Murdering A Self Proclaimed Prophet
He is suggesting that a muslim who commits blasphemy, should be killed because of apostasy.. and not because of blasphemy… it is even worse.
No I don’t think so. Even during the Prophet sws time no body was punished for uttering words against the Prophet sws. The Muslims were told to ignore mushrikeen who were deliberately uttering words against Prophet sws. This is a Pakistani Ulema made law which Muslims use whenever it suits them. About Apostasy when the message of the Prophet sws was absolutely clear to his addresses , then a Muslim who left Islam could be killed. This was time specific and DOES NOT apply today. Nobody Has the right to judge another person. Allah will judge each and every one and he is all knowing. The person in the clip is talking nonsense and will be answerable to Allah.
So, the clergy has more power to define Islam’s image than the scholars like Ghamidi saab who studied it for years and understood the correct meaning of Islam ? All 4 sunni schools of thought give punishment for apostasy, and according to Hanafi school, a Muslim blasphemer is an apostate and is fit to be killed, it seems all of them got it wrong.. but the fact is they are the ones who define Islam currently in the world. We can talk all about it is not part of Islam, but almost all the mainstream scholars agree that both apostates and blasphemers need be killed. If “true Islam” is only what is in the mind of Ghamidi saab, and all the mainstream scholars and clergy are propagating “cruel Islam” .. what one can say ? Finally what is being practiced is important, and apparent as Islam.