Why Just One Creator?
Are you referring to ‘we have no way of knowing this for certain’?
I’m simply saying your claim is correct but disregards a possibility of multiple creators
I specifically tried to disregard kalaam. Yes a necessary being cannot have any shared traitd because that means the trait icontingent and therfore any being possessing them is not necessary. But I want to see the Quran’s claim. How does the Lord of the Worlds argue that he exists? He does so by what Sir Faisal seems to be calling a ‘hypothetical claim’. The Quran uses the ‘hypothetical claim’ that if there was more than one creator, there would be anarchy
The assumption that fitra/intuition can lead to multiple Creators is not correct. Only mind, if left unchecked, can lead us on that path. We have examples of many great mythologies and philosophical ideas that humans have created, but when we analyze them, we find no sound basis of those ideas. Ghamidi sahab has explained fitra very extensively in these videos: Discussion 30094
The mythologies and philosophies are just a part of the human imagination that find no basis in reality. My claim cannot be compared to that. Is my basis not sound? That is what I am asking. How is my analysis of the universe incorrect in this matter?
Correct. If only the universe is analyzed, and it’s analyzed only by computers and/or robots, then they could reach such an inconclusive answer. When we discuss things here, we’re discussing in the context of humans who are born with a-priori knowledge/fitra, who experience the universe in light of that knowledge, who have intellect and the power to reason, and who are aware of the history of messengers of God on earth.
And your argument about egos and teams. This would only be true if you concede that God is egoistic
If you still have questions, listen to the audio yet again 😂