Objection On Usool E Hadith
My friend that objection is completely absurd. There’s no field of knowledge where every hearsay story or idea is accepted as truth. Why would Hadith science be any different? The absolute best that could be expected of such situations is that rejected material be documented, and we already have that. Of course we can’t be certain what Muhaddathin might have still left out which they didn’t even bother to document. However, even if we could achieve absolute certainty that they documented every single lie and hearsay story, it still would not change anything. Today we have volumes of documented fabricated narrations. Was it able to change the knowledge that we have received with utmost certainty? Each one of such narrations would still be rejected today in the light of the Quran and the Sunnah.