Why Should We Believe In History Written By Muslims?
Brother I keep asking u why don’t you have the same concerns about history of other nations/cultures? Why u r not insisting that holocaust histories written by Jews shouldn’t be believed? The reason of doubting, if sound, should be applied to all histories and not just histories written by Muslims Why u r thinking that history is corrupted? The hadith u quoted doesn’t mean that historians lied. Many things r reported that can prove that historians regarded Muhammad SAW as a person and not an angel.
In addition to what Faraz sahab has stated, it must be appreciated that k nowledge is a journey, not an event. We can only make our decisions based upon what’s reasonably evident. If our data changes, we can always revisit our beliefs as we must. There’s no problem in investigating history to figure out any discrepancies that may impact our beliefs, however, simply questioning history without any evidence to the contrary is just counterproductive.