How To Determine A Hadith's Authenticity?
There’s a complete subject of Hadith Science in which a given narration is graded as Mauquf , Marfu , Maqtu , Hassan , Saheeh , etc. Generally when you read a particular narration, it should state the grade(s) as determined by one or more Hadith scholars. It’s important to note that the criteria and consequently the resulting grading of any narration can differ between Hadith scholars. Also, regardless of the grading, there’s still no certainty that a particular narration means what is apparent just from the words . Therefore, for a common person it’s best to learn Hadith narrations through scholars who spend a lot of time in understanding and explaining them in proper context. Ghamidi sahab’s principles of understanding Hadith are stated in the post below: Discussion 1042 For the hadith you quoted about camel urine, please see the following: Discussion 1790