Is The Money Earned From Haram Way Also Haram In Itself?
@Irfan76 sir when it is said that anything that is caused by Haram is Haram to use. is this principle only used to some tangible asset or it’s in all and all dimensions. for example, if a person sells pork and earns money. with this money he goes to see a cinema to watch a movie. (his using money to watch movie was Haram). after watching movie he has flash backs and memories of the movie scenes. he sometimes thinks about the scenes of movie from his memory and enjoys those memory or laughs over the memory of those comedy scenes. will his this act (enjoying the memory of those scenes) be Haram to do as well? because the memory of those things came from watching movie which was Haram for him to watch because of the payment of it through Haram money. so would this rule be applicable in his imagination as well? (he using his memory imagination to get a benefit of making himself feel joyous) Ps. the scenes in themselves do not have any Haram action like porn or shirk or anything bad. they are normal comedy scenes
@Irfan76 sir I understand that they cannot be undone. but it wouldn’t be Haram if a person deliberately uses this memory to make himself joyous? similarly if a person tries to remmeber the scenes in order to write a novel based on similar story. his writing of that novel with deliberate thinking of that memory would be halal, and it would be halal to use it to entertain others and earn money over it etc?
@Irfan76 sir does this thing apply to feelings for people? for example, Ali wanted to become Azhar’s friend. and so he wanted to start friendship by initiating feelings of attachment inside Azhar’s mind with him by giving Azhar a gift. Ali decided to gift him an item which was Haram to give but Ali wasn’t aware of the prohibition. The gift given to Azhar. made Azhar realized that Ali gave him a gift which made Azhar develop a love and attachment feeling inside him for Ali. and they became friends, Ali used to bring him the same item for gift many times and slowly slowly the friendship developed stronger. after some months suddenly Ali realized that the first act he did to initiate the feelings in Azhar’s mind was Haram (I.e gifting that item). and only because of that act did Azhar started to develop feelings for him. later he had used this initial feeling in Azhar’s mind to accept more gifts and outings he planned with Azhar, which made him develop more feelings. (ie. if the initial feeling of love was not present then Azhar would have not accepted those outings plan with him). And also he used to gift him the same Haram item for gifts again and again. now after realizing the whole scenario, if he decides to continue relation with him would it be Haram? for example if he says Azhar to go on a vacation with him. Azhar would not go on a vacation with some stranger but only with someone with whom he has love and attachment with. so Ali knows that if he asks Azhar to go on vacation with him, the feelings in Azhar’s mind would play a vital role in going with him resulting in them both enjoying this trip., will it be halal for Ali to ask for this? one may say that since not all feelings of love are developed from Haram, some are from halal too. I would still ask that if for suppose all feelings developed were from Haram actions, would it be still Haram to use these feelings to get more things done and have good relation?
@Irfan76 sir same would be for knowledge that a person gained for example from a stolen book or through a teacher upon doing something Haram. his using of that knowledge to benefit himself won’t be Haram in itself. and if with this knowledge he does some service to someone and charges money then the money won’t be Haram as well. so both the action of using that knowledge for personal benefit, and for service to other for money. both of these actions are totally Halal right sir?