Marrying An Atheist Woman
@codename.AJK sir if someone interprets this ayat of concession about marriage with ahl e kitab, as that because only these 2 groups (Jews and christian) were mentioned with words that they are made halal, so now no third group can be said to be halal for marriage. like if some religion forms today where people are monotheist like Muslims and they are living under total Muslim dominance. the religion is called XYZism but marrying woman of this religion is not allowed because even though they are monotheist (and they don’t have shirk beliefs like christians) and live under Muslim dominance, but because they do not belong from the groups of ahl e kitab, so it is prohibited to marry their woman. if someone interprets the ayat like this then what would we say to them?
@Irfan76 and sir if for suppose let’s say in future in a Muslim intellectual dominant society, an ahl e kitab man lives and if he wants to marry a woman of Muslims and would live in the girls house (Ghar jamaayi damad) then would such marriage be allowed? because illat of open polytheism is not there, illat of Muslim dominance is not there, illat of woman going to man’s house and eventually children getting significantly influenced by father side religion is not there. I mean these conditions that made an ahl e kitab woman halal, are found in a reversed role of Ahl e kitab man, would such marriage be halal?