Harsh Punishment For The Denial Of Truth
Fitrah doesn’t answer the questions I raised above. As it’s glaringly evident from history, humans have always been shooting in the dark in regards to criminal law. For example, male rape has only been recently recognized as a crime by the humanity, with certain countries still having no laws in this regard. Even female rape had no laws in various parts of the world where anyone could rape anyone except a rich woman without the fear of any consequences. Marriage by kidnapping a woman has been legal and very common practice in certain parts of the world. Forced marriages are still legal in certain countries. Similarly, capital punishment has had a spotty history as well. The answer to the question is satisfactory enough for those with insight. Those who make such baseless objections on Islam will first have to come up with answers to the questions I raised above before their questions can even be given any due consideration.
That is a good answer. I will ponder over what you said and start a new question if I have any further queries.
Perhaps but as brother Faisal explained above, it’s a question that can’t be answered by humans because Allah’s perfect standard of justice are beyond our comprehension and that all we can do is, hope that Allah is Just and Merciful in the end. I do not think Ghamidi Sahab will give a different answer from his student. I am, however, discussing things with the other brother because they might have a different way of tackling the issue or that I am able to explain my issue more in details so others may understand why I am giving this issue so much importance.