If I meet God in some afterlife, I'll ask Him why He didn't give me enough evidence. ...Really? Thanks for your comment! You'd be surprised by how often it comes up. As Craig says in one of the videos I linked, it is a kind of typical internet strategy for quote unqoute debate. It's really, I've found, an attempt to catch the opponent off guard. Interestingly, I was discussing this statement with someone I know who is agnostic and they immediately recognized the flaw in the reasoning. They said: "But you're not an atheist, you're a Christian." It was a kind of "duh" moment, one that some atheists apparently need to experience. Or you can just say, "You're actually a theist since I believe in just one more God than you do". Whatever they say back a response can be, "Since that 'reasoning' goes both ways, it really doesn't leave us anywhere productive.. so can we move on?". Funny thing is that I've thought of this statement from atheists for awhile and it wasn't until I read your post that the above response came to me. Thanks for the post, it really does lay out the fallacy of the whole comment. Indeed this is true. I mean if we're allowed to call other people whatever we desire regardless of the logical or epistemological nature of the terminology, we may as well use the reasoning in all sorts of strange ways. One point. When non-believers use the "we're all atheists" quote,