A Question Regarding Branch Application Of An Ayat
@Irfan76 sir but i meant to ask that which one is valid etc. because explanation 1 tells that a person needs not to bother about the effects that are produced by the Haram earned items and they can continue benefiting from the other halal things which are changed/molded/shaped by that Haram item, which gave them new capabilities regardless of whether it’s easy or difficult to avoid. so i can use those new capabilities because now at this stage if i use it, then I’m not or benefiting directly from Haram earned item itself. For example if i own a Halal wood and i use a haram earned cutter to make it into an arrow. using that cutter was sinful, but once used, it gave the wood a new shape and capabilities (to fly, to cut through flesh). Now if i further use the arrow to hunt down birds (where both capabilities of flying and cutting through will be used ; as given by the use of Haram earned cutter), i won’t be sinful for using this arrow for hunting. because cutter is not being directly used/benefitted to kill birds now. but explanation 2 gives a sense that “if it gets difficult to avoid, then one is allowed” this gives a sense that if it’s not difficult, as in case of this arrow example, then one has to get another arrow because it’s easy to avoid the first arrow by throwing it out and buying a new one. So i just wanted to know which one is Valid explanation in this topic?