Causing Others To Do A Sin By Doing A Sin, Or A Generic Halal
@Irfan76 sir there’s a confusion in my mind. in the example I sited above. the moment his actions manifest, the sin will manifest too because of his intention. and we want him to do this act. will we be counted as “wanting other person to do Haram?” or not. and in this example there was a confusion between 2 principle, about which one to give preference here. one principle is “no one is responsible for others action” the other principle is “do not help in sin and transgression”. and there’s another example if a taxi driver picks a man and the man says him to drop him at a temple. scholars in this example give preference to “do not help in sin and transgression” principle. and say this is Haram for driver. are the scholars correct here? or is other principle going to apply here? sir can you please explain me how to distinguish between where which principle is to be applied?
sitting beside a woman is a direct cause, but it is allowed in certain cases, like woman in need asks for help, etc. so the man has to decide in the given situation.