Fundamental Contradictions In Islam
Please go through material of Al mawrid and islamic resources again. 1- If you dont believe in hadith then it shouldn’t bother whether it says it 50 or 5 or any other number because you don’t believe it. Just for clarification, the whole incident was a dream as evident from this hadith https://sunnah.com/bukhari:7517 . In dream any thing can happen. For more details about Ghamidi sb understanding of the incident specifically episode 4 . please see Discussion 120473 2. If you think God has power and he can arrange a dead person to speak to living person in special circumstances. How it can be contradiction. The verse you referred is talking about something different in this regard. please read with context. 3. About timing of Prayers, one fundamentqal issue in understanding Quran is that every one thinks that it will tell everything from a to z. However, Quran rarely go into details when things are already common at that time. IT only corrects information which was wrongly practised at that time. When Quran talks about prayers, it donot intend to give details of number of prayers etc but giving specific detail according to context. the time of prayers have been described for 5 times which are quite distinct. Here are the timings – “Establish prayer at the two ends of the day and at the early part of the night …” (Hud 11:114) Ie fajar, maghrib and isha. – 17:78 verse talks about zuhur and fajar – 2:238 talks about ASr prayer 4. I am sure most muslims never read hadith about number of rakahs but practice what has been taught by teachers or parents. You are trying to imply before people werent praying until hadith were written. Secondly if hadith is history which can be mistaken then our own perception can be wrong too. Research on brain has already revealed to us how our mind play tricks. 5. According to Quran, all religions were same but people differed and created differences. So it there are similarities in other religion, it shows common ground not influence. similar question was asked to Ghamidi sb. see for his response Discussion 40677 • Reply 42560