Objection On Usool E Hadith
Yes that is ok,these principles were great and perfect, but this is also a logical objection that they have selected data which doesn’t contradict Quran and character of Prophet SAW (in principles), so a western orientalist objection can be made,so how would you reconcile that?
This is an invalid objection. Narrations are graded according to the principles. Ones deemed unacceptable are generally categorized as such. In fact we even have collections like Al-Mawduaat al-Kubra that list known fabricated narrations.
Sorry ,is by my words it seems that I’m talking rude(because i have this problem which gives negative indication to others) but inner me by God i am very thankful to you all for giving your precious time to us, at this platform we can present our objections as it is,and sorry again and May Allah reward you all.
Please don’t worry about that – I didn’t notice any rudeness in your discussion.