A Question Regarding Branch Application Of An Ayat
@Irfan76 yes yes sir I am not asking the previous question that if I earn something as a Haram earning and use it. in previous questions, my question dynamic was that if for example I earned a printer as a remuneration for Haram action then the use of that printer will be Haram but once used, the effects of it, i.e a printed document will not be Haram to use further , because what I’m benefiting from now, will be the paper (my halal earned) and the ink (also halal earned). the only effect the printer produced was imprinting that ink in a design to the paper (that will turn it into a readable document). Here just a question came after reading that ayah and looking at the way ghamidi Sahab explained it. I thought came that is it possible that according to this ayah, as a branch of it’s illat, will bidah/hilla and shirk be considered differently from general rule?? for example that if while using the Haram printer, if I had made a deliberate bidah convincing myself that “it is not Haram to use the printer”. then in this case, it’s effect ;the printed document will become Haram to benefit from further as well? (unlike above paragraph, where it’s halal to use because now in reading the document, the printer won’t be used anymore)
@Irfan76 Okay sir, so the extension of Haram only exist to the Haram earned item itself and not the effects produced by those items am i right sir? if I’m right sir, then can you just tell me that the effects produced (already written document). making use of those effects further will not remain Haram, but under which explanation of the 2 following? 1- the effects delivered are not always the part of Haram item itself. When we make use of those things further (written/printed document), what we make use of, at this stage is actually the basic already halal paper and ink (that was just arranged in a design and pasted on the paper). The exception of this would be when the object obtained is part of the Haram earned item itself, like in case of cow. when i earn a cow for my Haram work, i am not given the ownership of cow only, but everything produced by its body as well ie milk, wool. so the milk and wool is itself the part of Haram earned item so it will remain Haram. 2 – if effects are considered too, in prohibition, then Deen will become difficult as well. so instead of bounding people to see what effects after being produced, they can avoid relatively easily and then bounding them to avoid it, except when it becomes hard. Deen altogether removed this chapter and no matter if it’s hard to avoid the delivered effects or not. people are not bound to avoid the produced effects as well. like in the above case, avoiding a paper to not read it (the printed document) is not much difficult but still Deen doesn’t bound anyone to leave it and they can continue using that printed paper for benefit. So sir which explanation is in fact in place?