Washing In A Natural Way During Wudu And Ghusl
Salam….not a moderator….but just a fan of ghamidi sahab…. Im not answering your question here rather just wanted to share some thoughts. To me it appears that South Asian Molvis are too “Fiqhi”…It appears they like lawyers, define everything. Create super strict definition of every act. Like as an hypoethical example “sajdah is ko kehtai hain kai itnay unglee zameen par touch ho, iss angle mai ho” etc. Some South Asian Molvi sahabs apparently even make mustahab things farz. Including Sunnat namaz and witr. The eye closing part is something I’ve never heard of. This is what saudis website states about ghusl….obviously you’ve seen it…. https://islamqa.info/en/answers/82344/how-to-make-ghusl-for-major-impurity I hope the moderator can address, with evidences what part of ghusl is obligatory and whats is recommended but not obligatory, not to mention is washing once in wudu enough?
The understanding that you developed is correct Haseeb Sahab. Most of what you find online relating to Wuzu and Ghusl are opinions based on Fiqh. And now a days that fiqh is presented in way that it seems superior to or equivalent to Quran and Sunnah. No such detailing has been done in either of the sources, infact matters have been left to common knowledge where a person’s nature knows how to wash their face, arms etc. when they’re asked to do so. According to Ghamidi Sahab, fiqh is not something permanent the way it is presented and religion should be taught free of fiqh, ilm-e-kalam, philosophy and tasawwuf. Therefore, his opinions are based on pure understading of Quran and Sunnah, without any amalgamation of fiqh, which is developed by humans initially with a sincere intention of facilitating common muslims in following day-to-day directives of Islam. Regarding what Quran says how Ghusl should be done , please see: Discussion 30957 • Reply 30977 Whether Wuzu is compulsory for Ghusl , please see: Discussion 13304 • Reply 37005