Murdering A Self Proclaimed Prophet
Can I ask you a hypothetical question ? Let’s suppose for some time, that blasphemy punishment is approved by Prophet (assume that the hadith is sahih and it really happened that Prophet approved of killing the blasphemer) .. will you still say that killing of blasphemer is wrong or will you say that since Prophet approved of it, it is correct to kill the blasphemer ? In other words, I am asking if your opinion on a moral issue changes based on Prophet’s act/opinion or you think killing of blasphemer is morally wrong anyway ?
There is punishment for apostasy at least in the time of Prophet .. even Ghamidi saab agrees on it.. (after completion of proof).
Forget about itmam-e-hujjat for sometime .. is apostasy in itself a crime ? You said that the hadith is wrong, because Prophet would not have killed anyone for blasphemy, but you have no problem if the Prophet kills anyone for apostasy?
Allah’s commands will never be questioned by the Prophet sws or any other messengers. The Prophet sws carried out every command of Allah. His own inclinations are not being discussed
I am saying it again and again Islam does not prescribe any punishment for blasphemy. For apostasy the punishment was given during the time of the messengers by the order of Allah. This was finished after the Prophet sws time No state no person can give punishment for blasphemy or Apostasy in our present time. This is not his domain in this world.
After watching this video you can understand that mollanas are so powerful in Pakistan. They encouraged a fourteen years old boy to take the justice in hand and ruined his life