Islamic Inheritance
There is no error in the Quran. How can we be judged regarding inheritance law if it is not clear for us to follow. The law is written very clearly. The verses of Nisa 11-12 gives a comprehensive view of the inheritance law. The verse 176 is an explanation of these verses when certain clarification was needed. It starts with the words “they ask you, so tell them…” Traditional scholars differs in some aspects 1. The traditional scholars don’t think the distribution of shares among deceased relatives can be done in complex situations as per Quran’s directives thus they recommend decreasing everyone’s shares to be able to distribute to assigned relatives. This is called Awl rule per sunni Scholars and Radd rule per Shia scholars. Ghamidi sahib has read the same verses as they are and shown how easy is to distribute to shares per God commands without cutting down the percentages. He add or subtracts nothing to the shares. He has shown us how to read the language and apply them. 2. The traditional scholars think the first verses refers to maternal siblings’ shares and v176 relate to real siblings but Ghamidi sahib thinks it is as it is written -both real and maternal brothers and sisters. Quran is not differentiating between them; otherwise it would have been clearly written. 3. The word Kalala meaning is also where Ghamidi sahib differs. You can read his explanation in his tafseer why he think grammatically his selection of the meaning is correct per Arabic grammar. The Quran is complete and free from errors. In Quran the laws are clearly written in clear Arabic. This inheritance law is where one can easily see why Ghamidi sahib understanding of the Quranic Language is so correct.
For an in-depth understanding of the Islamic Law of Inheritance, please refer to the following thread: Discussion 10380