Why Did Allah Allow People Of The Book To Corrupt Crucial Details?
so the examples I earlier quoted, Khatim, Noor in 5:15 and Noor e Muhammadi SAW, Al-Ali and Ali RA Would you call them vague? and thats why people twisted them? One may argue them to be vague but the way Islam is practiced as a whole would show that they can’t be vague. Traditional Islamic view gets favor. Similarly is the issue with Judaism and Christianity, they will favor their interpretation of prophecies over ours. For Jews and Christians, we are the “Khatim, Noor-e-Muhammadi, Al-Ali” text-manipulators, they will prefer traditional view over our Prophetic (PBUH) prophecies view. Not at all, it was clear then and clear now. Just because they could read Ahmad in the scripture more clearly than today (this is also an assumption but lets not discuss that right now). easiest refutation would be that his name is not Ahmad but Muhammad SAW. They never said that, why? But his birthname was Ahmad. Maybe that’s why? please explain how would christian or jews become muslims or stop questioning all the related prophecies if Ahmad was mentioned as clearly as Jesus AS in the bible? Wouldn’t there be many many reasons to deny? It will not stop them from questioning, it will at least get to accept that a future prophet is possible and start a conversation. Right now, Jews only expect a Messiah and Christians expect no one. I think u r assuming their reasons for questioning and also giving too much importance to this 1 thing without much evidence (I haven’t read or heard any christian scholar to come forward with this argument. However, many sunday priests mention it out of context though. The mention of Kedar easily refutes that it could be someone else other than Muhammad SAW, but I not knowing isn’t an argument so please let me know if I am making a mistake) Here is a site countering the prophecy along with Kedar point: https://steelmanapologetics.com/is-isaiah-42-a-prediction-of-muhammad/ Here is another: https://thirdmill.org/answers/answer.asp?file=40474 I can list more responses but they are more informal and not pleasant to read. But the demand for Prophet’s (PBUH) prophecies is pretty strong online because by default he is considered a false prophet by both Jews/Christians.
wow! brother it seems you would go to any length to prove your view point why it is hard to accept that words are clear but people twisted them for their own gains? but it easier to question Allah that why He didn’t make it more clear or why He did not stop them from making those changes? another weakest argument. So jews and christian of medina would know Muhammad SAW’s birth name give to him by his mother who passed away when he a child and he spent rest of his life with his paternal grand father and his family. No reported contact with his maternal family as a child or as a grown man? if this seems reasonable to you then your can accept it secondly, I would request you to stay away from blogger and christian ministry websites, they aren’t looking for serious knowledge, they have an agenda and they will work on their agenda no matter what. Stretching of Kedar to an area of land is no scholarship.