Contradiction In Interpreting The Prohibitions In Quran 2:173 And 7:33
Both Quran 7:33 and 2:173 have style of “ Hasar ” in them i.e. the use of “ اِنَّمَا ” as referring to “ Only ” these things. However, in both these instances the context of Hasar must be kept in mind. Quran 2:172 first talks about All Tayyibat being Halal and then 2:173 includes prohibition of only those four items among all Tayyibat (i.e. things which had potential to be considered as Tayyab ). While Quran 7:28 onwards is more broader in context where it talks about matters of “ Zeenat ” and that they have all been declared Halal by Allah and then comes Hasar that among every such thing only five matters have been declared Haram by Allah. For comments of Ghamidi Sahab , please refer to the video below from 48:44 to 52:21 https://youtu.be/RKCOvg5F_Z4?si=yGeicdaxd4Q9tUxL&t=2924