Harsh Punishment For The Denial Of Truth
Now we are going in circles and i am losing interest. We have already agree that denial of truth behavior leads to crimes on Earth and God do not punish those who deny truth in error.
Good question. My response is that obviously based on our intuitions (which you called nagging feelings; intuition is better word I guess) we think just for shirk/kufr/sarkashi at least there should be no eternal punishment whatsoever. But I think Ghamidi sb has addressed it by stating that the premise that – there will be eternal punishment for such sins at all cost – is not valid. Eternal punishment should be seen more of as a warning than it being enforced in reality. So, to me Ghamidi sb’s stance sounds logical. Allah is capable and completely just in even giving somebody eternal punishment (for which He himself will give you justification, and by default we will be convinced as He is all-knowing). But unless somebody is being subjected to eternal punishment in hell, you can’t raise this objection – again, look at eternal punishment as a warning. So, your objection can be logically answered, at least to my understanding.
Listen to 5:50 to 6:10. Ghamidi Sahab says that suppose Allah does give eternal punishment, it will still be totally Just. That is an issue. How we can understand, that what kind of crime this is that Allah is willing to give eternal hell for. Sure He might not give it because as your video suggests, it is only a warning but if He makes it a reality, it would be totally justified……but how is it justified? What harm kufr/shirk/sarkashi does do to deserve eternal hell? https://youtu.be/6rzTcruILwU?t=350