Marriage With Ahmadi
It’s not always about the community one is following but about the personal belief too. If one believes in the finality of prophet Muhammad saw as it’s proved from Quran and hadees and there is no doubt . But that individual is born to be ahmadi and he is searching upon the truth about ghulam ahmed qadiani. I think it’s permissible to marry such individual as they are not gustakh e rasool .
Theoretically u r correct, we can not declare anyone kafir or non-muslims But we can not use this in legal consideration regarding marriage, divorce, inheritance, child custody, adultery etc. There r many sects who insist they r muslims, Agha Khanis, Daruz, Nusairys, Yazidis, nation of islam etc. they all have 3 things in common adding another source of wahi, denying finality of prophethood of Muhammad SAW, denying 1 or more basic tenet of islam Sahaba didn’t regard such people as Muslims either Qadianis believe in another prophet and believe jihad is not part of Islam anymore in any way shape or form. I do not believe they can be regarded as Ahl e Kitab because firstly they didn’t receive revelation before and separate from Quran and secondly from Sahaba’s reaction to such sects and personalities. They were rejected and sometime fought. Sahaba didn’t regard their belief in the tauheed and Quran as testimony of their ahl e kitab status. I may be completely wrong so I would request to Please share any writings /lectures of Ghamidi sahab or any other scholar explaining the legal/academic reasonings.