Quran 49:15 – Doubt After Belief
If one is doubting prophethood of Prophet Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم, then why would one prefer to call himself a Muslim. I don’t understand, what’s the compulsion of him calling himself a Muslim?
It varies from question to question and from doubt to doubt. If its a mere short-lived ‘waswasa’, then it would be just fine. But If a person being an informed Muslim, dies in the state of actually questioning the Prophethood of Prophet Muhammad (Sws), I think even the use of word ‘Zan’ would be inappropraite in that case.
Having a doubt, according to my understanding of the word IS questioning it. Could you give an example of doubt va belief? Because doubts arise from questions as far as I know
I don’t get it- how does one, even after getting answers to questions, live in doubt? The very definition of doubt is being unsure because you have questions
To be honest I’m not sure if 49:15-18 is even talking about this. It seems to be more: Arab Bedouins thought they would accept Islam as a favour to Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم They started having some doubts because they didn’t come tk the conclusion logically Allah said ‘will you teach Allah his religion?’ Because they perhaps didn’t understand something so we’re trying to make their own ideas They were told that don’t do this as a favour- rather come to imaan as a logical conclusion as the other believers did. And since they came, because the arguments are so strong- they didn’t doubt it. I would think that their belief would be one of having no doubts of the basic ideas of Islam. Their hearts have so fully accepted the logical arguments of Islam that it’s not that they don’t have doubts rather they can’t have doubts therefore they don’t doubt. I may be wrong in this analysis but that’s the idea I get.