Is Every Kind Of Music And Signing Permissible In Islam?
Please see the following for Ghamidi sahab’s stance regarding music and fine arts in general: Discussion 1150 • Reply 1150 and Discussion 39704 • Reply 39720 For detailed argument about his stance, please see: Discussion 55241 Halal and haram are not arbitrarily determined in Islam. To understand the principles of determining halal and haram, please refer to: Discussion 1749
https://www.javedahmedghamidi.org/#!/hadith/5e537affc824c8e12d5583e6?articleId=5e539c6ec824c8e12d558444 https://www.javedahmedghamidi.org/#!/hadith/5e86dab8c824c8e12d564429?articleId=5e86eabac824c8e12d56448c all sahi and hassan rawat regarding singing which ghamdi saab is talking in 4 part of 23 objection series