Crucifixion Of Jesus (SWS) And Real Facts?
Qur’an makes those things clear to us which are for us necessary in Deen. The extra information it tells is just a favour. If not told, it doesn’t make any deficiency in the actual Deen. To let the people of the time of Jesus believe the Jesus is crucified is to let them fill their bucket of sin that they had him killed, so that they might be punished. It was not a deception to mislead them but let them perceoce what they did according to their plan. The Qur’an did not tell how Jesus was saved. It only tells that he was saved and God gave him death. Nothing can be said with certainty how he was saved. We will know these secret in the hereafter.
good points but I can hardly read these papers But as you said either judas got punished and made look like jesus and put on cross : which is to me very unlikely because :one : why would God turn this traitor into an image of a holy prophet and second judas was innocent of saying that he was the messiah so God does not do injustice of killing a man for a sin he didn’t commit Yes judas was a traitor and had his share of sin but not in this. And as I understood further: Jesus was then perhaps indeed crucified and put on cross but did not died by this crucifixion : and the verse wama katalulu wa ma salabuhu is actually saying that they did not killed him by that crucifixion. But God did and saved him later. But here the question arise; would God put his prophet through such humiliation? While HE is saying further that he will raise him up to himself so that these jews wont be able to even touch him and disrespect his body. So why would God then put jesus through this process and then save him? You said there can only be two options : Either jesus was indeed put on cross but survived ; and here my issue is then why is Quran saying it like this in the famous verse they did not killed him , nor crucified but the matter was made to appear so. Why in such a way that the reader gets confused and does not get clear answer. Second option : either judas or his companions made to look like him and crucified but this seems to me too far fetched and does’nt make sense. Final conclusion : we can not know what actually happened. No one knwos what the reality of the matter is and Quran is also telling it in a way that the reader doesn’t get the exact answer. It’s very vague. It’s implicating more tha one answer which to me I don’t get why.