Importance Of Sadd-E-Zariya Based Advice Of A Scholar?
@Irfan76 sir does it mean that if someone knowing the risk involved, doesn’t listen to the advice of scholar. but didn’t fall into the end stage sin (which the scholar was trying to prevent from). will this person still be sinful for minor sin for not doing what the scholar told him (this directive is neither in Quran nor in Sunnah, but a mere advice of scholar for prevention)?
@Irfan76 sir I understand that you say that if something has a significant potential to lead to a major sin, if it is not prohibited by Allah or his messenger. then doing this action in itself would not be sin (as in example of a man going to house of his alcoholic friend, despite knowing he can get tempted or pressurized to drink). but here in this video Ghamidi Sahab answered this that such a thing may not be sinful under not abiding by directive of Allah or his messenger. but such a thing can be sinful under the heading of “Nafs ke Saath Khayaanat” as was mentioned in Quran when Muslims did a thing which they thought was sinful (in reality it was not). sir then how to look into this matter? Because a person with a deep and fine details thinking mind, will see everything in falling under such things. he would inevitably go closer and closer to rahbaniyat as he’ll see such actions as high potential paving a way for sin, so he’ll definitely conclude these mundane actions sinful too (because of the principle) and he wouldn’t want to consistently do these actions fearing that if he falls under Istikbar while constantly doing those mundane acts. can you please explain sir https://youtu.be/M2dnHGLb5qM?si=rfd9EUmtmVs-6sN7 from 17:00 onwards