Abortion Of A Disabled Foetus After 120 Days Of Conception
I agree with Faraz sahib. If we came to know with such knowledge+ technology and advancement in science then we should take decision according to it. The lady in village didn’t know what they are going to face and child would die after birth Because it can’t survive without medications to keep duct open. So new born death rate is different in such areas. And again Faraz sahib made a valid point. And also We are loosing faith in religion. You let us suffer on the name of religion, luckily just giving stance as haram on abortion is different and facing the reality is different. Still u don’t have any valid logic of giving Ruh after 120 days . You just have information of completion process ,even though some fetus took more time/ days to get embryo and become a complete fetus . What distinguishes a fetus without Ruh and with Ruh , days are just numbers , when my wife had first pregnancy there was just an empty sack till 7 weeks without embryo. And that pregnancy heart beat started at week 10 approximately, however, we know as it usually started in 5 1/2or 6 weeks of gestation. Faraz sahib is Right. Now I realize this is not an Islamic issue.
With due respect ,I suggest ghamdi foundation should collect the information related to what is going on in technology , and pregnancy and developmental issues (everything) and then give us some up-dated fatwa on such topic please. Otherwise there is nothing different from what we get from ghamdi sahib and what we listen from a mullah ,sitting in a small city ,with just a same knowledge, on this topic without any know how,as how things works now a days ,what type of information we can get now when baby is in womb etc. Hope you could understand the sensitivity of this topic as well. Jaza-kumullah
Brother Muhammad, I can not say I understand what you are going through but I do have some idea of the pain and the weight of decisions you have to make as a father and a husband I would request you not to put Ghamidi sahab and his students in the same scale as our traditional scholars! I owe my religious understanding to Imam Islahi RA and Ghamidi sahab along with many of his students like Shehzad Saleem, Sajid Hameed, Rafi Mufti, and more recently, brothers Faisal, Umer, Ahsan and Irfan sahab. I do not have appropriate words to express my gratitude for these personalities and their teacher Ghamidi sahab. My conclusion in this matter is derived from the ideas, objectives I learned by reading and listening to Ghamidi sahab over the years Ghamidi sahab has the responsibility to give Allah’s intention in all walks of life and this particular matter deals with taking life away from a human being and I can not think of any matter more important and delicate than this. His opinion is absolutely correct religiously, however, very very respectfully I disagreed with him on non-religious grounds.