Ruling About Improper Dress
No I don’t agree with the idea of haq talfi. Haq talfi is eagles too collective not individual
So far as an ideal dress is concerned, it’s not available. We can decrease the simulations of emotion but not fully stop. As by wearing helmet, we decrease the chance of injury not stop.
how to run affairs, which are not wholly in control of me? ask permission to all those who can make to control the matter wholly, in community, new disease spread, doctors try to control it. anyone wanting to stop them? with what? knowledge or power? trying to stop with knowledge, do sabr, then hear that person, look at evidences, do continuous experiments.. if the given statement is objective truth, then all the doctors and people of knowledge are agreed to him.. trying to stop with power, do sabr and spread the truth, more power used to suppress then disassociate from community openly! more power used even to kill you, then do migration, if in the concerned community people don’t believe in God and that this whole universe will end one day and also not prohibit what God & his messenger made prohibited & also don’t follow the objective truth, then announce war against those who rejected your objective truths, until they pay yearly sum of money to you, and remain as less dignified of rest of citizens salam..
for a logical and definite end, I want to conclude all the discussion till now *part 1* first of all, my point of view was “The ruling criteria of any state is always in the welfare of citizens. It’s not necessary that majority of citizens are happy with that ruling or not. If that ruling is in the favor of civilian then that law will be enforced forcefully.” Ghamidi Sb point of view is “laws can only be enforced when there is haq talfi and ziadti” additionally he said that we can also enforce law related to adultery prohibition. I supported my argument with two examples in counter of ghamidi sb stance 1. forcefully polio vaccination 2. wearing helmet 3. wearing seat ballet none of this example can be categorized in haq talfi or ziadti Now, there are two situations: a. interpret these examples according to ghamidi sb stance b. interpret ghamidi sb stance according to these examples *part 2* this part of my question is related to obscenity. we all are agree that improper dress causes obscenity in society. obscenity makes imbalance in society. how to enforce people to wear proper dress. @faisalharoon @umerqureshi @irfanshehzad