How Can We Reconcile Punishment Of The Grave Hadiths With The Quran?
My question was how can we reconcile these Hadiths which seem to place the punishment of the grave in this earthly pit with the Qur’an? How can we reconcile that part in the Hadith which talks about the returning of the soul to the body in this earthly pit with the Qur’an?
Quran does not give the details about it when those bodies will be given. It is based on the narration which is in conformity with the description of the Quranic verse. You may confine to the Quranic description and stay on the point that there is no definite answer to the question that when those bodies will be given.
From the Bukhari hadith we can see that all creation will be reconstructed from ajb-uz-zanb on the day of Qiyaamah. Since ajb-uz-zanb is normal visible matter, we should conclude that the bodies of Qiyaamah are not yet created, but will be created on Qiyaamah, and this will be done using normal matter. What can we make of these hadiths?