RLOO Trainer
Source: trl

# RLOO TrainerTRL supports training LLMs with REINFORCE Leave-One-Out (RLOO). The idea is that instead of using a value function, RLOO generates K completions for each prompt. For each completion, RLOO uses the mean scores from the other K-1 completions as a baseline to calculate the advantage. RLOO also models the entire completion as a single action, where as PPO models each token as an action. Note that REINFORCE / A2C is a special case of PPO, when the number of PPO epochs is 1 and the number of mini-batches is 1, which is how we implement RLOO in TRL.References:- [Back to Basics: Revisiting REINFORCE Style Optimization for Learning from Human Feedback in LLMs](https://huggingface.co/papers/2402.14740)- [A2C is a special case of PPO](https://huggingface.co/papers/2205.09123)- [Fine-Tuning Language Models from Human Preferences](https://github.com/openai/lm-human-preferences)- [Learning to Summarize from Human Feedback](https://github.com/openai/summarize-from-feedback)- [The N Implementation Details of RLHF with PPO](https://huggingface.co/blog/the_n_implementation_details_of_rlhf_with_ppo)- [The N+ Implementation Details of RLHF with PPO: A Case Study on TL;DR Summarization](https://huggingface.co/papers/2403.17031)## Get startedTo just run a RLOO script to make sure the trainer can run, you can run the following command to train a RLOO model with a dummy reward model.```bashpython examples/scripts/rloo/rloo.py \    --learning_rate 3e-6 \    --output_dir models/minimal/rloo \    --per_device_train_batch_size 64 \    --gradient_accumulation_steps 1 \    --total_episodes 10000 \    --model_name_or_path EleutherAI/pythia-14m \    --reward_model_path EleutherAI/pythia-14m \    --non_eos_penalty```## Explanation of the logged metricsThe logged metrics are as follows. Here is an example [tracked run at Weights and Biases](https://wandb.ai/huggingface/trl/runs/u2sqci34)<!-- * `rlhf_reward_var_per_prompt`: calculated by `rlhf_reward.var(0).mean()`. This is the variance of the rewards estimated across the `args.rloo_k` samples. Usually we expect it to go down (cause policy entropy goes down). -->* `eps`: Tracks the number of episodes per second.* `objective/kl`: The mean Kullback-Leibler (KL) divergence between the current policy and reference policy.* `objective/entropy`: The mean entropy of the policy, indicating the randomness of the actions chosen by the policy.* `objective/non_score_reward`: The mean reward from non-score-related sources, basically `beta * kl.sum(1)`, where `beta` is the KL penalty coefficient and `kl` is the per-token KL divergence.* `objective/rlhf_reward`: The mean RLHF reward, which is `score - non_score_reward`.* `objective/scores`: The mean scores returned by the reward model / environment.* `policy/approxkl_avg`: The average approximate KL divergence between consecutive PPO policies. Note that this is not the same as `objective/kl`.* `policy/clipfrac_avg`: The average fraction of policy updates that are clipped, indicating how often the policy updates are constrained to prevent large changes.* `loss/policy_avg`: The average policy loss, indicating how well the policy is performing.* `val/clipfrac_avg`: The average fraction of value function updates that are clipped, similar to policy/clipfrac_avg but for the value function.* `policy/entropy_avg`: The average entropy of the policy during training, indicating how diverse the policy's actions are.* `val/ratio`: The mean ratio of the current policy probability to the old policy probability, providing a measure of how much the policy has changed.* `val/ratio_var`: The variance of the `val/ratio`, indicating the variability in policy changes.* `val/num_eos_tokens`: The number of end-of-sequence (EOS) tokens generated, which can indicate the number of complete responses.* `lr`: lr: The current learning rate used by the optimizer.* `episode`: episode: The current global step or episode count in the training process.## Cookbook* Debugging TIP: `objective/rlhf_reward`: this is the ultimate objective of the RLHF training. If training works as intended, this metric should keep going up.* Debugging TIP: `val/ratio`: this number should float around 1.0, and it gets clipped by `--cliprange 0.2` with PPO's surrogate loss. So if this `ratio` is too high like 2.0 or 1000.0 or too small like 0.1, it means the updates between consecutive policies are too drastic. You should try undertand why this is happening and try to fix it.* Memory TIP: If you are running out of memory, you can try to reduce the `--per_device_train_batch_size` or increase the `--gradient_accumulation_steps` to reduce the memory footprint.* Memory TIP: If you have multiple GPUs, you can also run training with DeepSpeed stage 3 to reduce the memory footprint `accelerate launch --config_file examples/accelerate_configs/deepspeed_zero3.yaml`.* Usage TIP: We recommend to use the "EOS trick" via `--non_eos_penalty --stop_token eos`, which replaces the score of completions that do not end with an EOS token with a static scalar penalty `--penalty_reward_value`. This can help the model learn to generate more coherent completions.## What is my model doing exactly?To help you understand what your model is doing, we periodically log some sample completions from the model. Here is an example of a completion. In an example [tracked run at Weights and Biases](https://wandb.ai/huggingface/trl/runs/u2sqci34), it looks like the following, allowing you to see the model's response at different stages of training. By default we generate `--num_sample_generations 10` during training, but you can customize the number of generations.![](https://huggingface.co/datasets/trl-internal-testing/example-images/resolve/main/images/ppov2_completions.gif)In the logs the sampled generations look like ```┏━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━┳━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━┳━━━━━━━━━━┓┃ query                           ┃ model response                  ┃ score    ┃┡━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━╇━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━╇━━━━━━━━━━┩│  SUBREDDIT: r/AskReddit         │  I'm in love with a friend, and │ 3.921875 ││                                 │ I don't know how to get rid of  │          ││ TITLE: How do you get someone   │ those feelings. I'm             │          ││ out of your head?               │ desperate.[PAD][P... │          ││                                 │                                 │          ││ POST: Hi,                       │                                 │          ││ I'm 22, and I have been with my │                                 │          ││ girlfriend for 5 years now. We  │                                 │          ││ recently moved together. We've  │                                 │          ││ always loved each other         │                                 │          ││ intensely.                      │                                 │          ││                                 │                                 │          ││ Problem, I recently started to  │                                 │          ││ have feelings for an other      │                                 │          ││ person (a friend). This person  │                                 │          ││ has had a boyfriend for now 3   │                                 │          ││ years, and has absolutely no    │                                 │          ││ ideas. Those feelings were so   │                                 │          ││ strong, it was hard to hide     │                                 │          ││ them. After 2 months of me      │                                 │          ││ being distant and really sad,   │                                 │          ││ my girlfriend forced me to say  │                                 │          ││ what was bothering me. I'm not  │                                 │          ││ a good liar, and now she knows. │                                 │          ││                                 │                                 │          ││ We decided to give us a week    │                                 │          ││ alone, I went to my parents.    │                                 │          ││                                 │                                 │          ││ Now, I'm completely lost. I     │                                 │          ││ keep on thinking about this     │                                 │          ││ person, and I hate that. I      │                                 │          ││ would like for those feelings   │                                 │          ││ to go away, to leave me alone.  │                                 │          ││ But I can't.                    │                                 │          ││                                 │                                 │          ││ What do I do? It's been 3       │                                 │          ││ months now, and I'm just        │                                 │          ││ desperate.                      │                                 │          ││                                 │                                 │          ││ TL;DR:                          │                                 │          │├─────────────────────────────────┼─────────────────────────────────┼──────────┤│  SUBREDDIT: r/pettyrevenge      │  My mom woke me up with a loud  │ 6.84375  ││                                 │ TV. I blasted Gangnam Style on  │          ││ TITLE: So, my mom woke me up    │ repeat, with the bass cranked   │          ││ with a loud TV.                 │ up as high as it could          │          ││                                 │ go.[PAD][PAD][PAD... │          ││ POST: She was in her living     │                                 │          ││ room, watching TV. This was at  │                                 │          ││ about 8:30 in the morning, and  │                                 │          ││ she was exercising. She turned  │                                 │          ││ the TV up extra loud to hear it │                                 │          ││ over her excercycle, and woke   │                                 │          ││ me up. I went in there asking   │                                 │          ││ for her to turn it down. She    │                                 │          ││ said she didn't have to; I      │                                 │          ││ explained that I always used    │                                 │          ││ headphones so she didn't have   │                                 │          ││ to deal with my noise and that  │                                 │          ││ she should give me a little     │                                 │          ││ more respect, given that I paid │                                 │          ││ rent at the time.               │                                 │          ││                                 │                                 │          ││ She disagreed. I went back to   │                                 │          ││ my room, rather pissed off at   │                                 │          ││ the lack of equality. I had no  │                                 │          ││ lock on my door; but I had a    │                                 │          ││ dresser right next to it, so I  │                                 │          ││ pulled one of the drawers out   │                                 │          ││ enough so that it caused the    │                                 │          ││ door to not be openable. Then,  │                                 │          ││ I turned my speakers up really  │                                 │          ││ loud and blasted Gangnam Style  │                                 │          ││ on repeat, with the bass        │                                 │          ││ cranked up as high as it could  │                                 │          ││ go.                             │                                 │          ││                                 │                                 │          ││ If you hate Gangnam Style for   │                                 │          ││ being overplayed, you will see  │                                 │          ││ why I chose that particular     │                                 │          ││ song. I personally don't mind   │                                 │          ││ it. But here's the thing about  │                                 │          ││ my bass; it vibrates the walls, │                                 │          ││ making one hell of a lot of     │                                 │          ││ noise. Needless to say, my mom  │                                 │          ││ was not pleased and shut off    │                                 │          ││ the internet. But it was oh so  │                                 │          ││ worth it.                       │                                 │          ││                                 │                                 │          ││ TL;DR:                          │                                 │          │└─────────────────────────────────┴─────────────────────────────────┴──────────┘```## Implementation detailsThe bulk of RLOOTrainer is based on the PPO implementation, which is based on the [The N+ Implementation Details of RLHF with PPO: A Case Study on TL;DR Summarization](https://huggingface.co/papers/2403.17031).Below is a vectorized advantage calculation for RLOO:```pythondef test_rloo_reward():    local_batch_size = 3    rloo_k = 4    rlhf_reward = torch.tensor([        1, 2, 3, # first rlhf reward for three prompts        2, 3, 4, # second rlhf reward for three prompts        5, 6, 7, # third rlhf reward for three prompts        8, 9, 10, # fourth rlhf reward for three prompts    ]).float() # here we have 3 prompts which have 4 completions each    baseline = (rlhf_reward.sum(0) - rlhf_reward) / (rloo_k - 1)    advantages = torch.zeros_like(rlhf_reward)    for i in range(0, len(advantages), local_batch_size):        other_response_rlhf_rewards = []        for j in range(0, len(advantages), local_batch_size):            if i != j:                other_response_rlhf_rewards.append(rlhf_reward[j : j + local_batch_size])        advantages[i : i + local_batch_size] = rlhf_reward[i : i + local_batch_size] - torch.stack(other_response_rlhf_rewards).mean(0)        assert (1 - (2 + 5 + 8) / 3 - advantages[0].item()) < 1e-6  # First rlhf reward for the first prompt    assert (6 - (3 + 2 + 9) / 3 - advantages[7].item()) < 1e-6  # Third rlhf reward for the second prompt    # Vectorized implementation    rlhf_reward = rlhf_reward.reshape(rloo_k, local_batch_size)    baseline = (rlhf_reward.sum(0) - rlhf_reward) / (rloo_k - 1)    vec_advantages = rlhf_reward - baseline    torch.testing.assert_close(vec_advantages.flatten(), advantages)```## Benchmark experimentsTo validate the RLOO implementation works, we ran experiment on the 1B model. Here are the command we used to run the experiment. We take the SFT / RM models directly from [The N+ Implementation Details of RLHF with PPO: A Case Study on TL;DR Summarization](https://huggingface.co/papers/2403.17031).```accelerate launch --config_file examples/accelerate_configs/deepspeed_zero2.yaml \    examples/scripts/rloo/rloo_tldr.py \    --output_dir models/minimal/rloo_tldr \    --num_ppo_epochs 2 \    --num_mini_batches 2 \    --learning_rate 3e-6 \    --per_device_train_batch_size 8 \    --gradient_accumulation_steps 8 \    --total_episodes 1000000 \    --model_name_or_path EleutherAI/pythia-1b-deduped \    --sft_model_path cleanrl/EleutherAI_pythia-1b-deduped__sft__tldr \    --reward_model_path cleanrl/EleutherAI_pythia-1b-deduped__reward__tldr \    --local_rollout_forward_batch_size 16 \    --non_eos_penalty \    --stop_token eos \    --kl_coef 0.03```Checkpoints and experiment tracking are available at:- [🤗 Model checkpoint](https://huggingface.co/vwxyzjn/rloo_tldr)- [🐝 Tracked experiment](https://wandb.ai/huggingface/trl/runs/u2sqci34)To evaluate, we use [vLLM](https://github.com/vllm-project/vllm) to load the checkpoints and GPT-4o mini as a judge model to evaluate the generated TL;DR against the reference TL;DR.For more information on how to use judges, see [Judges](judges).```bash$ python examples/scripts/evals/judge_tldr.py --model_name_or_path cleanrl/EleutherAI_pythia-1b-deduped__sft__tldr --judge_model gpt-4o-mini --num_examples 1000Model win rate: 33.00%$ python examples/scripts/evals/judge_tldr.py --model_name_or_path vwxyzjn/rloo_tldr --judge_model gpt-4o-mini --num_examples 1000Model win rate: 51.20%```The RLOO checkpoint gets a 51.2% preferred rate vs the 33.0% preference rate of the SFT checkpoint. This is a good sign that the RLOO training is working as intended.Metrics:![](https://huggingface.co/datasets/trl-internal-testing/example-images/resolve/main/images/benchmark/pr-1540/rloo.png)```bash# pip install openrlbenchmark==0.2.1a5# see https://github.com/openrlbenchmark/openrlbenchmark#get-started for documentation# to use it, change `?we=huggingface&wpn=trl` to your own project and `?tag=pr-1540` to your own tagpython -m openrlbenchmark.rlops_multi_metrics \    --filters '?we=huggingface&wpn=trl&xaxis=train/episode&ceik=output_dir&cen=sft_model_path&metrics=train/objective/rlhf_reward&metrics=train/objective/scores&metrics=train/objective/kl&metrics=train/objective/non_score_reward&metrics=train/objective/entropy&metrics=train/policy/approxkl_avg&metrics=train/policy/clipfrac_avg&metrics=train/loss/policy_avg&metrics=train/policy/entropy_avg&metrics=train/val/ratio&metrics=train/val/ratio_var&metrics=train/val/num_eos_tokens&metrics=train/lr&metrics=train/eps' \        "cleanrl/EleutherAI_pythia-1b-deduped__sft__tldr?tag=pr-1540" \    --env-ids models/minimal/rloo_tldr \    --pc.ncols 4 \    --pc.ncols-legend 1 \    --pc.xlabel "Episode" \    --output-filename benchmark/trl/pr-1540/rloo \    --scan-history```