Authenticity Of Hadith About Hazrat Fatima (R.A) And Parda
Salam Alaikum Any update???
Thank you for your explanation sir My question is , how do we ascertain if something is a binding ruling or just aadaab?For example, in one of the above ahadith, it is stated that a woman’s prayer WON’T BE ACCEPTED unless she wears a khimaar. How is it then just aadaab? Also, Ghamidi Sahab says that while Hadith cannot add something to the religion,but they can explain its details, right? So the first hadith of this forum could be an explanation of the details of Surah An-Nur Hijab Verse, no?How do we reconcile the fact that Prophet(PBUH) said that Fatima (R.A) need not struggle so much for covering her head and feet only because of the fact that there were only her father (PBUH) and here slave there with Ghamidi Sahab’s understanding of purdah? I guess I’m missing something here.Is this hadith unauthentic according to Ghamidi Sahab? Thank you
But why was she struggling so much to cover from head to toe if covering these parts are not mandatory? Shouldn’t she have reacted completely normally, since the area between her neck to knee was already covered?