Salah And Responsibility Of The State
Mene takreeban poori video dekhi hai aur jo samjh Aya hai ke Ghamidi sb ne kaha hai ke namaz yaa roza rakhna aap kisi par farz Nahi karskate aur ispe saza dena hakoomat ko koi haq Nahi deta jo bilkul Shai baat hai. Ghamidi sb ne kahi jagah apni videos mai yeh bhi kaha hai ke namaz, roza wagaira yeh sab insaan Allah se muhabbat aur taaluq ke lihaaz se in par amal karta hai jise Allah aur insaan ka taaluq mazboot hota hai. Iski ek Bahut khubsurat misaal yeh di thi ke jistarah hum apni waalida ke kisi hukm ko muhabbat aur izat mai nahi taal sakte tou Allah ke hukm par bhi usi tarah amal Karte hain. Yeh taaluq sirf ek fard ka uske khuda se hai mere roza rakhne par yaa namaz parhne par hakoomat koi dakhal andaazi Nahi karsakti. Maazrat ke saath yeh kahoon ga ke Dr Israr ki Bahut baaten mujhe Sahi Nahi lagi aur Ghamidi sb ne Bahut tafseel aur asaan lafzon mai is maamle par roshni daal di hai.
Please listen to Ghamidi Sahab’s response here: Discussion 25671 • Reply 25768
I still am confused. It is not clear. Ghamidi sb says government can ‘force/ interfere’ for people to pray in an Islamic state . BUT how ??
[These believers are those who], if We grant them authority in this land, will establish regular prayers and pay Zakah and enjoin what is virtuous and forbid what is evil. (22:41)