Suicide
1. Kindly watch the video carefully, Ghamidi Sahab did not ask questioner to suicide, he pointed out why people simply don’t commit suicide, that why a lot of us stop and ask questions rather than just killing ourselves. Because we love life, we know suicide is wrong and it is a tragedy, and no one considers it a wise decision. This inner attraction to life is one of the signs that we want to live, we want to be tested by Allah, we did agree to His deal and came into this life wholeheartedly. 2. Yes you will be a culprit, and video explains it. We did agree to exist. Both our inner nature testifies and Allah’s revelations through years of prophets confirms it. We do not need to remember our meeting with God (especially since it will break the test), simply pondering over the arguments and revelations will convince people the point, no one needs to remember. And if a patient of amnesia is refusing to remember and dodging treatment in hopes of avoiding responsibility, then that patient is also a culprit. And a person refusing to believe he came out of his mother’s womb mainly because he can’t remember is making poor argument as the video implies. Such a point will not be accepted on Day of Judgment. 3. Your soul existed because Allah wanted it. He does whatever He wants and creation has no say in it as the video stated. But to be tested here, seems to be a choice that He took out of a favor (Qur’an 33:72). Which makes suicide even less valid and making one a culprit very likely. We are under contract with God, we should not back down from our words. It is also not wise to rebel against God.