Halal Becomes Impermissible If Certainly It Will Cause Unintentional Sin?
Such unintentional thoughts are natural to occured. Humans cannot avoid them. To reject them is what is required. This the test they have to go through all the time. They are not supposed to avoid all the halal for such instant thoughts. It is not possible.
@Irfan76 sir as anything unintentional does not cause sin. and even if we do some halal action knowing certainly or near certain that an unintentional sin would happen, then still we don’t earn any sin even if that unintentional sin occurs, neither for the sinful action neither for doing halal action while knowing that such thing will be caused so I wanted to ask 2 examples 1 – As we know that if someone says words of kufr to save his life, then this haram is not counted as sin, similar to an unintentional sin. So if for example there’s 2 highways from city A to city B. And one of the smaller and easier highway (H1) is controlled by a tyrant tribal leader, who catches anyone who passes by this highway and then makes them utter words of kufr for the sparing of their lives and the one who doesn’t says it is shot dead. Now Ahmad wants to go to city B from A. he knows that if he goes through H1 he’ll be made to say küfr words. the other highway (H2) is a little longer and it would take more petrol to take that highway. so if he goes through (H1) highway while knowing about tribal leader, and then he gets caught and is made to say küfr words… will he be sinful for going through this highway? 2 – A tyrant ruler of a city makes everyone who goes out of city, say küfr words or get killed. Ahmad is a citizen of that city. – one time he goes out of city to get his father’s expensive medicine from outside – Then he has to again go out of city to work as he works in an office that is located out of city – And in evening he plans to go out of city because their is no gym in his small city and he drives to another city 30 mins, to go to gym. – he then plans for next day to go out of city to buy some new clothes for his children. Here will he be Islamically required to not go out for purposes of gym? buying new clothes? and for office? I mean will he be Islamically required to minimize his travel as much as possible? and if he goes out of city for purposes like getting new clothes or for gym, then will he be sinful when he gets caught up by ruler and is forced to say words of kufr?
@Irfan76 and sinful thought needing to be avoided is meant that we only are required to do not dwell on these feelings deliberately, and this what is totally required. we are not Islamically required to avoid that halal action because of instantaneous thoughts… and we are only required to try to remove the thought as much as we can once we realize it’s there, am I right sir? and sir as you said “If someone believes they cannot avoid sinful thoughts or behavior, they may choose to refrain from using something that is halal.” what I understand is you meant as sinful thought or act which is somewhat deliberate and intentional, But you are not not talking about unintentional sin here right sir? in summary, if a person thinks that he will surely fall into a haram thought/behavior but it be only unintentional, so here he is allowed to leave the halal action but he’s NOT REQUIRED to leave it… And if he does that halal action and later on does fall into that Haram thought/behavior unintentionally, then he would still not be sinful at all. am I right sir?