Why Did Allah Create People Who Would Go To Hell?
And I am saying that He wants to punish evil. It would go against His justice if He said something like “I will be merciful to everyone, including the criminals” in which case, it makes sense that He would choose not to create the rebellious, knowing they would reject guidance, saving them from punishment. But turns out, Allah has informed us, that He is not all-loving. He is above all, Just. He sees good and He rewards it. He sees evil and He warns it, sets it up for questioning and may choose to punish it. This is His decision, this is what He has ultimately chosen, and then informed us, to warn us, that “do not be among the rebellious” because these are the people that may lose His mercy i.e these are the people He will not give any leniency including “choosing not to create so they can avoid punishment.” This is the position we are in. So we have to accept this.
And I ask you: Why should Allah spare you if you are rebellious by choice?
How can I love and worship such a God who knowingly creates people just to torture them.