Exile Of Non Muslims From Arabia
If a non-Muslim country does it to Muslims, will you consider it moral and justified ?
Everyone will be judged according to their ilm / knowledge and the level of itmam-e-hujjat that became evident to them. The same applies to 7th century Native Americans. The itemam-e-hujjat of Prophet Muhammad (sws) was limited to the countries where letters were sent and it was not just letters, it was this iconic event that happened in Arabian Peninsula that became a source of Shadah itself. Please refer to the video I shared in response to your question of letters that you posted somewhere else, all of these questions have been answered there, both with respect to letters and other implications of itmam-e-hujjat.
Lack of communication ?? Supposed creator of the universe was bounded by lack of communication ??? Is that the reason, the final message to the “whole humanity” remained confined to Arabia only (apart from the letters sent to nearing kingdoms known to the “final messenger” ? Is it because the message didn’t reach America because God didn’t know how to communicate it to America ? When Muhammad was sent as a mercy to the whole world, why he was not made known to all the people in the world ? Did Muhammad even know America existed and people lived there? Do you honestly not see the problem with this? It is very very clear that Muhammad was a local Arabian man, and he did things in the locality/area which were known to him.. there is NOT a single supernatural occurrence of events in this ..
God has given them chance to accept the truth. Once they don’t God will decide what to do with them and he will do it with justice
We discussed it earlier too in “no compulsion” thread.. I proved that it is indeed compulsion if you threaten them with “accept the truth or be killed/thrown out of your home” . Did verse 60:8 mean that Allah said it is fine to throw them out of their homes in some conditions ? It seems Islam has its own definition of justice which apparently is ok with hypocrisy .
Valid questions.. are these numbers arbitrarily and randomly chosen ? Remember Qur’an is “detailed explanation of all things in religion” .