Sahih Bukhari 5093 – Women And Evil Omen / Bad Luck
Salam , btw Faisal sahab, thnks for clarifying that our contribs are welcome….i had been hesitant earlier in contributing. btw Zayf sahab ,I found a salafi opinion here https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WfZS3KNL214 (I’ve already read salafi islamqainfo too) . Although imvho according to my deficient understanding, their salafi way of understanding hadeeth is different from ghamidi sahab. It appears as soon as there is a saheeh label and that too for more than one narration, they would go onto say it must be that content of all narrations with saheeh label is true. Thus it seems as a princpal they would forcefully reconcile all narrations. Rather than thinking this part of conversation may have been missed out from that particular narration etc. I think the “if” part in bukhari 5094 strenghtens drshehzad’s narrative. I do not know drshehzad’s source though. In general it appears believing in (superstitions/bad omens) are disliked in our deen so this perhaps also strengthens drshehzad’s narrative. To be very honest reading hadeeth narrations independently(not in light of other sources) have caused me doubts as well. I think it is because we have lots of material, and narrators might have misunderstood etc.