Hadith That Allah Has Commanded Me To Spare My Beard
@UmerQureshi @Irfan76 Brother here in this video ghamidi sahab mentions that in this narration the word used (somewhat similar) are ‘we do what is against your Sunnah (way)’ But there is an article from a website where they mentioned that, according to tabqat ul Kubra of Ibn Sa’d the words are ; and the words according to at-Tabari the words are; So if we look at these words the word of ‘Amr’ is used, which they translate to ‘Commanded’. which again raises some question. Secondly they also mentioned that this incident is sound as well And in the 23 questions series of Ghamidi Sahab regarding beard, he mentioned that the Hadith regarding 10 things from Fitrah, Ghamidi Sahab mentioned that the narrator forgot 10th item, then narrator said like ‘Maybe it was …. thing’ and ghamidi Sahab said that if we even add this item to the list then a very big thing from Fitrah is left out which is ‘circumcision’. In the article they mentioned that, even if circumcision is left out, it does not dis-credit the Hadith because the Hadith (i guess) does not indicate that these are the ONLY things from Fitrah. which feels a valid argument. and they also quoted a Hadith below which again raises some more questions; Now if the Hadith mentioned above is sahih and sound. then it again raises question regarding it being from Fitrah and that even if the item of ‘circumcision’ is left out from the Hadith mentioning 10 items, it is not a problem at all. As a matter of fact, that article has presented a quite healthy strong criticism of the Ghamidi sahab’s stance on beard. The link to that website article is this ; https://waqarakbarcheema.wordpress.com/2013/07/05/putting-ghamidi-in-meezan-2-critique-beard-ahadith-analysis/ So how is the stance of Ghamidi Sahab explained with this criticism? Ps. the paragraphs written between tags are words of the article. And the Hadith presented above is from article ( i am not sure about it’s authenticity)