Is Homosexuality A Sin?
So, what is Islamic punishment for homosexuality in this world ? If he is not punished here (only Allah will punish him in afterlife) , does it mean he is free to do this act without law preventing him ?
We don’t allow “just let it happen” with traffic, because one person’s traffic violation can put the other person’s life in danger. We allow smoking.. and drugs as long as the person is an adult and knows what he is taking and understands all the implications of it. You have full rights to care for someone, but have no right to stop him from an act which is not doing harm to you or the society.
I would like to know those specific drugs and their reasons for prohibition .. if it is proven harmful, then obviously they will not be allowed for public consumption.. BTW, why don’t you apply the same logic of prohibiting homosexuality, to prohibiting other greater evils like polytheism ?
I would like to know if some one is born with the traits then how do we handle them I think consulting a specialist is very necessary Maybe a psychotherapist You can call this a trial but I think one needs to find the basis of it. It will be a long trial which brings a lot of anguish to the families
If homosexuality is a sin, like eating pork is, then let Allah judge them. Both, homosexuality and eating pork are not bad or immoral in themselves, but for some reason Allah considers these two acts as sins (though both are lesser sins than polytheism ). If polytheism is not causing any problem in the society, let the homosexuals and pork eaters also live in peace .. let Allah punish them in the afterlife, but at least let them enjoy this life without treating them as if they are disgusting criminals. Sad to see that a homosexual in our society (who is not doing any harm to others) is treated as a bad person, while the killers of innocent people are celebrated as Gazi .. that shows our level of morality.
How is this hadith against Qur’an and Sunnah.. also the historical account has it that the RGCs including Abu Bakr and Ali also killed homosexuals, they just differed in the method of killing them.