Hadith About Ahl-e-Bait And Panjtan-Paak
According to Ghamidi Sahab, Quran is very clear as to who are Ahl-e-bait i.e wives of the Prophet (sws) . Therefore, there is no question left to be asked in deciding this point. However, as far as other members of Prophet’s family like Hazrat Ali (rta), Hazrat Fatima (rta) are concerned ( as mentioned in Hadith-e-Kisa ), they can be considered as ‘Ahl-e-Bait’ too, but only as a secondary category because Quran has clarified the primary category of ‘Ahl-e-Bait’, therefore, other people can only be included subservient to the primary ‘Ahl-e-Bait’–as a second tier category if you will or as an extension of the term ‘Ahl-e-Bait’. There’s no need to reject this narration, we just need to keep the hierarchy straight. Ghamidi Sahab has also briefly commented on Hadith-e-Kisa ( Narration of the cloak ) and other ahadith mentioning Ahl-e-Bait . Please refer to the video below from 1:27 to 9:30 https://youtu.be/JorIUMdOkKs?si=-pLkLLq-3kZzOmHd&t=87