Status Of The Report On The Barking Of The Dogs Of حوأب At Ayesha
1) Hmm😊 2) Shaykh Albani commented on this and said by New Things she meant her participation in Battle of Jamal which she regretted later. 3.1) Hadith didn’t claimed that he had complete “ilm al gayb” same can be asked about Death of Ammar ibn Yassir r.a. and also about Karbala where Angel told Prophet ﷺ that Hassan a.s. would be killed and showed him dust of that land. 3.2) It’s possible before he didn’t knew who’s that wife but later Allah swt would have told him. Again prophet saw didn’t have complete Ilm e Gaib. He might not know what was the matter why there will be dispute between them. 3.3) Prophecies are prophecies. I don’t have any answer to it. Prophet usually tell about thing that gonna happen in future such as Signs of Qiyama, Ammar’s fate, etc etc. 4) I don’t really think it was prohibition or abort sign just a simple prophecy she wasn’t even going for War at that as Zubair r.a. said maybe allah will reconcile the people through you. 6) Interpretion in the light of Quran
@Ashehal وعليكم السلام I Disagree ! Almost all scholars except few are in the opinion that this hadith is Sahih. and their are various ahadith regarding this incident through various chains confirming the same. btw Sheikh Albani declared this ahadith as ”Extreamly Authentic” Engineer Sahab recently talked about prophecies and these ahadith have look https://youtu.be/morDz4549TE from 5:00