Status Of The Report On The Barking Of The Dogs Of حوأب At Ayesha
Well, first of all, the Mother of the Believers goes against the Prophet’s explicit saying (his explicit saying which he told her explicitly) Then, in a way, this report, by portraying that dogs barked at Ayesha, denigrates the Mother of the Believers (dogs barking at her, can you imagine that? In a whole army, specifically at her). Then, this report elevates the rank of Ali against Ayesha, which seems like the work of اہل تشیع, who consider her not to be good at all and think that the اہل بیت are Fatima, Ali, Hassan and Hussain, which is not true from the point of view of the Quran. The Quran always uses this term for a messenger and his wife or wives (for example, Ibrahim and Sarah). So you see, I get a bad vibe from this report. Furthermore, Imam Bukhari and Imam Muslim have not accepted it as it is not mentioned in their Sahihs.