Ghamidi Sahab's Contradictory Views Regarding State And Muslim Individuals
The whole confusion is the first question. Ghamidi saheb did not say that Deen does not address the Muslims collectively. He said, Deen addresses a person, and these persons make a society therefore Deen addresses the society. Wherever the Quran uses the plural form of a word, it means to address the Muslims collectively. Deen addresses a person in every of his position, so if he is a ruler, Deen tells him his responsibilities.