Fear Around Touching To Be Mother In Law, Hurmat-E-Musahrat
@Irfan76 sir I wanted to share something, When I went through tafsir of surah nisa ayat 23 in Ibn katheer (Urdu full version) and at tabari and Al jassass. I saw that they said that in past there was some discussion about whether “allati dakhaltum bihinna” Is only a condition for daughter of the woman or also for the mother of woman as well. Then all these mufassir proved with various evidences about the construct of sentence and language that this would condition apply only for Rabiba and for mother in law, she would be automatically Haram once nikah contract with her daughter is done. But these all mufassir showed that it was unanimously agreed and no discussion was there about a woman marrying either the father or the son of her husband, with which no consummation happened. The only discussion that occurred there was in regard to hurmat of mother in law, whether that establishes with nikah. And that too happened becauses of the proximity of the sentences which mention them. But about manquha of father or of son, there was unanimous agreement among all fuqaha that they are haram on mere contract of nikah