\documentclass[tikz,border=5pt]{standalone}
\usepackage[utf8]{inputenc}
\usepackage[T1]{fontenc}
\usepackage{pgfplots}
\pgfplotsset{compat=1.17}
\usetikzlibrary{pgfplots.groupplots}
\usetikzlibrary{shapes.geometric}
\usepgfplotslibrary{fillbetween}
\begin{document}
\begin{tikzpicture}
\sffamily
\begin{axis}[
title = {C3: Collective},
title style={align=center,yshift=-.1in},
legend style={font=\small,
nodes={scale=0.7, transform shape},
at={(0.0,1)},
anchor=north west,
draw=none,
fill=none},
legend cell align={left},
width = 2.0in, height = 2.5in,
ylabel near ticks,
xlabel near ticks,
every tick label/.append style={font=\scriptsize},
xmin=0,xmax=55,ymin=0.4,ymax=0.9,
xtick={3.7977154664886665, 27, 54},
tick pos=left,
xlabel={\small Number of raters},
xlabel style = {yshift=0.05in},
yticklabel style={
/pgf/number format/fixed,
/pgf/number format/precision=5
},
scaled y ticks=false
]
\addplot[solid, mark=o, mark options={scale=.3}, black]
plot [error bars/.cd, y dir = both, y explicit, ]
table[y error index=2]{
1 0.5244552365916657 0.05043656338749314 0.042646115880665025
2 0.5924458398580356 0.04878639279894781 0.039846798169239084
3 0.6325422612912204 0.04718487044052955 0.038593372481683264
4 0.6536676682051576 0.0461027299182879 0.037505071052175376
5 0.6677764732403334 0.045056213267508194 0.03648214227142543
6 0.6772308842936952 0.04454752250163374 0.03549811164649286
7 0.6826992447172777 0.04483535552801576 0.03568573846496681
8 0.6901376668032956 0.04401868027921407 0.034847264782998266
9 0.6910876228889521 0.043920572657683676 0.034882491631806345
10 0.6941767300872279 0.043958992164278454 0.03489231347093069
11 0.6992909794958984 0.04363701981737789 0.03437449783530888
12 0.6989633941294531 0.0431840096036169 0.03432556512833507
13 0.7013372922923224 0.04353314826850729 0.033473217862319826
14 0.7043242176651441 0.043296307775952725 0.03409179788473826
15 0.705595933916708 0.043185444102082915 0.03376082310086115
16 0.7058032695435763 0.04347553770934609 0.0338518296917516
17 0.7080428424557397 0.043604238785926674 0.03324089714108058
18 0.7087842402166307 0.04345248987027783 0.03371646156494956
19 0.7094177487785076 0.043364221587203766 0.03337815848886272
20 0.7108314533239026 0.04323769848717196 0.03331966805686348
21 0.7113352556932653 0.0430222315037142 0.03361863162494738
22 0.7119470875564347 0.04323081311418686 0.03315361712613274
23 0.7125716860230926 0.042519441279187054 0.03302806601980102
24 0.7136402281974906 0.04276285478374908 0.033323378154577865
25 0.7141014448122195 0.04312364956899273 0.03313657173889295
26 0.7146552666420254 0.04296181893434026 0.033071584199064974
27 0.7144526915640599 0.04276795560078561 0.033184301845515574
28 0.7146900577905048 0.04299758840159862 0.03327501618129969
29 0.7158560857833614 0.04217290130185347 0.03300414807302121
30 0.7161501890651951 0.04263611399182643 0.03302161278763727
31 0.7161401138836428 0.04222873720788278 0.032979840085267886
32 0.7167585015352604 0.04245680678600139 0.032963195427850756
33 0.7168943367631982 0.042545851453942185 0.03288466463885298
34 0.7172740260085435 0.042644661846046206 0.03286885871893397
35 0.7181322089844145 0.04238519511782013 0.032744823016502944
36 0.7185528917514565 0.04242177835321215 0.03272821830700412
37 0.7180194986468535 0.04232859564714342 0.032757833271647274
38 0.7184117657017545 0.04210539285086767 0.0328575424762535
39 0.7183267604867507 0.0422959966666564 0.0327782381952767
40 0.7187489985372717 0.04230847395505011 0.032721000280130585
41 0.7191662294946819 0.04225697557874997 0.03264271861033596
42 0.7193537128848448 0.0422374085110222 0.032553627985774436
43 0.7191323496150352 0.0421750157502111 0.03281370753636825
44 0.7195051919360845 0.04224275250925191 0.0325238363213014
45 0.7198729450370179 0.04210253998567459 0.032566269735319064
46 0.7199032925937141 0.04226845167048732 0.032702489727275075
47 0.7202491459259158 0.04213527680817175 0.03257816974775729
48 0.7201255545938338 0.04209230044374901 0.03256919285272086
49 0.720024218918412 0.04220336663544 0.032685971695064264
50 0.7204141839331883 0.04216817778312165 0.032514150052640245
51 0.720431665681266 0.04214505417072678 0.03259944289880112
52 0.7207349839081713 0.042113801071015367 0.03259147646486338
53 0.72078391909779 0.04209149100263687 0.03254869176286479
54 0.7209015087699076 0.04207899226134215 0.032537136264571775
};
\addlegendentry{Turkers}
\addplot[mark=none, blue, dashed, thick, samples=2, domain=-1:55] {0.7331056582890765};
\addlegendentry{three journalists}
\draw [blue, fill=blue, opacity=0.1] (axis cs:-1,0.6867234039011271) rectangle (axis cs:55,0.7708079395395433);
\addplot[mark=none, green, dashed, thick, samples=2, domain=-1:55] {0.6493943251223347};
\addlegendentry{one journalist}
\draw [green, fill=green, opacity=0.1] (axis cs:-1,0.5941083989904011) rectangle (axis cs:55,0.6954345399612075);
\addplot[mark=*, mark options={scale=.8}, blue, thick]
table[]{
54.0 0.7331056582890765
};
\addplot[mark=none, blue, dashed, thick, samples=2, domain=-1:31] coordinates {(54.0,0.7331056582890765) (54.0,0)};
\addplot[mark=*, mark options={scale=.8}, green, thick]
table[]{
3.7977154664886665 0.6493943251223347
};
\addplot[mark=none, green, dashed, thick, samples=2, domain=-1:31] coordinates {(3.7977154664886665,0.6493943251223347) (3.7977154664886665,0)};
\end{axis}
\end{tikzpicture}
\end{document}