Variant Readings Of Quran: Invalid Reference Used In Book Meezan?
oh wow.. it already was raised to the ustaad. I am so humbled. Allah is so kind for us to bless us with an ability to reach out to scholars without having to leave our homes. Sorry sir but I think the question would need to be put in front of Ghamidi sahib with a bit more detail and context. It’s fine not to ask during a live recording. Instead present my point offline and a response offline would be completely fine as well. Thank you all!
It is not ok to recite other Qirats. But if someone does so individually while knowing the difference between Quran and Akhbar-i-Ahad Qirats, then this can be considered a minor deviance. But when a group of people recite these Qirats under assumption that all these Qirats are same and they equate akhbar-i-ahad Qirat with Arza-e-Akhira Qirat, then this would be a major deviance (zalalat/fikri gumrahi). The way to tackle this would be through academic discourse. This is the same ruling which is also applies to a group when they equate ahadith obtained through Akhbar-i-Ahad with Quran & Sunnah, and consider them a separate and indepenent source of religion. Please refer to the following responses of Ghamidi Sahab : Please refer to the following link : Discussion 21789 • Reply 21981 ______________________ Please also refer to the following video from 47:52 to 52:47 and from 59:37 to 1:01:21 https://youtu.be/oTx-5IF5HYE?t=2872