How Does Allah Decide Who Will Be His Messenger ?
Why did you use her for Allah SWT
It’s Allah’s will and prophethood is his blessings he grants it to whom he wants. Allah is our creator and he has absolute knowledge and he does what’s he wants and you can’t understand it without submission otherwise you tried to find to kji in deen what’s Allah demand to you to become a good human polite and humble offer prayers do zakat and you are wasting yourself in such question. What will you after find the standard of prophecy? So it’s enough for us that they are Allah’s chosen people and Allah created them for our guidance that’s it fulfill your religion demands with this belief that it’s for your betterment.
Then give me answer of your question.what do you think about it.
In my opinion, some men claimed to be the messengers/prophets .. their claim is not proven to be true .. humans have been doing it for centuries.. even now many God-men are alive and present in various parts of the world and their followers think them to be Prophets … while others think that they are liars. Evidence for ALL of them is pretty poor…
The problem is.. the followers will ALWAYS have reasons to believe that their hero’s claims are matching with established history. Wasim Akram is my favourite player.. so I find any bad bowling clips of him as having some other reasons, or mostly I ignore them.. we all do it with the people who are our favourites.
I am absolutely with you in this claim and this got me thinking one time as well. But then, when you view the 1400 year history and the damage different sects have contributed in damaging and defaming different figures due to their own agendas/biases, then you start thinking with a clear mind.
I am not sure who called Muhammad al-sadiq .. but I know that many Arabians called him mad and many opposed him as a false Prophet.. now we can call all of them liars .. but that is the case with every false Prophet.