Status Of The Report On The Barking Of The Dogs Of حوأب At Ayesha
Prophecies are told to provide evidences of the truth of prophet hood and Quran. Also to some extent they serve the purpose to warn people. The prophet in many of his sayings foretold the bloodshed after him, which are documented in the chapter Ahadih Al Fitan in the books of Ahadith. However none of the Ahadith decides categorically for Muslims what is right or wrong as it was there test to decide. In the above Hadith the prophet only told about a happening. He did not condemned it nor prohibited the mothers of faithful. The addition that “you will on the wrong that day against Ali ” seems a later addition, as we don’t find this addition in the authentic narrations. However Ayesha did take it a warning but she too was not sure about it being a warning or she could never go against it.
وعليكم السلام He said hadith is ‘mursal’ so we must know who’s the one who narrated this to syedna qais bin abi hazim, and we find in another narration of Musnad Ahmad that he heard this from Syeda Ayesha r.a. hence its not mursal anymore https://youtu.be/SiynovzYi9U