How Does Allah Decide Who Will Be His Messenger ?
“Sorry to say, the morality displayed by these Prophets is not exactly very good.” What is the source of your claim?
There are hadiths where Prophet permitted lies to kill the enemy .. now how can he be called truthful if he permitted lies ? If I present the hadith, people may say it is a fabricated hadith.. so by that logic, every account which violates his truthfulness or morality, will be called fabricated..by this logic, I can prove Hitler also the most merciful ruler.
No body will take this seriously if you say Hitler was a merciful leader because the whole world is aware of atrocities committed by Hitler. The world doesn’t need anyone’s narration / Akhbar-i-Ahad to know that because it is an established history which doesn’t depend upon any single narrator transmitting it. However, regarding certain nuances of Hitler’s life, what he spoke at a certain day or how he acted at a certain event, we need to depend on those narrations / Akhbar-i-Ahad, but those narrations have no bearing on the established history that has consensus of the masses (ijma). Furthermore, to study our take on Prophethood, please refer to these threads: Discussion 15736 Discussion 16063 Discussion 16080 Discussion 16087