Causes Of Hadith Fabrication
Point 1: Not a single Hadith in the entire Hadith corpus can be guaranteed to have 100% exact words of the Prophet (AS). No matter if the status is “Sahi” or anything else. Point 2: The authentically transmitted statement (or Hadith) from the Prophet (AS) is Quran (not Bukhari or Muslim). Point 3: Hadith is a historical documentation that has “no” independent religious directive as in Hadith does not “initiate” anything new in “religion” Point 4: There can be multiple reasons for fabribication (political, early converts, time gap, some other motives). Point 5: Hadith or isolated reports (without context) are understood in light of the Quran and Sunnah. Any Hadith that goes againt Quran, Sunnah, established knowledge and rationality is problematic (no matter Sahi).
I dont see any reason for you to copy paste same comment again. Pls. avoid this in future. Thanks
I thought you didn’t answer that .. so I repeated it.
This is 127 page document and will take a long time to read. .can you please answer my questions in summarized form ? I just posted 3 steps of a hadith from Prophet and I am asking direct question on what are the logically possible outcomes.