the fact that he already doesn't like MMO's and makes that plain to see. It destroys all his journalistic credibility to write a piece of this nature. "By the way alot of MMO games in the past yearhave been crap(star wars)" You've made the same mistake that Luke has. You say it's "crap", but you do not explain why it's crap, or how it could be better than it is. Any specific failings, or is it a game you have merely chosen to dislike? How hard is it really? Sandbox MMO is the way. Give people an open world with little restrictions. Put an interesting combat system that doesnt involve mashing speed keys in a rotation perhaps something more like EQ1. Put a crafting system in like SWG before they screwed it, let people build houses and cities and add a side of minecraft in there and Booya, you got yourself a decent MMO. All this quest hub to quest hub crap that is way to easy and batshit boring is what killed the genre for me. Why would I want to do exactly the same thing as everyone else? Hell most of the time the only levels are any any different are the first 10 noob levels then everyone is doing the same boring crap. People these days want Sandbox games. A bit of freedom. Give people the tools to do that and it will be game on. I agree in many ways. I remember the first MMO I