Causing Others To Do A Sin By Doing A Sin, Or A Generic Halal
@Irfan76 okay sir I understand your point. but the question comes about that what comes under inappropriate? Muslims consider something to be inappropriate if it’s sin or is a violation of command of Allah. As Allah has commanded us to not do Zina. so we term Zina as inappropriate. but there are some things which lead to Zina like lustful touch or staring a woman. they would have been not inappropriate thing, had Allah not commanded us to avoid these actions too. so when Allah commanded us to not do these actions too, in the words of “la taqrabu” then we understood that doing these things will be violation of this guidance of Allah, hence Muslims term it as inappropriate. Ghamdi Sahab also when explaining the rule of sadde zariya said some words like this “Yeh cheezen aslan Haram nahi hotin, magar inki janip bharne se andesha hota hai ke maamla wahan Chala Jayega, toh is baab mein in cheezon se bhi roka hata hai” I meant to put forward this question sir, that isn’t it like Muslims only call anything religiously inappropriate, if it’s sinful? and if Allah hadn’t commanded “la taqrabu” or commanded to lower gaze , then a lustful stare may have not been considered inappropriate by Muslims. I mean if it was something inappropriate in itself, innately, then even without these commands, it would remain inappropriate. but what I understood is that the reason Muslim calls these actions inappropriate is because of these commands of Quran of lowering gaze and “la taqrabu”. so how to relate these aspects… that under the command of “la taqrabu” only those things come which are inappropriate themselves (for applying this principle it’s logical that we should first know by our nature, which things are inappropriate [independent of guidance of sharia], in our nature). only then can we identify which things are innately inappropriate and hence fall under this command. But if we don’t know innately, inappropriate things (In this matter, not others) then we would logically call only call those things inappropriate which are violation of Allah’s command. sir can you please help me understand what do you mean when you say is something inappropriate itself? and how to look into this matter in above paragraph. I mean it becomes a confusing circle, if we call lustful stare, inappropriate because of an existing command of Allah then it means it was not Inappropriate itself but after command of Allah ,it became inappropriate. but we also say for application of “la taqrabu” , only those things will come under it which are inappropriate themselves. it means we should be able to identify which things are inappropriate (separate from the guidance of shariah) in our nature, so that we put it under category of “la taqrabu”. and then say that his is command of Allah. sir if I couldn’t explain my point to you, please let me know I’ll try to explain more. Please help me in this regard of understanding the roots.