find her when he returns to America. As it turns out, this girl is a single mother who runs a kennel in Louisiana. He tracks her down and ends up working for her and keeping the whole photo story a secret from her. It's a gentle romance and as we said, Efron's pretty good in it. But we couldn't help thinking how different this movie would've been if he had only picked up someone else's photo . If this girl was someone more exciting, this would've been a totally different movie. If it was a picture of Lady Gaga, Efron could've gone back to America and fallen in love with a multi-platinum hit-maker; if it was a picture of an Astronaut, the movie would've seen Efron train at NASA for the opportunity to spend time with his beloved on the International Space Station! In either of these cases, this movie might have had a broader appeal. Let's look at a few more ways in which The Lucky One could've played differently: Plot: Sgt. Logan Thibault returns to America after being saved by a picture of eccentric crossword puzzle constructor Mary Horowitz ( Sandra Bullock ). After tracking her down in Northern California, Logan recounts his story to her. Mary takes this to be a sign and quickly becomes obsessed with Logan. When Logan is redeployed to Afghanistan, Mary sneaks onto a flight to Helmand province posing as a journalist. Once there, she surprises Logan who now has to execute his