Explanation Of Hurmat-e-Musahirat
Some narrations tell that Nikah in such cases does not go invalidated, while some others say that it goes invalid. The narration of Umme Hani does not specify that it was narrated from the prophet. Two different narrations are narrated from Ibn Abbas. No narration is unobjectionable. The matter is of Ijtihaad. Accordingto Ghamdi saheb there is not grounds to declare alrady established nikah invalid due to Zina with in law mehram. The narrations in favour of Ghamidi saheb’s opinion are in principle, right.