Did Prophet Beat Ayesha Ra.
The same riwayah is translated differently to state “nudge on the chest”. https://sunnah.com/muslim/11/132 The question is why does it really matter? Whatever Ghamidi sahab thinks about this riwayah is still someone’s opinion about a 1500 year old story which may or may not be true, but more importantly, doesn’t make a grain of a difference in the message conveyed to us by the prophet SAW. Wouldn’t it be better that we focus on that message, try to live by it, and tell others around us about it, rather than wasting our time and energy on things that don’t really matter?