Forbidden Acts In Jannah
Your first two paragraphs are a satisfying answer but I do have a few issues especially with the third paragraph: 1. You say that haram things can be made halal like wine if the illat is removed but if an individual argues that is also the case with certain acts of sex (because the argument is that there is impurity involved in these acts so that is why they are haram) then how do we argue against? That if filth and impurity (like human waste) will no longer exist in Jannah then there is no filth in oral/anal sex. What’s the argument here to show that wine will be purified but everything else won’t be if an individual does argue this? 2. If at highest Tazkiya a person may not desire for haram things then why would someone desire for wine either? Allah calls it “work of Shaytan” (5:90), a Muslim would dislike Shaytan’s work in every case yet Allah goes through the effort of purifying it and allowing it? Also I think there are plenty of Muslims that can live in Jannah without wine but Allah is still promising it and giving it to us so why not for other haram things? 3. Ghamidi Sahab argued in his video (1:26 onwards https://youtu.be/4_fHGJWCad0?t=87 ) that when people become rebellious, Allah said that He will give them all that they desire (like e.g wine) so they may give up their rebelliousness. Issue is that if we argue that certain haram things will never be purified or given in Jannah, wouldn’t people in this life will become rebellious for these things? Like is it safer to just say to everyone that “You will have whatever you want and if there is any issue (of certain things not allowed in Jannah), Allah will resolve it later when we get there” ?.