If God Is Loving, Why Punish On Shirk?
I am not certain of others, sir. Many Muslims might fail on Day of Judgment, Many non-Muslims will succeed on Day of Judgment. The entire summary of Surah Baqarah is that no specific group will succeed on Day of Judgment according to Ghamidi Sahab. There will a fair examination of everyone, everyone will be judged according to a strict Justice standard and no one will be wronged. This is the promise of God. Belief in this promise is only way the Day of Judgment concept works, it is a core of our belief as Muslims. So yes, we live in hope and fear that Allah will honor us and our non-Muslims brothers/sisters. Because we don’t know what is going to happen, that’s why we must prepare.