Questions List (Week: 10th May 2021 To 23rd May 2021)
Question 2: Carried Forward Why Muslims chose rebel against Allah order to follow Quran (6:114, 7:52, 10:37,7:185. 31:6, 45:6, 77:50) Why follow Sunnah o hadith when Quran donot say to follow these. Quran has clearly mentioned Isha optional (17:79). Muslims have made it farz based on some outdated literature. Does not it show rebellious nature of Muslims against Allah word? Original Thread: Discussion 44733
Question 4: Carried Forward Is marrying Step Sister from father Halal Or Haram Or Disliked? This question has been asked in reference to Saudi Ulema Council which has allowed to marry step sister ( https://www.google.com/amp/s/islamqa.info/amp/en/answers/33711 ) Original Thread: Discussion 45816
Question 5: Carried Forward In a recent Nikah sermon at occasion of Jibran marriage by Ghamidi shb, he specifically mentioned the equality and equal fazeelat of husband and wife (“یہ بالکل برابری کی سطح کا رشتہ ہے”) which made me a bit confused about his usual stance of husband having fazeelat over wife, husband being a CEO of family etc. Can Ghamidi sb clarify this Original Thread: Discussion 47452
Question 13: Carried Forward (This question has been asked several times on AG and people are having trouble grasping the rationale behind the answers already provided. Therefore, Comments of Ustad would be helpful): What does the Islam say about women who choose to not bear children for non-medical reasons? Is it frowned upon or is it permissible? Can the husband force her to have children? Original Thread: Discussion 49134
Question 15: Carried Forward Why Quran repeats same stories of prophet again and again? Original Thread: Discussion 48918
Question 18: In Surat 33 Verse 33, the wives of the Prophet PBUH have been asked to remain in their homes and in 33:53 they have been asked to speak to men behind a curtain. And Ghamidi Sahab is of view that these directives were of permanent nature for the Wives of the Prophet (sws) and even Hazrat Umar (rta) made sure that these directives were followed after Prophet’s (sws) demise. If this is the case, then how can we explain the fact that after the death of the Prophet PBUH, Hazrat Aisha became a scholar, debated laws with male companions and narrated thousands of hadiths. Also she participated in the Battle of the Camel and gave speeches and led troops on the back of her camel. Original Threads: Discussion 49844 Discussion 50171
Question 19: I need guidance on an illegal extension of inherited property which we (5 siblings + mother) inherited less than a year ago. It is known by the elders of the same area that the house we live in (along with many other houses in the same row) have an illegal extension carried out many many years ago. The extended area belongs to Riasat i.e. Govt. of Pakistan. I am willing to pay for it but I don’t find a viable solution. Demolishing the extended part is extremely hard as my brother’s family is living there. Paying it off is also very difficult it would open a Pandora box with legal and judicial problems and may also effect all the house in the same row. My questions are: 1. Can I calculate the due amount of the extended part and deposit it in any of the Govt. of Pakistan donation account? 2. Will that suffice for my father as well as I also want to pay on his behalf as a loan on me? 3. Is there any better way of doing it? Original Thread: Discussion 50132