Sorry for the intrusion, but Gibbs is an interesting player that divides opinion and destroys my supercoach team each time I think he is due for a "break out year". My outside view of Gibbs is that he is jack of all trades, master of none. He can do it all skills wise, but nothing specifcally role wise to take advantage of those skills. He can play as a mid, but other players are more specifically just mids so Gibbs can be used elsewhere to fill a hole. He then becomes a utility. Utility players are used & abused, they can never find consistency as their role is always changing. He would be in the starting 4 midfielders at most bottom 10 clubs. In a way he reminds me of Daisy Thomas, also a high draft pick, but took a long time to be classed as a midfielder, he got stuck up on a half forward flank mostly where his impact was limited. His best footy has been as a genuine onballer and has had lots of competition for that spot, so he still gets reassigned at times. I think MM will play him in the middle straight up and basically groom him as the Judd replacement. If he can't do the job he will end up on a half forward flank as a lead up forward where he can do some damage, but would be a bit of a disapointment to see his talents wasted there.. I don't think