Consent In Physical Relationship With Concubines
When I search ghamdi Sahabs opinions on this topic, I saw some videos where ghamdi quotes that Islam prohibited making of slaves from POWs. He quoted some verses from surah Mohammed. Even though the shabaas and the messenger used to capture POWs and enslave them even after the battle of badr.
What about battle of mustaliq , battle of Hunain and I have read about many other expeditions where many woman were enslaved. I believe even during the time of Sahabs I have read texts that relates to enslavement of prisoners of wars also including the exceptions you mention above
Ahadith are the narrations of the onlookers. They usually miss some details. If Ali had intercourse with the slave girl, and the prophet didn’t not mind it, it means that the act was legitimate. There was no need to wait. She might have no physical relation with anyone before.