Quran 9:10-13 Reason For The Directive Of War
The Usul of Ghamidi Sahab is to read the text of Quran as a coherent whole. How does a coherent reading of surah 9 ayat 1 to 15 support the narrative that the hukm to kill was for knowingly disbelieving? The text seems clear that other reasons are given, repeatedly, for the hukm to kill.
11. I.e., they are not much aware of religion and the institution of prophethood and hence deserve to be treated with lenience. It may well be possible that after a long period of preaching and pursuasion some aspect still remains in the conclusive communication of the truth. Hence, if any one of these people need asylum to hear and understand what was being presented to them, Muslims must give him this respite and after reciting and making him understand the word of God transport him to his place of safety so that he can calmly reflect and decide whether he has to accept Islam or die. After this, obviously he too will have to face the same directive that is mentioned earlier. this is Ghamidi sahabs tafsir of 9:6. This kind of hints that itmam e hujjat wasn’t completed- the people didn’t even know the message- the balagh as not done- so how would the punishment even after four months be justified? @faisalharoon I think you can delete the other conversation as it would be better if we also discuss 9:6 here