Quran 43:32: Hunter Gatherers And Classless Society
This all might be true but this is all hierarchy not a class system. Hierarchy exists in most aspects of humanity’s social life. From family to business, it is everywhere. Even in the socialist states there existed hierarchy in industry and their party structures. But what Ghamidi Saheb’s tafseer implies is that classes can never be eliminated and their existence is among part of God’s divine plan for this world. He literally uses the word “tabqaat”. Hierarchy elimination is probably the goal of anarchists, not communists. The later are of the idea that it would exist even in higher stages of communism. And also, as you have also pointed out, hierarchies were naturally there in hunter gatherer societies. Class existence idea isn’t true for those early societies. So again, what does the verse really mean?