What Kind Of Enmity Made Yazeed Murder Hazrat Hussain (rta)?
سب سے پہلے تو یہ جاننا ضروری ہے کہ تاریخ کو پڑھنے کا یہ طریقہ درست نہیں۔ تاریخ کو دیکھنے کے اصول سمجھنے ہیں تو غامدی صاحب کی واقعہ کربلا پر پلے لسٹ ہے، اسی طرح امیر معاویہ اور علی رض کے تنازعات پر بھی، وہ مکمل سنیں. اس طرح کی تمام تاریخی روایات پر تنقید پڑھنی ہے تو کفایت اللہ سنابلی صاحب کی کتاب قابل مطالعہ ہے
Following commentary of Dr. Irfan Shahzad on Yazeed is also very insightful in this regard: Please refer to the video below from 1:27:32 to 1:40:29 https://youtu.be/oBaUZLVoSj0?si=N8fWpjKQocXyr1cZ&t=5252
There was no hatred against Hussain (rta) and his family, and not everyone was killed. Imam Zain ul Abideen and other members of his family were taken to Yazeed after this incident and they were treated in a very good manner and were returned after few days in a proper escort. It is also narrated that Head of Hussain (rta) was presented in front of Yazeed ( the same is reported for Ibn-e-Ziyad so there could be duplication ) and he expressed sorrow after seeing this, cursed Ibn-e-Ziyad for murdering Hussain (rta) and stated that had he been there, he would have spared him. It appears that Imam Zain ul Abideen and other female members were not harmed because they did not actively participate in the battle/resistance. Had there been any enmity against the family of Hussain (rta), then no one should have survived the action of the government during Karbala. Also two years later, during incident of Harra (Battle of al-Harra), family of Hussain (rta) specially Imam Zain ul Abideen was not hurt in any way because Yazeed knew they were no involved in that rebellion. The dictatorship/monarchy of Yazeed considered it an act of rebellion and acted how all monarchies act when they smell even a whiff of challenge to their rule. The reaction of Yazeed, specifically of ibn-e-Ziyad was disproportionate to the act of Hazrat Hussain (rta) which was a poor political move and unwarranted aggression. Please watch all the videos below , which explains how it was poorly managed crisis from a political standpoint which lead to innocent martyr of Hussain (rta) . https://youtu.be/cBASyqxUc1U?si=WgfBjIJgQzV9FZZY