When Is Income Earned Be Categorized As Haram?
@Umer25 sir, can you provide verses from the Quran and also hadiths about income? I want to know whether my argument is still in accordance with the Quran and Sunnah or not I won’t ask the previous question, I just want to ask about this one thing, sir. Please answer it, sir.
Money earned from any activity which in itself is a Haram activity (major or minor) is prohibited. I didn’t understand the beach example.
I am not aware of these details. But if this is true then yes, your conclusion is correct.
I’m not aware of this business and how it works or how it looks. But from a principle point, if there is exposure of fawahish involved the way you described in the previous reply i.e. creating and showing private parts that look like female private parts or making replica of exact naked body of a woman etc. then it is fawahish and such a business will be considered prohibited in religion.
Even if they are not real people, still there are some issues involved. Think of it this way, just the way we will consider selling nude/naked sketch or painting of a female body as Haram, similarly selling nude dolls replicating a female body cannot be considered as allowed.
Your first example is correct. The second and third examples, however, are not accurate. If a person creates kissing videos as part of a “social experiment,” the act itself remains impermissible, and producing such content is not allowed. In contrast, if a movie or drama includes a minor level of intimacy while the primary purpose of the production is not objectionable, then the income earned from that work cannot automatically be declared haram. Still, it is important to understand that a person is accountable for any impermissible actions they engage in. These are two separate matters: the income may not be entirely haram in certain situations, but the sinful act itself remains a sin and the individual is responsible for it.