Collective Takfir Of Today’s Bani Israel
Adding to my last post: Also, this does not seem to align with the punishment framework. In other words, someone who is described as “kafir” in sense Y (i.e., a present-day blind follower on whom ʾitmām al-ḥujjah is not necessarily completed) appears to receive the same type of punishment (maḥkūm) as a “kafir” in sense X (i.e., one on whom ʾitmām al-ḥujjah has been completed).