The Reality Of NAZAR (Evil Eye)
@Sohail Sahab! Do we have Ghamidi Sahab’s opinion specifically addressing those Ahadith?
“That’s why a lot of work needs to be done to actually make a sense of what Hazrat Ayesha (rta) in reality could’ve said.” What is the way to determine that ? Didn’t the hadith scientists already perform this task it by verifying the narrators’ reliability to the best of their ability ?
Doesn’t the narrator try to quote the Prophet or Aisha verbatim ? Or he narrates his own interpretation of the nazar (evil eye) statement from them (if they said it) ?
Could you explain the headache example of not being able to be tested in labs? Most headaches happen in the nerves, blood vessels, and muscles that cover a person’s head and neck. Sometimes the muscles or blood vessels swell, tighten, or go through other changes that stimulate the surrounding nerves or put pressure on them.