Regarding Conditional Forgiveness Of Allah Swt
“Ghamidi sahab has already clearly stated his point that if God so wills, He can forgive any sin, however, He will not forgive any matters where the right of another person has been violated until that person also forgives” “…until that person has also forgives”. With respect, I want to assert that this is totally wrong concept which is only derived from human reasoning of Justice, not of Allah.Therefore, I will request to correct this concept.Because : 1.using,”until” and “unless” clearly create a dependency on another person like, ‘until I forgive him Allah will not forgive the person (as he wronged me).Thus, the wrongdoer’s forgiveness is depend on me.In the context of justice, it apparently sounds good.Howover, If someone says that Allah’s forgiveness depend on another person, I think it is great Shirk. 2.Regarding forgiveness, Allah will see a repentant’s sincerity,nothing else.Therefore, you could argue how a person can be sincere if he does not/cannot fulfil the rights of other, how he can become sincere in his repentance. That is another thing.Obviously, sincerity is a matter between a person and Allah. 3. If Allah’s forgiveness dependent on other person’s approval, the situation like in where wronged one curse,never forgive,died, negative emotions until wronged one does not forgive (until is a time bound term) etc will come up.Then many other fatua will be needed. These are very sensitive thing can conflict with the essence of monotheism. 4. Allah is just. But this does not logically conclude that he does not forgive a sin until the wronged one forgive.There are many ways Allah can serve just,we don’t know exactly.e.g He can allow the wronged one some other reward,baraqah in his life etc. Overall he can satisfy the person in many ways. He is the owner of our life and property.What I am not agreeing that you are giving an imaginative and fixed scenario of serving justing in which Allah needs the approval of other as you have put ‘until’. 5. The concept of Haqqul ibad is not derived from Quran and Sunna.People say this because of this hadith https://sunnah.com/bukhari:6534 Even the hadith does not indicate any dependency like until /unless. Moreover this hadith is not a part of sunna where Quran says Allah forgives all sin.