Isn’t Ijma And Tawatur Just Opinions?
We call it fard based on Quran and hadith. So again, the responsibility is not on us.
We shouldn’t call it fard. We shouldn’t say anything if there’s a chance that it isn’t the original practice
I wonder if Ghamidi sahab would agree that we can be skeptics labour this sort of transmission
No there’s no assumption required. Whoever saw Prophet SAW performing salat with or without sadl/qbd followed the ritual that way, hence it’s not a compulsory practice. If Prophet SAW wanted to establish only one way, like the rakahs in fard salat, a split is inconceivable.