Ambiguity In Ghamidi Sahab's Definition Of Polytheism (Shirk)
aapka ye aitraaz sahi nahi lagta hai kyunki ghamidi sahab ne shirk ki definition do lines me samet de hai jiske liye log kai safat likhty hai unho ne mukhtasar se lafzo me ye sari baat bayan kar di hai,jisko samajhny ke liye itni pechidgi me jany ke shayad zarurat nahi jisme aap ja rahy hai,ghamidi sahab ki definition me ye baat khud bakhud ajati hai jo ayat me bayan hui hai,kehty hai shareek nahi karty lekin phir bhi khuda ki baat nahi manty.baqi indirect way me shirk me sabhi log mubtila hai jaisy khuda or rasool koi faisla kardy to dusro ko hakam na banao,giroh bandi mat karo jo aisa kary unka rasool se taaluq nahi,nafs ki parashtish mat karo,halaki log iski bhi taweely kar lety hai ke ham ye nahi ye karty hai.duniya me shayad hi koi kahy ki vo ghairullah ki ibadat karta hai ek khuda ko manty hue bhi sifarishi rakhty hai ye shaitani kaam hai jo ghuma phira ke karvaya jata hai varna koi iski baat nahi manega.