Issue Of Takfir When A Proclaimed Muslim Denies Basic Tenets Of Islam
What Umer sb is saying is, if he calls himself muslim then he has to profess basic tenets of Islam in public. If he don’t then he is not Muslim.
Someone who denies any tenet of Islam publicly, whether it be Khatm-e-Nabuwat of Prophet Muhammad (sws) or any other, and still claims to be a Muslim, then only rational explanation is that he is doing so because he interprets Quran or Hadith differently. In that case, we will have a discussion on that interpretation. If someone who denies any basic tenet of Islam publicly just out of mere whim and still claims to be a Muslim, no such person exists in real world and if he does, then he requires medical help . We cannot call any person who claims to be a Muslim as being out of the fold of Islam . Please refer to the video below from 34:20 to 36:31 https://youtu.be/DOdblAAEPbA?si=4dOaoit-6vcP5xTx&t=2060