Namaaz In Urdu
Reasons for performing Namaaz in one’s own language. (It could be wrong. It needs clarification) 1. Namaaz was also farz on other prophets ummah. And they use to perform in their own language. So why are we all need to perform in a language (Arabic) that we don’t understand.
Reasons for performing Namaaz in one’s own language. (It could be wrong. It needs clarification) 3. (According to Shabir Ally) There’s nothing in Quran and Sahi-Hadees to make Arabic language compulsory for Salah.
Yes I understand that there would be a consensus recorded in fiqh books so what fiqh books mention this issue and say it must be in Arabic? As mentioned above I don’t think imaam Abu hanifa agrees
Here are a few testimonies… I can attest to the last 40 years and my father can attest to an additional 50 years and my father confirms that his father confirmed for another 30 years that the prayer was being performed in this manner and in Arabic language. I am sure we can easily collect sufficient testimonies around the World to prove Ijma and twatur. We can also look at old books and old info. Isn’t this how it is suppose to work?
https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLvDnnnkYLWQd-CLG93wcqDsS2K4SIztMr In this playlist from part 44 to 51 there are 8 lectures of Ghamidi Sir (each around 1 hour) explaining the topic “Principles of Determining the Sunnah” I will study this first then I’ll check the proof of ijmah for this issue then only I can decide about my viewpoint. Now I am undecided. Till then let’s consider that it is compulsory for us to recite the Quranic part only in Arabic. Now let’s discuss the second part of the question: “Agar waqai ham log paband hain to kya yeh sahi hai ki ham sirf recitation sikh len, cheezon ko rat len aur bagair samjhe padhne ko kafi mane. Aksar madaaris aur Islamic schools isi ko sahi mante hain aur yahi talim dete hain.” What is the correct way of learning the arabic? @faisalharoon sir, brother @AhmadShoaib , brother @altmash , brother @Sonnadi