Asking For Test First
Sister Fatima, meray khayal mein, iss ayat me Qur’an uthaanay ki bat nahi ho rahi, jis ‘trust’ ka zikr ho raha hy, wo hy ye ability ke hamari marzi jo chahay kerein (free will), iss ability ko lenay se zameen aasmaan ne inkaar ker diya qiun ke iss ability ke sath test bhi shuru hojata hy aur consequently jaza saza bhi hogi. Hum insaan hyn he isliye ke humnay ye free will le li.
sister maryam apka kehna sahi hai lekin kuch point phir bhi zehen me aaty hai,ke khuda ne free will ke liye pucha to unho ne inkaar kardiya kyunki iske baad test me parna tha,hame to ye tasawwur karna mushkin ho raha hai ki khuda inse puchega ke bhae zameen tum free will lena chahoge,asmaan tum ya pahad tum sabne mana kar diya or insaan ne le liya issy to ye zahir hota hai ke insaan ko ye samajh hi nahi thi jo in bejan cheezo ko thi ke ham isko leny se test me parjaenge,ek jagah quraan me hai ki adam a.s ki takhleeq karne ke baad farishto ne khuda se kuch pucha jiska javab khuda ne ye diya ki jo mai janta hun vo tum nahi janty or adam a.s se kaha ki fariston ko unsab cheezo ke naam batao jo mainy tumhe sekhaya hai to vo bata bety hai yaha pe to jo ilm farishto ko bhi nahi tha vo khuda ne insaano ko diya,itni izzat or azmat or ilm, or yaha par itna shaor bhi nahi diya ke in arz o sama se zyaada samajh sake,khuda ko puchny ke koi zarurat nahi vo to sabke zimmy kaam laga deta hai or koi ussy inkaar nahi karta. dusri baat ke zameen asmaan ya pahad free will ka kya karty jabki quraan insaano ki rahnumayi ke liye hai,zameen,asmaan,pahad ke liye to nahi hai ya unki bhi rahnumayi honi thi.thoda takrao tha sari baato me lekin jab hamne inki baat suni to ye ayat zyaada vazeh hogai,hosakta hai mera nazariya ghalat ho