determining which rights are infringed by which activities. [footnotes omitted] Nesson's Grokster Manifesto We invite judges to help shed its corporate vestiges of babylon as it applies to open knowledge libraries. Grokster is a troublemaker for the dons of p2p. Our Code is Open, don?t you see. The Open Library of Knowledge will distribute p2p torrents of information seeded in a mirrored ring data bases rooted in time and space as firmly as engineers can plant them. Our enterprise nonprofit. Wikipedia is our model. Like my original post, however, many have concentrated on the fact that Rosen was decrying the very DRM that she had been such a strong proponent of. Let us not forget, however, that Rosen was an enemy of MP3 players all together. Indeed, let us go back to those halycon days of 1998 when the RIAA went after the Diamond Rio MP3 Player. See , RIAA Takes Stand to Protect Legitimate Online Marketplace . If the RIAA had its way, there wouldn't be any portable MP3 players. The only portable players you would be able to buy would play only DRM restricted tunes. In her most recent article, Rosen claims that, "If you are really a geek, you can figure out how to strip the songs you might have bought