Ahd-e-Alast And Committing Shirk Unknowingly
According to this verse, the covenant of Alast is binding on every person whether that person lives in isolation or belongs to any religious group. The example quoted by you was very apt since everyone knows murder is not a good thing because it is also part of our innate morality just like innate concept of God. However, when one believes in that and still commits either of these acts not consciously but because of a certain interpretation then other factors would need to be considered as well, like the interpretation itself, honesty of a person while following that interpretation, what was that person’s attitude when presented with counter arguments, whether that person knowingly rejected those arguments as well and followed the wrong discourse etc etc. Following two videos will also be helpful in this regard: Discussion 37854 • Reply 37863 Discussion 55838 • Reply 55882