Fear Around Touching To Be Mother In Law, Hurmat-E-Musahrat
@Irfan76 sir so if we were to extract the illat, what would the illat be? Secondly sir, According to surah nisa 4:22 and nisa 23 where the words “allaati dakhaltum” are used, what does these words mean? Ghamidi sahab in his lecture said it as “khalwat”. Which means seclusion, some scholars say intercourse and some say mere foreplay also would be included in this words, that’s why I guess the hanafi madhab includes looking at private part and touch of lust also in it. So what is the concept and illat told by the words “allaati dakhaltum”?
It is penetration. Seclusion is not penetration but in old times there was no way to resolve a dispute whether in seclusion man did intercourse or not and therefore seclusion was equated with intercourse or penetration. Now we can tell through medical report of penetration actually took place or not.