Questions (Week: 09th November 2020 To 15th November 2020)
Question-04 : Carried Forward As per Ghamidi Sahab, we can keep a fast and do some extra khairaat (charity) on 12th rabi-ul-awwal but we cannot offer nafal Salah. When we can keep a nafal fast and do some extra khairaat then how come offering of nafal salah comes under Bidah? And what’s the basis of doing the first two ibadah and not the Salah ibadah becasue we do offer nafal salah in times of happiness – someone may do it on their wedding or on the birth of their child. Isn’t is a similar thing? Original Thread : Discussion 34962
Question-05 : We see that in result of the ittemam e hujjat by rasul saw mushrikeen and ehle e kitab were punished. What is the basis on which these two groups were dealt differently? Ghamdi saab said that the difference was ehle e kitab had originally tawheed in them. Mushrikeen also believed in Allah but used to do shirk just like ahl e kitab did. Is it as imam islahi says that ahl e kitab were not the direct addressees of prophet but the arabs as bani ismael were? Original Thread: Discussion 35579