Last 2 Verses Of Srah Tawbah And Historic Evidences
Ijma and tawstur means that what is transmitted through generations to generations incessantly. Qur’an is transmitted through this means. No haidth is transmitted in this way. Qur’an is not supposed to conform to the theories. These are just conjecture. Qur’an is the book of guidance. One should seek guidance from Qur’an in the matters of morality, shariah and accountability in the hereafter.
I think in certain aspects may be it will provude evidence….but taking it base and trying to cover every type of aspect by tbis 19 theory….is wrong…. This has possiblity….
A theory is obviosly a theory….And as well there seems no purpose of anyone to inject tgese ayahs if for sake of discussion we assume…. Because there is no such thing which may become beneficial for him in any way….. It may be also that some people had realizes 19 code….or so…and then Rk tried to adjust it in every aspect….he as well added letters,adjustments many a times…..
Not in my knowledge but the two links I gave above, you will understand how Ghamidi Sahab thinks about these topics i.e his argument on why Qur’an and Sunnah are solid in terms of authenticity and the Quranist discussion being about why you must follow certain principle to understand the Qur’an or anyone can interpret anything out of it which is dangerous. This is probably why he does not comment on RK. He violated two main points of his that I linked above. There is also Ghamidi Sahab video on why scientific and numerical miracles should not be pulled out of the Qur’an which is relevant: Discussion 30165 • Reply 30288 You may make a separate thread requesting for Ghamidi Sahab opinion on RK or just register for Ask Ghamidi event. For more relevant discussions on this, kindly see: Discussion 30166 Discussion 43610