Which Scholar Should I Follow
@UmerQureshi sir ap bhi is pe roshni dalye ma Janab Ghamidi sb ki raye ko ikhtayar krna chahti hn us ma muje apne lye zaida asani mehsos hoti ha wrna kya ma har kisi ko kehti hn meri birthday celebrate na kro na ma celebrate nai krti ya ye mushreekana roots rkhta ha jb k daleel tu dono scholars dete hn apni apni side ki zahir ha un ki daleel zaida sahi lagy gi jo traditional scholars hn k shirk sy link ha iska is lye celebrate nai krna wish nai krna insan kahy bt b thek ha aur safe side b ha lakin agr apni wish ko made nazar rkhte hove is raye ko ikhtyr kya jay jo Ghamidi Sahb ka opinion ha tu ma sahi path pe hun kiun k insan khush rehna chahta hn celebrate krna chahta ha lakin dosre scholars ki btain k ye shirk ha ye kufr ha ap deen se bahr hn etc insan ghamidi sahab ka opinion apna b ly tu aik emotional torture rehta ha k kahain hum shirk ma shamil tu nai ho rhy kiun k dosre scholars k mutabiq tu Hazrat essa A.S ki wapsi ko na manana apne aqeede sy inkar ha wo isko aqeedy ka hisa karar dete hn wo kehte apka iman mukamal nai is tarh ki baton ma insan kry tu kya kry ye kehna asan ha ap unki he bt sunain ap dosra opinion apna lein traditional jaisy salon sy chalta arha lakin is sy mehsos hota deen tu bht tang ha koe khushi nai kuch nai mushkil ha deen sth ma ye ehsas b jari rehtaha k hum shirk tu nai kr rhy ya shamil tu nai ho rhy aisy ma kya krna chahye confusion waly answer tu har koe dy rha k mutmain nahi rehnumai farma dijye JAZAK ALLAH