Source document: https://docs-lawep.s3.us-east-2.amazonaws.com/1694846795238.pdf (South Africa)
Thursday, 15 June 2023 852 [No 24 – 2023] Fifth Session, Sixth Parliament REPRINT NATIONAL ASSEMBLY ________________________ INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER ______________________ Note: 1.

 Indicates an oral question.

2.

† Indicates the translated version of the question.

3.

◙ Indicates a written question not yet replied to after 10 working days expired.
Table of Contents President of the Republic .................................................................................................... 856, 862, 872 Minister in The Presidency ................................................................................................................. 861 Minister in The Presidency for Electricity .......................................................................................... 853 Minister of Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development ......................... 857, 858, 859, 863, 870 Minister of Basic Education ................................................................................................ 854, 868, 871 Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs ............ 853, 854, 855, 856, 864, 866, 872 Minister of Defence and Military Veterans ........................................................................................ 870 Minister of Employment and Labour .................................................................................................. 853 Minister of Finance ..................................................................................................................... 865, 866 Minister of Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment.................................. 859, 860, 862, 863, 864, 870 Minister of Health ....................................................................... 854, 855, 856, 859, 867, 868, 869, 871 Minister of Higher Education, Science and Innovation .............................................................. 862, 867 Minister of Home Affairs .................................................................................................................... 861 Minister of International Relations and Cooperation .................................................................. 866, 871 Minister of Justice and Correctional Services ............................................................................. 856, 869 Minister of Mineral Resources and Energy ........................................................................ 860, 867, 872 Minister of Police ................................................................................................................ 854, 856, 866 Minister of Public Enterprises............................................................................................. 857, 862, 865 Minister of Public Service and Administration ................................................................................... 871 Minister of Public Works and Infrastructure ...................................... 853, 855, 861, 864, 865, 869, 871 Minister of Small Business Development ........................................................................................... 869 Minister of Social Development ......................................................................................... 855, 857, 868 Minister of Sport, Arts and Culture .................................................................................................... 863 Minister of Tourism ............................................................................................................ 857, 858, 872 Minister of Transport .......................................................................................................... 854, 866, 871 Minister of Water and Sanitation ........................................................................ 853, 854, 859, 864, 866 Summary of Questions ........................................................................................................................ 873 INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 853 QUESTIONS FOR WRITTEN REPLY THURSDAY, 15 JUNE 2023 (REPLY BY 30 JUNE 2023) 2428.
Ms A L A Abrahams (DA) to ask the Minister of Employment and Labour: (1) With reference to the Fourth Quarter Report for the 2022-23 financial year of the Department of Social Development which indicates that primarily the National Treasury and the Department of Employment and Labour need to provide comments and inputs before Cabinet is requested for approval to re-gazette the Green Paper for public comments (details furnished), (a) what are the reasons that his department has not provided comments and input on the presentation as it appears to be delaying the development of the green paper on Comprehensive Social Security and Retirement Reforms and (b) on what date does his department envisage to provide their comments and input on the green paper; (2) (3) what is his department’s position on the (a) Green Paper and (b) National Social Security Fund within the Green Paper; what are the full and relevant details of the comments and input that his department intend to provide on the Green Paper?
NW2706E 2429.
Ms P Madokwe (EFF) to ask the Minister in The Presidency for Electricity: In light of the fact that one of the factors flagged by the labour collective at Eskom to be contributing to the entity’s dysfunctionality is the strained relationship between the executives, the workforce and/or labour operating in the entity, such that decisions are allegedly taken without the input and/or consideration of the workforce that has been there for years to give valuable input, what measures has he put in place to ensure that (a) the relations are urgently fixed and (b) whoever created a system where parallel operations are undertaken at Eskom without all the crucial stakeholders are held accountable?
NW2749E 2430.

Ms A M Siwisa (EFF) to ask the Minister of Public Works and Infrastructure: In light of the reports of collapsing ceilings of classrooms at schools across the Republic, what (a) total number of schools have been reported to his department for renovations to ensure that all school premises are safe and (b) is the status of the reports?

NW2752E 2431.
NW2752E 2431.

Mrs M R Mohlala (EFF) to ask the Minister of Water and Sanitation: What specific measures and actions has he, together with the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs, undertaken to address the ongoing water crisis in Cradock effectively and to mitigate further economic decline?

NW2754E INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 854 2432.
Mrs M R Mohlala (EFF) to ask the Minister of Water and Sanitation: What (a) measures has his department together with the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs put in place to effectively address the critical issue of municipalities struggling to meet their payment commitments for bulk water, which poses a severe threat to essential services and the well-being of affected communities, (b) actions and strategies will he take to tackle the mounting municipal debts to water boards, in the event that the defaulting municipalities persist in their non- responsiveness and neglect of their obligations and (c) specific measures does his department have in place to ensure their accountability and prevent the burden of non- payment from unfairly impacting the water boards?
NW2755E 2433.

Mr N G Myburgh (DA) to ask the Minister of Water and Sanitation: (1) What (a) total number of new dams are currently under construction and (b) are the details pertaining to (i) location, (ii) capacity and (iii) costs of each dam; (2) what (a) total number of new dams are being planned for construction in the foreseeable future and (b) are the details pertaining to (i) location and (ii) capacity of the dam that is planned?

NW2763E 2434.
NW2763E 2434.

Mr M S F de Freitas (DA) to ask the Minister of Transport: What (a) is the name of each Passenger Rail Agency of South Africa (Prasa) board member who has resided for either a long or short period at any of the properties, (b) were the start and end dates in each case of such stay, (c) were the lease arrangements and terms and conditions with regard to each property and (d) are the reasons that the specified board members were residing at the properties in each case?

NW2764E 2435.
NW2764E 2435.

Mrs M O Clarke (DA) to ask the Minister of Health: What total number of staff members were involved in the incident where newborn babies were placed in cardboard boxes and (b) consequence management steps will be taken with regard to each staff member who was involved in the incident?

NW2765E 2436.
Mr M G E Hendricks (Al Jamah-Ah) to ask the Minister of Basic Education: (1) Whether her department has any regulatory control over the curriculum being taught by a certain school (name furnished) as confirmed by its Director for Education (details furnished); if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, (2) (3) whether she will intervene to de-register and close the school for (a) promoting a certain ideology (name furnished) in furtherance of apartheid and (b) preparing and encouraging South African learners to serve in a foreign army that is renowned for its brutality and ongoing defence of apartheid (details furnished); if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details; whether she has found that the school’s curriculum and ethos contravene the values of the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996, which rails at all forms of apartheid, which the United Nations Organisation declared a crime against humanity; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what are the relevant details?
NW2766E INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 855 2437.
Mr M G E Hendricks (Al Jamah-Ah) to ask the Minister of Police: (1) Whether the SA Police Service (SAPS) intends investigating students of the University of Cape Town who hosted solidarity programmes on Palestine on the campus during the Israeli Apartheid Week in March 2023; if so, why; (2) whether any charges were brought against individuals in March 2023 at the Claremont Police Station for using public and/or private educational institutions to promote Zionism in furtherance of an apartheid ideology which the United Nations has declared a crime against humanity; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?
NW2767E 2438.
Ms T Breedt (FF Plus) to ask the Minister of Social Development: (1) With reference to the expiry date of the gold cards of the SA Social Security Agency (SASSA) being postponed until 31 December 2023, what process do SASSA beneficiaries need to follow in order to renew their SASSA gold cards; (2) (3) whether any plans are in place to roll out the renewal process of the gold cards before 31 December 2023; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details; whether any plans are in place to prevent thousands of beneficiaries from running out of time to renew their gold cards; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details; (4) what steps should those SASSA beneficiaries take who wish to replace their gold cards early?
NW2768E 2439.

Mr P A van Staden (FF Plus) to ask the Minister of Public Works and Infrastructure: Whether, with reference to his reply to question 224 on 7 March 2023, he is now in a position to provide details of state-owned properties, both (a) improved and (b) unimproved, that are currently being rented out; if not, why not; if so, (i) to whom are the state-owned properties rented out and (ii) at what total amounts in each month?

NW2769E 2440.
Mr I M Groenewald (FF Plus) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs: (1) Whether she receives regular reports on qualified appointments of chief financial officers (CFO) and municipal managers (MM); if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what (a) percentage of (i) CFOs and (ii) MMs currently employed by municipalities comply with the minimum qualifications as prescribed by the Municipal Finance Management Act (MFMA), Act 56 of 2003, and (b) total number of (i) CFO and (ii) MM positions at municipalities countrywide are currently vacant and/or filled by acting CFOs and/or MMs; (2) whether municipalities report to her the use of accounting consultants; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what is the total number of municipalities that are currently employing the services of accounting consulting firms to (a) prepare their annual financial statements and/or (b) fulfil the role of internal auditors at municipalities?
NW2778E INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 856 2441.
Ms M D Hlengwa (IFP) to ask the Minister of Health: Whether, considering that public hospitals and mortuaries have been burdened with unclaimed corpses and noting that corpses are now decomposing at a faster rate due to loadshedding, his department has put any measures in place to ensure that such facilities are not burdened and overpopulated with unclaimed corpses; if not, why not; if so, what (a) measures and (b) steps has his department taken to trace the families of the deceased?

NW2779E 2442.
NW2779E 2442.

Prof C T Msimang (IFP) to ask the President of the Republic: Considering that he recently authorised the Special Investigating Unit to investigate allegations of serious maladministration in the affairs of a certain Office (details furnished), which was identified by reports of the Auditor-General of South Africa, (a) how long will the specified investigation take, (b) what total budget has been set aside and (c) what are the expected outcomes?

NW2780E 2443.
NW2780E 2443.

Prof C T Msimang (IFP) to ask the Minister of Justice and Correctional Services: Considering that prisons are not equipped to accommodate persons living with disabilities, what is his department’s five-year plan for constructing and making available correctional facilities that accommodate persons living with disabilities?

NW2781E 2444.
Mr N Singh (IFP) to ask the Minister of Health: Whether his department conducted any studies and/or live monitoring to assess the current extent of electromagnetic pollution in urban and rural areas caused by (a) Internet Wi-Fi [5G], (b) Low Earth Orbit satellites, (c) mobile phone towers and (d) Internet fibre cables; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details of any (i) potential negative impacts on human, animal and environmental health and (ii) legislative and/or regulatory measures (aa) currently being considered and (bb) already in place to manage and mitigate the pollution to acceptable levels?
NW2782E 2445.
Ms S A Buthelezi (IFP) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs: Whether, considering that her department has briefed the Portfolio Committee on Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs regarding the Disaster Contingency Plan for the upcoming winter, her department has identified areas to be allocated for housing across all provinces in order to avoid a repetition of flood victims being displaced and having to live in community halls for an indefinite time; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?
NW2783E 2446.

Ms S A Buthelezi (IFP) to ask the Minister of Police: Whether, given that there has been an exponential increase in the killings of amakhosi or traditional leaders in the past decade, the SA Police Service has taken any steps to (a) bring to book those responsible for the killings and (b) curb the phenomenon; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?

NW2784E INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 857 2447.
Ms Z Majozi (IFP) to ask the Minister of Police: Given that mass shootings, such as the Enyobeni Tavern shooting that took place almost a year ago in East London in the Eastern Cape, have occurred in the Republic and have been increasing in the past few years throughout different provinces, what (a) progress has been made with the investigations into mass shootings and (b) steps have been taken to prevent similar incidents from occurring?

NW2785E 2448.
Ms L L van der Merwe (IFP) to ask the Minister of Social Development: Considering that, according to the Estimates of National Expenditure 2023 shared by the National Treasury, her department intends to strengthen community engagements in 34 districts over the medium term by implementing the Community Mobilisation and Empowerment Framework, which promotes the use of household and community profiling to inform service and support provision and furthermore aims to link 2% of grant recipients with sustainable livelihood opportunities, (a) how did her department reach the 2% target and (b) what are the detailed reasons that the specified figure is so low, considering that there are almost 27 million grant recipients?
NW2787E 2449.
Mr M S F de Freitas (DA) to ask the Minister of Tourism: With reference to flights, accommodation and other expenses incurred by South African Tourism (SAT) linked to the proposed Tottenham Hotspur deal, (a) what were the total expenses incurred per line item for each party in each case, (b)(i) how and (ii) by what date will the specified expenses be reimbursed to the SAT by the parties concerned, (c) who will reimburse the expenses, (d)(i) what are the total amounts to be reimbursed and (ii) by whom in each case and (e) what are the reimbursement terms and conditions in each case?
NW2789E 2450.

Mr M S F de Freitas (DA) to ask the Minister of Public Enterprises: With reference to surveys emailed to passengers who had recently travelled with SA Airways, (a) how (i) are the responses to completed surveys analysed and (ii) is the information used and (b) what is the average turnaround time between receipt of survey responses and the collation of the information?

NW2790E 2451.
Mr N P Masipa (DA) to ask the Minister of Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development: (1) What total amount (a) has been allocated to each agri-park in each financial year since it was established and (b) was spent by each specified agri-park in each specified financial year; (2) whether she will furnish Mr N P Masipa with the full list of all agri-parks, indicating (a) the total number of agri-parks, (b) the relevant details of the current status of each agri-park and (c) which agri-parks are currently (i) functional and (ii) dysfunctional; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?
NW2792E INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 858 2452.
Mr N P Masipa (DA) to ask the Minister of Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development: (1) Whether she will furnish Mr N P Masipa with the relevant details about the dysfunctional agri-parks regarding the (a) total amount spent on each dysfunctional agri-park project, (b) reasons for the failures, (c) actions taken against the implementors and (d) total number of jobs lost as a result of the failed projects; (2) whether her department intends to allocate additional money towards the projects; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?
NW2793E 2453.

Mr N P Masipa (DA) to ask the Minister of Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development: Considering that the Animal Health Act, Act 7 of 2002, was passed by Parliament and signed into law by former president Mr Thabo Mbeki in 2002, what (a) are the reasons that the specified Act was never promulgated and (b) was the name of the official who failed to implement the Act?

NW2794E 2454.
Ms H Ismail (DA) to ask the Minister of Tourism: (1) What total number of (a) directors-general (DGs), (b) deputy directors-general (DDGs), (c) chief executive officers (CEOs) and (d) acting CEOs are in each section and/or entity of her department; (2) (3) (4) whether there are any performance management criteria that they adhere to; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details; what consequence management criteria are in place for such DGs, DDGs, CEOs and acting CEOs; what (a) total number of senior management vacancies are in her department and (b) are the relevant details of the salaries attached to each?
NW2795E 2455.
Ms H Ismail (DA) to ask the Minister of Tourism: (1) What total number of disciplinary actions and/or consequence management action have been taken and/or are implemented against any of the (a) directors- general (DGs), (b) deputy directors-general (DDGs), (c) chief executive officers (CEOs) and (d) acting CEOs for any irregular and/or wasteful expenditure incurred in each (i) entity and/or (ii) project of her department; (2) (3) whether her department has done any audits on all projects initiated by her department to date; if not, why not; if so, whether she will furnish Ms H Ismail with the full, relevant details in a detailed report; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?
NW2796E INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 859 2456.
Ms H Ismail (DA) to ask the Minister of Tourism: (1) Whether she will furnish Ms H Ismail with a comprehensive overview of the procedure that was followed from the point when SA Tourism conceived the idea of a trip to New York to celebrate the Freedom Day to the stage when the proposal was formally put forward for approval; if not, why not, if so, what are the relevant details; (2) what checks and balances are in place to ensure that proposed expenditure is compliant with rules and regulations?
NW2797E 2457.

Mrs M O Clarke (DA) to ask the Minister of Health: Regarding the case of medical negligence that the Health Professions Council of South Africa failed to investigate (details furnished), in what way will his department assist the forensic investigator to get to the bottom of all the queries and/or allegations?

NW2798E 2458.
Mrs M O Clarke (DA) to ask the Minister of Health: (1) What (a) is the (i) name and (ii) type of health facility in each province and (b) category of public hospital does each specified facility fall under; (2) (3) (a) what is the ideal clinic status of each facility and (b) on what date was the last inspection conducted; (a) what (i) number and (ii) type of health facilities are currently developed in each province, (b) by what date will each facility be completed and (c) what is the cost of each facility that is currently developed?
NW2799E 2459.

Mr N G Myburgh (DA) to ask the Minister of Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment: (1) What steps has her department taken to salvage the remaining wetlands of the Republic as 50% is destroyed and 30% is in a weak ecological condition; (2) whether she will furnish Mr N G Myburgh with the details of any plans for the effective recovery of already destroyed and/or seriously damaged wetlands; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?

NW2800E 2460.
NW2800E 2460.

Mr N G Myburgh (DA) to ask the Minister of Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development: What is the total Rand value of agricultural produce exported from the Republic to the (a) United States of America, (b) European Union, (c) Russian Federation, (d) People’s Republic of China and (e) African continent in the 2022-23 financial year?

NW2801E 2461.
Ms A M M Weber (DA) to ask the Minister of Water and Sanitation: (1) Whether his department received the application for a Water Use Licence General Authorisation (WULGA) for the Kusile Wetland Offset Plan from Eskom Holdings SOC Ltd; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what is the date of the specified application; INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 860 (2) Whether he will furnish Ms A M M Weber with the details of whether Eskom Holdings Pty (Ltd) has received the WULGA license for the Kusile Wetland Offset plan; if not, why not; if so what are the relevant details??
NW2802E 2462.
Ms A M M Weber (DA) to ask the Minister of Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment: (1) What are the reasons that Eskom Holdings SOC Ltd has not yet started to rehabilitate the badly degraded wetlands (details furnished) in the Victor Khanye Local Municipality in Mpumalanga; (2) (3) (a) what is the current state of the specified wetlands and (b) by what date will Eskom Holdings SOC Ltd commence with the rehabilitation of the wetlands; what are the details of the (a) vegetation and (b) biodiversity that has been destroyed to date?
NW2803E 2463.
Ms A M M Weber (DA) to ask the Minister of Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment: (1) Whether Canada and the Republic will split the expenses incurred for firefighting as the two countries signed a Memorandum of Understanding for the exchange of wildland fire management resources (details furnished); if not, why not; if so, what part of the cost will each country cover; (2) (3) whether she will furnish Ms A M M Weber with the breakdown of expenses regarding (a) the cost of (i) return flights, (ii) accommodation and food and (iii) equipment and resources and (b) all the other associated costs; (a) from which province does each (i) fire fighter and (ii) manager come from and (b) what is the total number of (i) fire fighters and (ii) managers from each province?
NW2804E 2464.
Mr T A le Goff (DA) to ask the Minister of Mineral Resources and Energy: (1) With reference to the replies to question 54 on 24 February 2023 and 213 on 1 March 2023, and given the current need to end load shedding, (a) on what basis were bids regarding the 3200 megawatts (MW) of renewables rejected due to insufficient space on the grid and (b) what are the reasons that only 1000MW was procured when grid space was available; (2) (3) (a) on what document and/or information does he rely to determine whether or not the grid is full, (b) how does he verify the information to ensure that the grid is full or not and (c) on what date will the Grid Capacity Allocation Rules be revised to ensure that the projects that are not ready to come online do not continue to take up space on the grid; whether, given the urgent need to end load shedding and the fact that there is over 3400MW available in the Eastern and Western Cape, the remainder of the 3000MW Bid Window 6 will be reopened to be further allocated; if not, why not; if so, on what date?
NW2805E INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 861 2465.
Mr A C Roos (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs: With regard to the total number of tourism visa applications received by his department in the 2022-23 financial year, (a) what total number of visa applications were (i) received and (ii) rejected, (b) for what reasons that they were rejected and (c) what were the nationalities of the persons (i) who had successfully applied and (ii) whose applications were rejected?

NW2806E 2466.
Mr A C Roos (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs: (a) Who is the chairperson of the Immigration Advisory Board that was established in terms of section 4 and 5 of the Immigration Act, Act 13 of 2002, (b) who are the other members of the board appointed in terms of section 4(2)(a-l) of the specified Act, (c) what number of meetings were held by the board in the 2022-23 financial year, (d) what was the advice and/or outputs of the board to him in the specified financial year and (e) what was the total remuneration paid to the board in the 2022-23 financial year?
NW2807E 2467.

Mr A C Roos (DA) to ask the Minister of Home Affairs: What (a) was the total value of (i) court orders and (ii) court settlements with his department in the 2022-23 financial year, (b) was the interest accrued on the specified court orders and/or settlements and (c) were the total fees paid to legal counsel on the court cases and/or settlements?

NW2808E 2468.
Ms S J Graham (DA) to ask the Minister in The Presidency: (1) What are the (a) relevant details of the progress that has been made on the (i) establishment of a state-owned holding company to house strategic state-owned entities (SOEs) and (ii) recommendations to retain, consolidate and/or dispose of SOEs and (b) time frames in terms of the establishment and implementation of the recommendations; (2) (3) whether the evidence-based criteria for the restructuring of SOEs have been published; if not, on what date will the criteria be published; if so, whether she will furnish Ms S J Graham with the specified evidence-based criteria; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?
NW2809E 2469.
Ms S J Graham (DA) to ask the Minister of Public Works and Infrastructure: (1) (2) (3) (a) On what date was the last assessment of the condition of the Brighton Beach Police Station buildings in Bluff in KwaZulu-Natal conducted, (b) what buildings were assessed and (c) what are the details of the findings; what is the progress of the installation of the JoJo tanks that have been installed with pumps that have not been linked to the water system; what (a) processes were used in terms of the allocation of living quarters for (i) single and (ii) married SA Police Service (SAPS) officials and (b) are the basic standards of accommodation provided by the SAPS at the specified precinct; INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 862 (4) (5) what safety assessment has been conducted on the basement of the single quarters where water and sewage are overflowing into the basement; whether a budget has been allocated for repairs and refurbishment of the station in the current financial year; if not, by what date will a budgeting process be undertaken to address the issues at the police station; if so, what are the relevant details?
NW2810E 2470.

Ms S J Graham (DA) to ask the President of the Republic: (1) (2) (3) On what date was the Presidential Climate Finance Task Team (PCFTT) established; what total number of meetings have been held by the PCFTT since its establishment; whether the PCFTT has put together a programme of action for the roll-out of the Just Energy Transition Implementation Plan with time frames; if not, on what date will the programme of action for the roll-out be available; if so, what are the relevant details?
NW2811E 2471.

Mrs C Phillips (DA) to ask the Minister of Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment: Whether her department intends taking over the function of awarding environmental authorisation for prospecting and mining rights (details furnished) in the core and transition zone of all biospheres; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what are the relevant details?

NW2812E 2472.
NW2812E 2472.

Mr G K Y Cachalia (DA) to ask the Minister of Public Enterprises: (1) Whether he will furnish Mr G K Y Cachalia with an update of the outcome of the freight rail plan of Transnet; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details; (2) what are the (a) relevant details of the progress that has been made in fast- tracking the participation of the private sector in its major corridors and (b) details of the (i) time frames and (ii) interested parties?

NW2813E 2473.
Mr S Ngcobo (DA) to ask the Minister of Higher Education, Science and Innovation: (1) (2) Considering the rising levels of gender-based violence and other crimes in institutions of higher learning and training, what are the reasons that his department is deferring the full implementation of the Safety and Security Minimum Norms and Standards to the 2024-25 financial year; what steps is his department currently taking to ensure the safety and security of students and staff in institutions of higher learning and training across the Republic?
NW2814E INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 863 2474.

Ms H S Winkler (DA) to ask the Minister of Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development: (1) Whether, with reference to her reply to question 1384 on 4 May 2023, she will clarify the discrepancy in the reference numbers with regard to Farm Meyershoek No.
847; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what are the relevant details; (2) (3) at what stage is claim KRN6/2/2/E/42/0/0/25 that was implemented to accommodate community members who were not part of the original claim KRN6/2/2/E/42/0/0/202; (a) what is the timeline for the conclusion of the claim, (b) what are the reasons that there has been a delay to finalise the specified claim, (c) what are the reasons that her department is allegedly restarting the process of the claim when in fact it should be in its final stage and (d) how will her department assist the residents of the community who have waited for years for the claim to be processed and were told it was in the final stages, only to find that now the process is allegedly starting from scratch?
NW2815E 2475.

Ms H S Winkler (DA) to ask the Minister of Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment: What (a) role and (b) recourse does her department have in terms of monitoring and guiding provincial environmental departments when they do not comply with legislation?

NW2816E 2476.
Ms H S Winkler (DA) to ask the Minister of Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment: (1) Whether there is any plan for a process to review the total allowable catch (TAC) allotted to commercial fishing rights holders in order to accommodate the allocation of a higher quantity of small-scale fishing rights; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what are the relevant details; (2) whether her department has any plan in place to accommodate customary fishing rights where they clash with existing fishing rights implemented by her department; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?
NW2817E 2477.
Mr T W Mhlongo (DA) to ask the Minister of Sport, Arts and Culture: (1) With reference to his reply to question 1552 on 17 May 2023, what (a) amount was paid as an incentive to the winners and (b) is the name of each beneficiary of the incentive; (2) (3) (4) (a) on what date was the tender for the event advertised and (b) what was the amount of the tender; what (a) advertising agency and/or media house was used to advertise the specified tender and (b) were the specifications on the tender document; what (a) was the closing date for the tender and (b) number of companies submitted bids for the event; INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 864 (5) whether he will furnish Mr T W Mhlongo with the details of all the companies that were shortlisted as service providers for the event; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?
NW2818E 2478.
Mrs M B Hicklin (DA) to ask the Minister of Public Works and Infrastructure: (1) (2) (3) (4) (a) What was the purpose of the dinner that was held immediately after the debate on Budget Vote 13 on 23 May 2023 and (b) where was it held; (a) what amount did the dinner cost for each person and (b) from which budget line item was the budget for the dinner apportioned; what (a) number of stakeholders were invited to the specified dinner and (b) was the intended outcome of the dinner; what benefit to (a) her department, (b) the annual performance plans and (c) key performance indicators did the dinner fulfil?
NW2819E 2479.
Mr J F Smalle (DA) to ask the Minister of Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment: (1) What (a) number of times has raw sewage spills affected the water quality of downstream users of the Arabie Dam in the Ephraim Mogale Local Municipality, Limpopo, since 1 June 2019, (b) actions have been taken to mitigate against the sewage spills, (c) is the source of the sewage spills and (d) actions have been taken against any (i) person and/or (ii) institution in this regard and (e) are the details of any report that was issued; (2) (a) what was the (i) effect of the sewage spill on the environment and water quality and (ii) total cost to rehabilitate the sewage spill and (b) what are the relevant details of any report that was issued in this regard?
NW2820E 2480.

Mr J F Smalle (DA) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs: What (a) has been the total (i) monetary value and (ii) percentage of the (aa) water and (bb) electricity losses recorded by her department for each municipality in the past three financial years and (b) contingency plans did (i) her department and (ii) specified municipalities put in place to curb the specified losses?

NW2821E 2481.
NW2821E 2481.

Mr J F Smalle (DA) to ask the Minister of Water and Sanitation: (1) What steps has his department taken to intervene to improve the quality of drinking water in the Musina Local Municipality, Limpopo, following the direct pumping of water from the river to residences due to load shedding; (2) (a) at what intervals is the water tested and (b) what are the relevant details of the contaminants that were found to include high quantities of pollutants?
NW2822E INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 865 2482.
Ms O M C Maotwe (EFF) to ask the Minister of Finance: (1) What (a) number of tenders did Eskom award using deviations that required the approval of the National Treasury in the period 1 December 2019 to 28 February 2023 and (b) are the details of tenders that (i) were approved and (ii) were not approved; (2) what (a) was the total monetary value of each of the tenders, (b) were the services for which each tender was awarded and (c) were the entities that were awarded the tenders?

NW2823E 2483.
NW2823E 2483.

Ms O M C Maotwe (EFF) to ask the Minister of Public Enterprises: Whether the information received by Eskom management that indicated a potential serious security risk to Eskom’s operations and assets, which led to the R500 million security tender, was provided by a privately funded investigation; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what checks and balances were employed to ensure that there was no corruption, price inflation, and/or fraud in the transaction?

NW2824E 2484.
Ms O M C Maotwe (EFF) to ask the Minister of Public Enterprises: Whether he was informed that the information provided to Eskom management indicating a potential serious security risk to Eskom’s operations and assets was sourced from a privately funded investigation when he approved the R500 million security tender; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what are the relevant details of the issues that gave credibility to the findings of an investigation conducted by individuals without proper accreditation and that was carried out in a clandestine manner that warranted his approval?
NW2825E 2485.
Mr S Tambo (EFF) to ask the Minister of Public Works and Infrastructure: (1) What (a) number of projects have stalled for a period exceeding 12 months due to construction company incapacities in the past five years, (b) is the total monetary value of the projects, (c) are the full details of the projects and (d) have been the consequences to the companies and/or owners of the construction companies; (2) whether he intends to establish a state-owned construction company to ensure such conduct does not arise in future; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?
NW2826E 2486.

Mrs T P Msane (EFF) to ask the Minister of International Relations and Cooperation: What innovations has the African Union Research Unit established to have more reliable and effective early warning systems in place when it comes to climate change as it displaced and affected a lot of Africans in the recent years?

NW2827E INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 866 2487.
Mrs T P Msane (EFF) to ask the Minister of International Relations and Cooperation: Whether the Southern African Development Community assessed the preparation and build-up to the Zimbabwean government elections which are due to take place in August 2023 to ensure that the elections will be fair and transparent, noting that the Zimbabwean government has signed the Patriotic Bill into law; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what are the relevant details?

NW2828E 2488.
NW2828E 2488.

Ms P Marais (EFF) to ask the Minister of Water and Sanitation: Whether he has been informed that the tap water in Ward 5, Riemvasmaak in the Kou- Kamma Local Municipality, is brown and dirty, and that residents are complaining of stomach pains and diarrhoea; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what (a) is the position in this regard and (b) interventions have been provided in this regard?

NW2829E 2489.
NW2829E 2489.

Mr K Ceza (EFF) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs: What (a) number of infrastructure projects undertaken by her department have not been finished according to schedule in the past three years and (b)(i) number of persons have been held liable in terms of an investigation under section 106 of the Local Government: Municipal Systems Act, Act 32 of 2000, on wasteful and unauthorised expenditure and (ii) are the further relevant details in this regard?
NW2830E 2490.

Mrs L F Tito (EFF) to ask the Minister of Transport: What are the full details of the measures that her department has put in place to (a) protect and (b) replace guard rails that are being stolen and targeted by steel recyclers?

NW2831E 2491.
Ms R N Komane (EFF) to ask the Minister of Police: Whether, in view of the Parliamentary Budget office having identified compensation of employees and contingent liabilities as possible risks to the 2023 appropriations and expressed concerns over unfunded budgets for the compensation of employees in many departments, the SA Police Service has shown an increase of approximately 5000 police trainees but a reduction in the expenditure; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what are the reasons?
NW2832E 2492.

Ms R N Komane (EFF) to ask the Minister of Finance: (1) Which departments are the main drivers of the misalignment of the economic policy; (2) whether the misalignment of the economic policy is because the Government does not have legislation that enforces collaboration and coordination; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what are the relevant details?

NW2833E INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 867 2493.
Ms N N Chirwa (EFF) to ask the Minister of Health: What (a) are the reasons that the Mafikeng Provincial Hospital does not have enough bed space for new-born babies and (b) measures have been put in place to ensure that new-born babies are not being placed in cardboard boxes again?

NW2834E 2494.
NW2834E 2494.

Ms N N Chirwa (EFF) to ask the Minister of Mineral Resources and Energy: With reference to the numerous mines that have been cited as neither meeting their obligations in community projects nor giving back to the communities in which they operate, what (a) are the details of the mines that (i) have not been meeting their community obligations and (ii) are repeat offenders in this regard and (b) steps did his department take in response to the offending mines?

NW2837E 2495.
Ms N P Sonti (EFF) to ask the Minister of Higher Education, Science and Innovation: With reference to the recommendations contained in the report submitted to him by Professor Norman Duncan, in which it is stated that students claimed that they were scammed by the employees of the Central University of Technology, (a) what steps will he take to intervene in the matter, (b) in what way will the involved parties be held accountable and (c) on what date is it envisaged that consequence management will take place?
NW2839E 2496.

Ms N P Sonti (EFF) to ask the Minister of Higher Education, Science and Innovation: What steps does his department intend to take to (a) resolve the matter of the workers of the Sefako Makgatho Health Sciences University who are said to have downed tools in protest over a 7% wage increase and (b) concede to the demands of the workers?

NW2840E 2497.
NW2840E 2497.

Ms N P Sonti (EFF) to ask the Minister of Higher Education, Science and Innovation: With reference to the fatal stabbing of a female student at a residence of the Nelson Mandela University, (a) what steps does he intend to take to mainstream security features across all institutions of higher learning to avoid incidents of gender-based violence and femicide continue to haunt institutions of higher learning and (b) by what date will the efforts be initiated?

NW2841E 2498.
Mr K Ceza (EFF) to ask the Minister of Health: Whether, with reference to the Gauteng Department of Health that is alleged to have failed to spend over R2 billion of its budget, amidst the devastating status of health facilities and conditions that persons have to deal with in health facilities in Gauteng, his department has undertaken any investigation to find out the cause of the failure; if not, why not; if so, (a) what has been found to be the reason for the failure, (b) how does he intend to ensure that funds that are meant to improve and cater for the health needs of our people are utilised for what they are meant for across the Republic and (c) what is the direct impact of the failure on (i) the quality of healthcare in the province and (ii) the lives of persons who require quality health care services?
NW2842E INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 868 2499.
Ms L H Arries (EFF) to ask the Minister of Social Development: (1) What are the details of the processes that were followed in the awarding a three-year security contract worth R61m to three companies by her department in Limpopo; (2) whether there were any declarations made of matrimonially connected directors; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what the relevant details; (3) whether any conflict of interest was declared; if not, why not; if so, what are the elevant details?

NW2843E 2500.
Ms L H Arries (EFF) to ask the Minister of Social Development: Whether her department, in collaboration with any other relevant law enforcement agencies, engaged in any operation to curb the confiscation of the cards of SA Social Security Agency (SASSA) beneficiaries by loan sharks, shop owners, drug dealers and/or any other unscrupulous businesses over the past five years; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what (a) total number of cards were recovered in each province, (b) measures have been put in place to ensure that the practice is eliminated and (c) programmes has she put in place to educate SASSA beneficiaries about such unlawful arrangements?
NW2844E 2501.

Ms L H Arries (EFF) to ask the Minister of Social Development: In each of the past five years, (a) which provinces witnessed a rise in child malnutrition, (b) by what percentage has malnutrition risen in each province and (c) what interventions have been put in place for such provinces?

NW2845E 2502.
NW2845E 2502.

Dr S S Thembekwayo (EFF) to ask the Minister of Health: Whether he has been informed that staff at the Bheki Mlangeni District Hospital in Gauteng have been ill-treating a 97-year-old patient by tying his one leg to the bed; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what (a) urgent intervention has he taken in this regard and (b) are the reasons for tying up the patient?

NW2846E 2503.
NW2846E 2503.

Dr S S Thembekwayo (EFF) to ask the Minister of Basic Education: Whether she has been informed that the Letlhabile High School in Mamelodi have broken toilets due to ageing infrastructure; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what are the relevant details of the intervention that she will initiate in this regard?

NW2847E 2504.
Ms A M Siwisa (EFF) to ask the Minister of Public Works and Infrastructure: (1) With reference to the information provided to the Portfolio Committee on Public Works and Infrastructure on 7 June 2023 that there are 238 land parcels in KwaZulu-Natal and that 18 of those have already been identified, what total number of the land parcels are situated in the eThekwini Metropolitan Municipality, where flood victims are still accommodated in halls and other temporary structures; INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 869 (2) whether any of the land parcels have been handed over to the Department of Human Settlements in order to build houses for flood victims to restore their dignity; if not, why not; if so, (a)(i) what total number of land parcels was handed over and (ii) on what date and (b) what are the relevant details of the memoranda of understanding between her department and the Department of Human Settlements?
NW2848E 2505.

Ms A M Siwisa (EFF) to ask the Minister of Health: (a) What steps of intervention has he taken to address the concerns raised about the clinic in KwaMashu Section E, which is in a condition of dilapidation and putting the lives of the ill members of the community who visit the clinic to seek medical attention at risk, (b) on what date is it envisaged that renovations will take place and (c) what are the relevant details of the time frames that have been put in place in this regard?
NW2849E 2506.
Ms C N Mkhonto (EFF) to ask the Minister of Justice and Correctional Services: (1) Whether the 2023-24 budget allocated to the Special Investigating Unit (SIU) accommodates possible increase in compensation of employees, in view of the unprecedented high volume of work emanating from all three spheres of government that is given to the SIU; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details; (2) (3) (4) what is the (a) total number of vacancies at the SIU and (b) time frame with specific dates on which the vacant positions will be filled; (a) what total amount does his department owe the SIU and (b) how old is the debt; whether any interventions and/or measures have been put in place to ensure that government institutions and entities pay the SIU on time; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?
NW2850E 2507.

Ms B Mathulelwa (EFF) to ask the Minister of Small Business Development: In light of how small businesses and/or co-operatives are struggling to access funding from her department, what total number of businesses did she develop in her hometown since the start of her term of office?

NW2851E 2508.

Ms B Mathulelwa (EFF) to ask the Minister of Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment: Which secured places in the coastal Eastern Cape and KwaZulu-Natal have been reserved for informal fisheries?
NW2852E 2509.

Mr W T I Mafanya (EFF) to ask the Minister of Defence and Military Veterans: What are the reasons that the new uniform of the SA National Defence Force is being manufactured in other countries when the Republic is the most viable country to produce it?

NW2853E INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 870 2510.
Mr N S Matiase (EFF) to ask the Minister of Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development: (1) Whether her department has started the Pietermaritzburg High Court that all monies paid to the Ingonyama Trust by all persons and any other entity under the lease agreement should be refunded; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what total number of persons have been refunded; the order of implementing (2) whether she has reported to the court on the steps taken to comply with the order within three months of the date of the court order and every three months thereafter until the parties agree that the court order has been implemented; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?
NW2854E 2511.
Mr N S Matiase (EFF) to ask the Minister of Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development: Whether, since the ruling of the Pietermaritzburg High Court delivered on 11 June 2021, she has corrected the breach of her duty of ensuring that administrative measures to respect, protect, promote and fulfil the constitutional right to property and security of tenure of the holders of informal land rights for persons living under Ingonyama Trust land in KwaZulu-Natal are protected; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what are the further, relevant details?
NW2855E 2512.
Mr N S Matiase (EFF) to ask the Minister of Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development: (1) Whether, since the ruling of the Pietermaritzburg High Court delivered on 11 June 2021, she has ensured administrative and corrective measures such as implementing an alternative system of recording customary and other informal rights to land of persons and communities residing in land held by trusts; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details; (2) whether she has ensured that the necessary administrative capacity to implement Chapter XI of the KwaZulu-Natal Land Affairs Act, Act 11 of 1994, and that of the KwaZulu-Natal Land Affairs (Permission to Occupy) Regulations are reinstated; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details?
NW2856E 2513.

Mr T Mogale (EFF) to ask the Minister of International Relations and Cooperation: (1) Whether the BRICS summit will still be held in the Republic; if not, why not; if so, (2) whether the President of Russia, Mr Vladimir Putin, will be in attendance physically at the summit; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, how is the Government planning to handle the arrest warrant issued against President Putin?
NW2857E INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 871 2514.
Mr A V Khoza (EFF) to ask the Minister of Public Service and Administration: In light of the practice by big businesses, banks and other corporates of seconding their employees to state departments, including The Presidency, what (a) total number of employees from the specified entities are seconded to the State departments, (b) number of secondments are paid by the (i) respective entities and (ii) State and (c) are the companies getting in return for them to second own employees to the State and even pay them?
NW2858E 2515.

Mr A V Khoza (EFF) to ask the Minister of Transport: In light of the report that the Republic has a total of 331 909 kilometres of roads spanning rural tracks, gravel roads, tarred roads, highways and freeways, what (a) total number of the roads in the Republic are tarred and (b) is the Government’s plan to have the untarred roads tarred, in order to facilitate human and vehicular?

NW2859E 2516.
NW2859E 2516.

Mr A V Khoza (EFF) to ask the Minister of Public Works and Infrastructure: In light of the fact that the Park Road Police Station has been under construction for many years now and is still incomplete despite three contractors having been contracted to do the construction, (a) what happened to the two previous contractors, (b)(i) what total amount were they paid and (ii) over what period of time and (c) what percentage of the budget has been expended to date in the project?

NW2860E 2517.
NW2860E 2517.

Mrs N J Nolutshungu (EFF) to ask the Minister of Health: What (a) measures have been put in place to ensure that residents in the deep rural areas of the Eastern Cape have easy access to ambulance services and (b) total number of ambulances have been allocated for each rural municipality?

NW2861E 2518.
NW2861E 2518.

Mrs N J Nolutshungu (EFF) to ask the Minister of Basic Education: (a) What (i) total number of learners are currently not accommodated in the Scholar Transport Programme in each province and (ii) are the reasons in this regard and (b)(i) on what date is it envisaged that all learners will be accommodated in the programme and (ii) what time frames have been put in place in this regard?

NW2862E 2519.
Mrs N J Nolutshungu (EFF) to ask the Minister of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs: (1) (2) Whether she will furnish Mrs N J Nolutshungu with a list of all (a) bridges and (b) roads that were damaged by floods in (i) KwaZulu-Natal and (ii) the Eastern Cape; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details; (a) which of the specified bridges and roads (i) were fixed and (ii) are still not fixed and (b) what time frames have been put in place to fix all bridges and roads that are still not yet fixed?
NW2863E 2520.

Mr A Matumba (EFF) to ask the Minister of Tourism: On what date will she take action against a certain member of the SA Tourism Board (name furnished) against whom the Portfolio Committee on Tourism recommended consequence management for allegedly misleading them?

NW2864E INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 872 2521.
Mr A Matumba (EFF) to ask the Minister of Tourism: What is the policy position on collaboration on the collection and collation of tourist data between her department, Statistics South Africa and the Department of Home Affairs?

NW2865E 2522.

Mr A Matumba (EFF) to ask the Minister of Tourism: What is the policy position on the development of tourism economic accounts at a provincial and local level to elevate the economic value of tourism on local economic development?

NW2866E 2523.
Mr B N Herron (Good) to ask the President of the Republic: (1) With regard to the findings of the Special Investigating Unit (SIU), as reported in the Final Consolidated Report for Proclamation R23 of 2020, dated 10 December 2021, in particular the findings of the SIU on the City of Cape Town (CCT) (details furnished), what progress has been made by the SIU regarding instructions to the State Attorney; (2) (3) (4) (5) whether any civil action has been instituted following the report of the SIU; if not, why not; if so, (a) on what date and (b) what is the current status of such action; whether the SIU informed the CCT that the (a) expenditure was regarded as irregular and (b) service provider profited excessively; if not, why not, in each case; if so, on what date was the CCT informed; whether the SIU had directed and/or expected of the City Manager (CM) to take any steps; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what steps whether the SIU report found that the CM had taken the specified steps; if not, what are the consequences set out in the report of not taking the steps; if so, on what date did the SIU find that the CM took the steps?
NW2871E 2524.
Mr B N Herron (Good) to ask the Minister of Mineral Resources and Energy: (1) Whether, with reference to his reply to question 214 on 24 February 2023, regarding the partnership between Eskom and Cape Peninsula University of Technology (CPUT), his department has any role to play in the just energy transmission programme (JETP); if not, why not; if so, (2) (3) (4) whether the retraining programme that is being implemented by Eskom and CPUT therefore is of no interest to his department as it has a role to play in the JEPT; if not, why not; if so, what are the relevant details; whether his department has its own JETP; if not, (a) why not and (b) which department is responsible for ensuring a just transition in the energy supply chain; if so, what are the relevant details; whether there are any plans to replicate or implement similar programmes as part of his department’s just energy transition plans; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what are the further, relevant details; INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 873 (5) what total number of affected employees has his department targeted for retraining under its own JETP plan?
NW2872E SUMMARY OF QUESTIONS QUESTIONS FOR ORAL REPLY QUESTIONS TO WHICH A REPLY WAS NOT SUBMITTED IN ACCORDANCE WITH RULE 143(1) AND SUBSEQUENTLY ENDORSED AS UNANSWERED IN ACCORDANCE WITH RULE 143(2) FOR REPORT TO LEADER OF GOVERNMENT BUSINESS (RULE 136(1)) WEDNESDAY, 14 JUNE 2023 CLUSTER 1 PEACE AND SECURITY 340.

Mr Q R Dyantyi (ANC) (p37)—Justice and Correctional Services 348.

Ms M R M Mothapo (ANC) (p38)—Defence and Military Veterans 351.
Ms T R M Zungu (ANC) (p38)—Defence and Military Veterans 317.

Mr D J Stubbe (DA) (p38)—Minister in The Presidency 362.

Mrs Y N Yako (EFF) (p38)— Justice and Correctional Services WEDNESDAY, 7 JUNE 2023 CLUSTER 5: ECONOMICS 253.

Mr F Jacobs (ANC) (p32)— Small Business Development.

[Standing over – Rule 144(2)] 302.

Ms B Mathulelwa (EFF) (p32)— Small Business Development.

[Standing over – Rule 144(2)] 256.

Mr L E McDonald (ANC) (p33)— Transport.

269.


Mr D Bergman (DA) (p33)— Trade, Industry and Competition.

292.

Inkosi R N Cebekhulu (IFP) (p34)— Trade, Industry and Competition.
INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 874 QUESTIONS FOR WRITTEN REPLY QUESTIONS TO WHICH A REPLY WAS NOT SUBMITTED IN ACCORDANCE WITH RULE 145(5) AND SUBSEQUENTLY ENDORSED AS UNANSWERED IN ACCORDANCE WITH RULE 146(3) FOR REPORT TO LEADER OF GOVERNMENT BUSINESS THURSDAY, 9 FEBRUARY 2023 (REPLY BY 23 FEBRUARY 2023) ◙3.

Ms T L Marawu (ATM) (p2)—The Minister in The Presidency.

◙5.

Ms T Breedt (FF Plus) (p3)—Communications and Digital Technologies.

◙13.
◙13.

Mr N P Masipa (DA) (p5)—Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development.

◙44.

Ms D Kohler (DA) (p11)—Communications and Digital Technologies.

◙99.

Ms TM Mbabama (DA) (p21)—The Minister in The Presidency.

◙128.

Ms M D Hlengwa (IFP) (p27)—Minister in The Presidency for Women, Youth and Persons with Disabilities.

◙129.

Ms M D Hlengwa (IFP) (p27)—Minister in The Presidency for Women, Youth and Persons with Disabilities.

◙176.

Mr M K Montwedi (EFF) (p35)—Communications and Digital Technologies.
FRIDAY, 17 FEBRUARY 2023 (REPLY BY 3 MARCH 2023) ◙200.

Mr W F Faber (DA) (p)— (p 42)—Police.

◙204.

Mr G R Krumbock (DA) (p 42)—Social Development.

◙209.

Ms TM Mbabama (DA) (p 43)—Minister in the Presidency.

◙210.

Ms TM Mbabama (DA) (p 44)—The Presidency for Women, Youth and Persons with Disabilities.

◙211.

Mr M Bagraim (DA) (p 44)—Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development.

◙224.

Mr P A van Staden (FF Plus) (p.48)—Public Works and Infrastructure.

◙242.
◙242.

Ms D Kohler (DA) (p 52)—Communications and Digital Technologies.

◙254.

Ms S J Graham (DA) (p 54)—Public Works and Infrastructure.

◙255.

Ms S J Graham (DA) (p 55)—Public Works and Infrastructure.

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 875 ◙272.

Mr W Horn (DA) (p.58)—Justice and Correctional Services.

◙294.

Mr S S Zondo (IFP) (p 63)—Public Works and Infrastructure.

◙307.
◙307.

Ms M D Hlengwa (IFP) (p 66)—The Presidency for Women, Youth and Persons with Disabilities.

◙342.

Mr D F Mthenjane (EFF) (p 72)—Minister in The Presidency.

FRIDAY, 24 FEBRUARY 2023 (REPLY BY 10 MARCH 2023) ◙403.

M. Gen O S Terblanche (DA) (p103)—Police.

[53] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))] ◙412.

Dr P J Groenewald (FF Plus) (p106)—to ask the Minister of Police.† ◙510.
Dr P J Groenewald (FF Plus) (p124)—Police.† FRIDAY, 3 MARCH 2023 (REPLY BY 17 MARCH 2023) ◙596.

Ms S J Graham (DA) (p 168)—Public Works and Infrastructure.

◙597.

Ms S J Graham (DA) (p 169)—Communications and Digital Technologies.

◙603.

Ms T Bodlani (DA) (p 170)—Communications and Digital Technologies.

◙616.

Mr H C C Kruger (DA) (p 173)—Minister in The Presidency.

FRIDAY, 10 MARCH 2023 (REPLY BY 27 MARCH 2023) ◙728.
Mr M Bagraim (DA) (p223)—The Presidency for Women, Youth and Persons with Disabilities [180] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

◙730.

Ms N K Sharif (DA) (p223)—The Presidency for Women, Youth and Persons with Disabilities [182] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

◙735.
◙735.

Ms M D Hlengwa (IFP) (p224)—The Presidency for Women, Youth and Persons with Disabilities [190] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

◙747.

Ms D Kohler (DA) (p228)—Communications and Digital Technologies.

◙753.

Dr M M Gondwe (DA) (p229)—Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development.

◙754.

Dr M M Gondwe (DA) (p229)—Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development.
INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 876 ◙768.

Ms S J Graham (DA) (p233)—Communications and Digital Technologies.

◙815.

Prof C T Msimang (IFP) (p244)—Justice and Correctional Services.

FRIDAY, 17 MARCH 2023 (REPLY BY 3 APRIL 2023) ◙882.

Dr P J Groenewald (FF Plus) (p 281)—Police.

◙889.

Ms D Kohler (DA) (p 282)—Minister in The Presidency for Planning, Monitoring and Evaluation.

◙948.

Mr S S Zondo (IFP) (p 295)—Public Works and Infrastructure.

◙953.
◙953.

Mr K P Sithole (IFP) (p 296)—Transport.

◙961.

Ms M D Hlengwa (IFP) (p 297)—Minister in The Presidency for Women, Youth and Persons with Disabilities.

FRIDAY, 24 MARCH 2023 (REPLY BY 11 APRIL 2023) ◙1008.

Mr S Tambo (EFF) (p 331)—Minister in The Presidency: [Interdepartmentally transferred from Communications and Digital Technologies with effect Monday, 27 March 2023].

◙1037.

Ms T Bodlani (DA) (p 336)— Communications and Digital Technologies.

◙1038.
◙1038.

Ms T Bodlani (DA) (p 336)—Communications and Digital Technologies.

◙1039.

Ms T Bodlani (DA) (p 336)—Communications and Digital Technologies.

◙1063.

Ms S J Graham (DA) (p 342)—Public Works and Infrastructure.

◙1064.

Ms S J Graham (DA) (p 342)—Public Works and Infrastructure.

◙1087.

Mr H A Shembeni (EFF) (p 347)—Police.

◙1106.

Mr S S Zondo (IFP) (p 350)—Public Works and Infrastructure.

◙1111.
◙1111.

Ms M D Hlengwa (IFP) (p 351)—Minister in The Presidency for Women, Youth and Persons with Disabilities.

FRIDAY, 31 MARCH 2023 (REPLY BY 18 APRIL 2023) ◙1116.

Ms D Kohler (DA) (p 378)—Communications and Digital Technologies.

◙1165.

Mr W T I Mafanya (EFF) (p 387)—Defence and Military Veterans.

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 877 ◙1179.

Ms P Madokwe (EFF) (p 389)—Police.

◙1222.

Mrs V van Dyk (DA) (p 398)—Sport, Arts and Culture.

◙1223.
◙1223.

Mrs V van Dyk (DA) (p 398)—Sport, Arts and Culture.

◙1241.

Dr L A Schreiber (DA) (p 402)—Communications and Digital Technologies.

◙1252.

Mr J Engelbrecht (DA) (p 404)—Justice and Correctional Services.

◙1253.

Mr J Engelbrecht (DA) (p 404)—Justice and Correctional Services.

FRIDAY, 21 APRIL 2023 (REPLY BY 9 MAY 2023) ◙1281.

Mr V Pambo (EFF) (p445)—and Correctional Services.

◙1283.

Mrs E N Ntlangwini (EFF) (p445)—Finance.

◙1302.

Ms P Marais (EFF) (p448)— Justice and Correctional Services.
◙1325.

Mrs Y N Yako (EFF) (p452)—Justice and Correctional Services.

◙1351.

Mrs V van Dyk (DA) (p458)—Sport, Arts and Culture.

◙1358.

Mr A G Whitfield (DA) (p460)—Police.

◙1359.

M. Gen O S Terblanche (DA) (p460)—Police.

◙1360.

Dr L A Schreiber (DA) (p460)—Finance.

◙1364.

Ms B S Masango (DA) (p461)—Social Development.

◙1366.

Ms D Kohler (DA) (p461)—Finance.

◙1367.

Mr A G Whitfield (DA) (p461)—Police.

◙1368.

Mr A G Whitfield (DA) (p462)—Police.

◙1369.
◙1369.

Ms T Bodlani (DA) to ask the Minister in the Presidency: [Interdepartmentally transferred from Communications and Digital Technologies with effect Monday, 15 May 2023] What are the (a) reasons that the Media Development and Diversity Agency funding process does not make direct payment to the beneficiaries instead of making payments via intermediaries and (b) full details of all (i) intermediaries that were utilised and (ii) related (bb) since the 2022-23 1 April 2023?
NW15 71E financial year and transactions (aa) for ◙1376.

Mr W Horn (DA) (p463)—Justice and Correctional Services.

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 878 ◙1389.

Mr S J F Marais (DA) (p467)—Defence and Military Veterans.

◙1393.

Ms E R J Spies (DA) (p468)— The Presidency for Women, Youth and Persons with Disabilities.

◙1394.

Ms E R J Spies (DA) (p468)—The Presidency for Women, Youth and Persons with Disabilities.

◙1395.
◙1395.

Ms E R J Spies (DA) (p468)—The Presidency for Women, Youth and Persons with Disabilities.

◙1398.

Ms T Bodlani (DA) (p469)—Communications and Digital Technologies.

FRIDAY, 5 MAY 2023 (REPLY BY 19 MAY 2023) ◙1403.

Ms Z Majozi (IFP) (p 487)—Communications and Digital Technologies.

[209][ Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))] ◙1411.

Dr D T George (DA) (p 488)—Finance.


[217][ Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))] ◙1412.

Dr D T George (DA) (p 488)—Finance.

[218][ Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))] ◙1422.

Ms T Bodlani (DA) (p 490)—Communications and Digital Technologies.
[231][ Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))] ◙1431.

Mr S Tambo (EFF) (p 492)—Communications and Digital Technologies.

[246][ Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))] ◙1443.

Mrs Y N Yako (EFF) (p 495)—Justice and Correctional Services.

◙1444.

Mrs Y N Yako (EFF) (p 495)—Justice and Correctional Services.

◙1448.
◙1448.

Ms N P Sonti (EFF) (p 495)— Minister in The Presidency for Women, Youth and Persons with Disabilities.

◙1471.

Mrs L F Tito (EFF) (p 499)— Minister in The Presidency for Women, Youth and Persons with Disabilities.

◙1478.

Mr N S Matiase (EFF) (p 500)—Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development.

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 879 ◙1483.

Mrs K N F Hlonyana (EFF) (p 501)— Minister in The Presidency for Women, Youth and Persons with Disabilities.
◙1492.

Mr A M Khoza (EFF) (p 502)—Justice and Correctional Services.

◙1493.

Mr V Zungula (ATM) (p 503)—Basic Education.

◙1508.

Ms S J Graham (DA) (p 506)—Public Works and Infrastructure.

◙1511.

Mr N P Masipa (DA) (p 507)—Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development.

◙1517.

Dr M M Gondwe (DA) (p 508)— Minister in The Presidency.

◙1530.

Mr A G Whitfield (DA) (p 511)—Police.

◙1533.

Ms D Kohler (DA) (p 511)—Communications and Digital Technologies.

◙1548.
◙1548.

Ms N K Sharif (DA) (p 514)— Minister in The Presidency for Women, Youth and Persons with Disabilities.

◙1556.

Mr I S Seitlholo (DA) (p 515)—Transport.

◙1560.

Mr W Horn (DA) (p 517)—Justice and Correctional Services.

◙1563.

Mr M L Shelembe (DA) (p 517)—Defence and Military Veterans.

◙1564.

Mrs M B Hicklin (DA) (p 517)—Public Works and Infrastructure.

◙1565.

Mrs M B Hicklin (DA) (p 517)—Public Works and Infrastructure.

◙1566.

Mrs M B Hicklin (DA) (p 518)—Public Works and Infrastructure.
◙1568.
Mr M Hlengwa (IFP) to ask the Minister of Justice and Correctional Services: [Interdepartmentally transferred from International Relations and Cooperation with effect Monday, 8 May 2023] Whether the Government intends to execute the warrant of arrest against the President of the Russian Federation, Mr Vladimir Putin, as issued by the International Criminal Court, given that the Republic is a signatory to the Rome Statute; if not, what is the position in this regard; if so, what are the relevant details?
NW1811E ◙1571.

Mr H A Shembeni (EFF) (p 519)—Police.

◙1574.

Mrs L F Tito (EFF) (p 520)— Minister in The Presidency for Women, Youth and Persons with Disabilities.

◙1577.

Mr S Tambo (EFF) (p 520)—Finance.

◙1580.

Ms L H Arries (EFF) (p 520)—Social Development.

◙1584.

Mr A M Khoza (EFF) (p 521)—Justice and Correctional Services.

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 880 ◙1585.

Ms C N Mkhonto (EFF) (p 521)—Transport.

◙1590.


Mrs N J Nolutshungu (EFF) (p 522)—Transport.

FRIDAY, 12 MAY 2023 (REPLY BY 26 MAY 2023) ◙1598.

Ms P Madokwe (EFF) (p 538)— Minister in The Presidency for Women, Youth and Persons with Disabilities.

◙1601.

Mr T Mogale (EFF) (p 538)— Justice and Correctional Services.

◙1602.

Mr V Zungula (ATM) (p 539)— Finance.

◙1607.

Ms L L van der Merwe (IFP) (p 540)— Social Development.

◙1609.

Ms N N Chirwa (EFF) (p 541)— Health.

◙1611.


Ms N N Chirwa (EFF) (p 541)—Health.

◙1615.

Mrs Y N Yako (EFF) (p 542)— Justice and Correctional Services.

◙1616.

Mrs Y N Yako (EFF) (p 542)— Public Works and Infrastructure.

◙1617.

Mrs Y N Yako (EFF) (p 542)— Justice and Correctional Services.

◙1618.

Mrs M R Mohlala (EFF) (p 542)— Water and Sanitation.

◙1621.

Ms C N Mkhonto (EFF) (p 542)—Transport.

◙1622.

Mr A V Khoza (EFF) (p 543)— Transport.

◙1625.


Dr P J Groenewald (FF Plus) (p 543)— Police.† ◙1627.

Dr P J Groenewald (FF Plus) (p 544)— Defence and Military Veterans.† ◙1628.

Mr B N Herron (Good) (p 545)—Justice and Correctional Services.

◙1635.

Dr M M Gondwe (DA) (p 547)— Public Service and Administration.

◙1636.

Dr M M Gondwe (DA) (p 547)—Public Service and Administration.

◙1639.

Ms H Ismail (DA) (p 548)—Police.

◙1644.

Mrs C Phillips (DA) (p 550)—Public Works and Infrastructure.

◙1645.
◙1645.

Mrs C Phillips (DA) (p 550)—Public Works and Infrastructure.

◙1646.

Mrs C Phillips (DA) (p 551)—Public Works and Infrastructure.

◙1647.

Mr M L Shelembe (DA) (p 551)—Defence and Military Veterans.

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 881 ◙1649.

Mr I S Seitlholo (DA) (p 551)— Public Works and Infrastructure.

◙1654.

Mr L Mphithi (DA) (p 553)—Human Settlements.

◙1655.

Mr L Mphithi (DA) (p 553)—Human Settlements.

◙1658.
◙1658.

Ms S J Graham (DA) (p 553)—Public Works and Infrastructure.

◙1659.

Ms S J Graham (DA) (p 554)— Public Works and Infrastructure.

◙1660.

Ms S J Graham (DA) (p 554)— Public Works and Infrastructure.

◙1661.

Dr L A Schreiber (DA) (p 554)— Public Works and Infrastructure.

◙1662.

Adv G Breytenbach (DA) (p 555)—Justice and Correctional Services.

◙1668.

Mr W Horn (DA) (p 556)—Justice and Correctional Services.

◙1674.

Mr A G Whitfield (DA) (p 557)—Public Works and Infrastructure.

◙1681.
◙1681.

Mr S J F Marais (DA) (p 560)—Defence and Military Veterans.

◙1687.

Mr H C C Krüger (DA) (p 561)—Minister in The Presidency.

◙1688.

Mr M Bagraim (DA) (p 562)—Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development.

◙1690.

Mr M Bagraim (DA) (p 562)— Communications and Digital Technologies.

◙1692.

Mr M Chetty (DA) (p 562)— Defence and Military Veterans.

◙1694.

Mr J N de Villiers (DA) (p 563)— Finance.

◙1699.

Mr J Engelbrecht (DA) (p 564)— Human Settlements.

◙1700.
◙1700.

Mr W F Faber (DA) (p 564)— International Relations and Cooperation.

◙1704.

Mr G R Krumbock (DA) (p 565)—Public Enterprises.

◙1705.

Mr G R Krumbock (DA) (p 565)—Public Service and Administration.

◙1707.

Ms K L Khakhau (DA) (p 565)—Social Development.

◙1712.

Mrs W R Alexander (DA) (p 566)—Transport.

◙1713.

Mrs W R Alexander (DA) (p 567)—Minister in The Presidency for Women, Youth and Persons with Disabilities.

◙1714.

Mrs W R Alexander (DA) (p 567)— Water and Sanitation.

◙1719.
◙1719.

Mr M Hlengwa (IFP) (p 568)— International Relations and Cooperation.

◙1725.

Ms Z Majozi (IFP) (p 569)— Communications and Digital Technologies.

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 882 ◙1730.

Ms S A Buthelezi (IFP) (p 570)— Human Settlements.

◙1732.

Prof C T Msimang (IFP) (p 570)—Justice and Correctional Services.

◙1735.

Mr S S Zondo (IFP) (p 571)— Public Works and Infrastructure.

◙1736.

Mr S S Zondo (IFP) (p 571)—Human Settlements.

◙1749.
◙1749.

Mr K Ceza (EFF) (p 573)—Finance.

◙1760.

Mr M K Montwedi (EFF) (p 575)— Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development.

◙1767.

Ms L H Arries (EFF) (p 576)—Social Development.

◙1773.

Mr A V Khoza (EFF) (p 577)— Defence and Military Veterans.

◙1774.

Mr A V Khoza (EFF) (p 577)—Defence and Military Veterans.

◙1778.

Mrs N J Nolutshungu (EFF) (p 578)— Public Works and Infrastructure.

◙1784.
◙1784.

Mr W T I Mafanya (EFF) (p 579)— Minister in The Presidency for Women, Youth and Persons with Disabilities.

◙1790.

Mr H A Shembeni (EFF) (p 580)— Justice and Correctional Services.

◙1791.

Mr W Horn (DA) (p 580)— Justice and Correctional Services.

FRIDAY, 19 MAY 2023 (REPLY BY 2 JUNE 2023) ◙1795.

Mr P Madokwe (EFF) (p 602)—Police.

◙1796.

Ms L L van der Merwe (IFP) (p 603)—Minister in The Presidency for Women, Youth and Persons with Disabilities.

◙1798.
◙1798.

Ms L L van der Merwe (IFP) (p 603)— Home Affairs.

◙1804.

Ms A M Siwisa (EFF) (p 604)— Higher Education, Science and Innovation.

◙1805.

Ms A M Siwisa (EFF) (p 604)— Justice and Correctional Services.

◙1807.

Mr P Madokwe (EFF) (p 605)— Justice and Correctional Services.

◙1811.

Mr S J F Marais (DA) (p 605)— Defence and Military Veterans.

◙1812.

Mr M S F de Freitas (DA) (p 606)— Home Affairs.

◙1813.

Ms M E Sukers (ACDP) (p 606)— Social Development.

◙1814.
◙1814.

Dr P J Groenewald (FF Plus) (p 606)— Justice and Correctional Services.† ◙1815.

Dr P J Groenewald (FF Plus) (p 606)— Public Enterprises.† INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 883 ◙1816.

Dr P J Groenewald (FF Plus) (p 607)— Defence and Military Veterans.† ◙1819.

Mr P A van Staden (FF Plus) (p 608)— Public Works and Infrastructure.

◙1822.

Mr N P Masipa (DA) (p 608)— Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development.

◙1823.
◙1823.

Mr N P Masipa (DA) (p 609)— Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development.

◙1824.

Mr N P Masipa (DA) (p 609)— Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development.

◙1828.

Dr M M Gondwe (DA) (p 610)— Public Service and Administration.

◙1829.

Dr M M Gondwe (DA) (p 610)— Public Service and Administration.

◙1830.

Mrs C Phillips (DA) (p 610)— Public Works and Infrastructure.

◙1834.

Mrs N W A Mazzone (DA) (p 612)— Communications and Digital Technologies.

◙1835.
◙1835.

Ms T Bodlani (DA) (p 612)— Communications and Digital Technologies.

◙1836.

Ms T Bodlani (DA) (p 612)— Communications and Digital Technologies.

◙1837.

Ms T Bodlani (DA) (p 612)— Communications and Digital Technologies.

◙1838.

Mr I S Seitlholo (DA) (p 612)— Public Works and Infrastructure.

◙1839.

Mr I S Seitlholo (DA) (p 613)— Public Works and Infrastructure.

◙1840.

Ms A L A Abrahams (DA) (p 613)— Social Development.

◙1846.

Mr J Engelbrecht (DA) (p 614)— Justice and Correctional Services.
◙1847.

Mr J Engelbrecht (DA) (p 615)— Justice and Correctional Services.

◙1851.

Mr L Mphithi (DA) (p 615)— Human Settlements.

◙1858.

Mr W Horn (DA) (p 618)— Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs.

◙1862.

Mr D Bergman (DA) (p 618)— Trade, Industry and Competition.

◙1863.

Mr D Bergman (DA) (p 619)— Trade, Industry and Competition.

◙1874.

Mr S L Ngcobo (IFP) (p 621)— Public Service and Administration.

◙1875.

Ms M D Hlengwa (IFP) (p 621)— Communications and Digital Technologies.

◙1876.
◙1876.

Inkosi B N Luthuli (IFP) (p 621)— Police.

◙1878.

Ms S A Buthelezi (IFP) (p 622)— Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs.

◙1879.

Ms S A Buthelezi (IFP) (p 622)— Human Settlements.

◙1880.

Inkosi B N Luthuli (IFP) (p 622)— Small Business Development.

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 884 ◙1881.

Prof C T Msimang (IFP) (p 623)— Justice and Correctional Services.

◙1885.

Ms Z Majozi (IFP) (p 623)— Police.

◙1890.


Inkosi R N Cebekhulu (IFP) (p 624)— Defence and Military Veterans.

◙1891.

Inkosi R N Cebekhulu (IFP) (p 625)— Defence and Military Veterans.

◙1892.

Inkosi R N Cebekhulu (IFP) (p 625)— Defence and Military Veterans.

◙1893.

Mr S S Zondo (IFP) (p 625)— Higher Education, Science and Innovation.

◙1894.

Ms Z Majozi (IFP) (p 625)— Police.

◙1897.

Ms O M C Maotwe (EFF) (p 626)— Public Enterprises.

◙1902.
◙1902.

Mr S Tambo (EFF) (p 626)— Communications and Digital Technologies.

◙1904.

Mr K Ceza (EFF) (p 627)— Water and Sanitation.

◙1907.

Mrs L F Tito (EFF) (p 627)— Transport.

◙1912.

Ms R N Komane (EFF) (p 628)— Public Service and Administration.

◙1917.

Mrs S M Mokgotho (EFF) (p 629)— Human Settlements.

◙1922.

Ms P Marais (EFF) (p 630)— Higher Education, Science and Innovation.

◙1923.

Ms L H Arries (EFF) (p 630)— Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs.

◙1924.
◙1924.

Ms L H Arries (EFF) (p 630)— Social Development.

◙1927.

Ms A M Siwisa (EFF) (p 630)— Public Works and Infrastructure.

◙1928.

Mrs M R Mohlala (EFF) (p 630)— Water and Sanitation.

◙1929.

Mr B S Madlingozi (EFF) (p 631)— Water and Sanitation.

◙1931.

Ms C N Mkhonto (EFF) (p 631)— Employment and Labour.

◙1933.

Ms B Mathulelwa (EFF) (p 631)— Small Business Development.

◙1935.

Mr M N Paulsen (EFF) (p 631)— Transport.

◙1937.

Mr H A Shembeni (EFF) (p 632)— Police.

◙1938.


Ms M Makesini (EFF) (p 632)— Human Settlements.

◙1939.

Mrs C C S Motsepe (EFF) (p 632)— Minister in The Presidency for Women, Youth and Persons with Disabilities.

◙1941.

Mr D F Mthenjane (EFF) (p 632)— Police.

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 885 ◙1942.

Mr D F Mthenjane (EFF) (p 632)— Minister in The Presidency for Electricity.

◙1944.

Mr V Pambo (EFF) (p 633)— Justice and Correctional Services.

◙1945.
◙1945.

Mr V Pambo (EFF) (p 633)— Justice and Correctional Services.

◙1946.

Mrs K N F Hlonyana (EFF) (p 633)— Communications and Digital Technologies.

FRIDAY, 26 MAY 2023 (REPLY BY 9 JUNE 2023) ◙1949.

Ms L L van der Merwe (IFP) (p 657)—Social Development.

◙1955.

Ms P Madokwe (EFF) (p 658)—Mineral Resources and Energy.

◙1957.

Mrs M R Mohlala (EFF) (p 659)—Water and Sanitation.

◙1960.

Mr M S F de Freitas (DA) (p 659)—Home Affairs.

◙1962.
◙1962.

Ms T Breedt (FF Plus) (p 659)—Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development.

◙1963.

Mr B N Herron (Good) (p 660)—Water and Sanitation.

◙1966.

Ms O M C Maotwe (EFF) (p 661)—Public Enterprises.

◙1967.

Ms O M C Maotwe (EFF) (p 661)—Public Enterprises.

◙1968.

Dr M Q Ndlozi (EFF) (p 661)—The Presidency.

◙1969.

Dr M Q Ndlozi (EFF) (p 661)—The Presidency.

◙1970.

Dr M Q Ndlozi (EFF) (p 661)—The Presidency.

◙1971.

Mr S Tambo (EFF) (p 661)—Communications and Digital Technologies.

◙1972.
◙1972.

Mr S Tambo (EFF) (p 662)—Higher Education, Science and Innovation.

◙1973.

Mr S Tambo (EFF) (p 662)—Water and Sanitation.

◙1974.

Ms H O Mkhaliphi (EFF) (p 662)—Finance.

◙1975.

Mrs T P Msane (EFF) (p 662)—Water and Sanitation.

◙1976.

Mrs T P Msane (EFF) (p 662)—Public Works and Infrastructure.

◙1979.

Mr K Ceza (EFF) (p 663)—Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs.

◙1980.

Mrs L F Tito (EFF) (p 663)—Transport.

◙1981.

Mrs L F Tito (EFF) (p 663)—Human Settlements.

◙1984.
◙1984.

Mr T Mogale (EFF) (p 664)—Higher Education, Science and Innovation.

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 886 ◙1985.

Mr T Mogale (EFF) (p 664)—Higher Education, Science and Innovation.

◙1988.

Mr M K Montwedi (EFF) (p 664)—Mineral Resources and Energy.

◙1990.

Mr Y Tetyana (EFF) (p 665)—Water and Sanitation.

◙1991.

Mr Y Tetyana (EFF) (p 665)—Water and Sanitation.

◙1993.

Mr W T I Mafanya (EFF) (p 665)—Defence and Military Veterans.

◙1994.
◙1994.

Ms L H Arries (EFF) (p 665)—Social Development.

◙1995.

Ms L H Arries (EFF) (p 665)—Social Development.

◙1996.

Ms A M Siwisa (EFF) (p 665)—Public Works and Infrastructure.

◙1997.

Ms A M Siwisa (EFF) (p 666)—Public Works and Infrastructure.

◙1998.

Mrs Y N Yako (EFF) (p 666)—Police.

◙2002.

Mrs N J Nolutshungu (EFF) (p 666)—Police.

◙2004.

Ms B Mathulelwa (EFF) (p 667)—Basic Education.

◙2005.

Mr H A Shembeni (EFF) (p 667)—Police.

◙2006.

Mr H A Shembeni (EFF) (p 667)—Police.

◙2007.


Mrs C C S Motsepe (EFF) (p 667)—Public Service and Administration.

◙2011.

Mr N S Matiase (EFF) (p 668)—Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development.

◙2012.

Mr N S Matiase (EFF) (p 668)—Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development.

◙2013.

Mr T Mogale (EFF) (p 668)—Higher Education, Science and Innovation.

◙2014.

Ms M Makesini (EFF) (p 668)—Sport, Arts and Culture.

◙2016.

Ms K N F Hlonyana (EFF) (p 668)—Higher Education, Science and Innovation.
◙2017.

Mr W Horn (DA) (p 668)—President of the Republic.

◙2018.

Mr M S F de Freitas (DA) (p 669)—Home Affairs.

◙2019.

Mr N P Masipa (DA) (p 669)—Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development.

◙2020.

Mr N P Masipa (DA) (p 669)—Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development.

◙2021.

Mr N P Masipa (DA) (p 669)—Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development.

◙2025.

Mrs C Phillips (DA) (p 670)—Water and Sanitation.

◙2027.

Mrs C Phillips (DA) (p 670)—Water and Sanitation.


INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 887 ◙2028.

Mrs V van Dyk (DA) (p 670)—Sport, Arts and Culture.

◙2029.

Mrs V van Dyk (DA) (p 671)—Sport, Arts and Culture.

◙2031.

Ms T Bodlani (DA) (p 671)—Communications and Digital Technologies.

◙2032.

Ms T Bodlani (DA) (p 671)—Communications and Digital Technologies.

◙2033.

Ms T Bodlani (DA) (p 671)—The Presidency.

◙2034.

Dr D T George (DA) (p 672)—Finance.

◙2035.


Mr I S Seitlholo (DA) (p 672)—Public Works and Infrastructure.

◙2036.

Ms A L A Abrahams (DA) (p 672)—Finance.

◙2037.

Ms A L A Abrahams (DA) (p 672)—Social Development.

◙2038.

Ms A L A Abrahams (DA) (p 672)—Social Development.

◙2041.

Ms S J Graham (DA) (p 673)—Public Works and Infrastructure.

◙2042.

Ms S J Graham (DA) (p 673)—Public Works and Infrastructure.

◙2047.

Mr H C C Krüger (DA) (p 674)—Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development.

◙2048.
◙2048.

Mr H C C Krüger (DA) (p 675)—Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development.

◙2049.

Adv G Breytenbach (DA) (p 675)—Justice and Correctional Services.

◙2050.

Mr N G Myburgh (DA) (p 675)—President of the Republic.

◙2051.

Mr N G Myburgh (DA) (p 675)—International Relations and Cooperation.

◙2052.

Mr N G Myburgh (DA) (p 675)—International Relations and Cooperation.

◙2053.

Adv G Breytenbach (DA) (p 675)—Justice and Correctional Services.

◙2054.
◙2054.

Adv G Breytenbach (DA) (p 676)—Justice and Correctional Services.

◙2058.

Mr T W Mhlongo (DA) (p 676)—Sport, Arts and Culture.

◙2059.

Mr T W Mhlongo (DA) (p 677)—Sport, Arts and Culture.

◙2060.

Mr T W Mhlongo (DA) (p 677)—Sport, Arts and Culture.

◙2061.

Mr E J Marais (DA) (p 677)—Public Works and Infrastructure.

◙2064.

Mr J F Smalle (DA) (p 678)—Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs.

◙2065.

Mr G K Y Cachalia (DA) (p 678)—Public Enterprises.

◙2073.
◙2073.

Ms Z Majozi (IFP) (p 679)—Police.

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 888 ◙2077.

Prof C T Msimang (IFP) (p 680)—Mineral Resources and Energy.

◙2078.

Prof C T Msimang (IFP) (p 680)—Justice and Correctional Services.

◙2079.

Prof C T Msimang (IFP) (p 681)—Justice and Correctional Services.

◙2082.

Ms S A Buthelezi (IFP) (p 681)—Human Settlements.

◙2084.

Mr K P Sithole (IFP) (p 682)—Transport.

◙2085.

Ms Z Majozi (IFP) (p 682)—Police.

◙2088.


Mr S L Ngcobo (IFP) (p 683)—Employment and Labour.

◙2089.

Mr S S Zondo (IFP) (p 683)—Public Works and Infrastructure.

◙2090.

Mr S S Zondo (IFP) (p 683)—Higher Education, Science and Innovation.

◙2091.

Inkosi R N Cebekhulu (IFP) (p 683)—Defence and Military Veterans.

◙2092.

Inkosi R N Cebekhulu (IFP) (p 683)—Defence and Military Veterans.

FRIDAY, 2 JUNE 2023 (REPLY BY 19 JUNE 2023) 2095.

Ms P Madokwe (EFF) (p 719)—Mineral Resources and Energy.
2096.

Ms N N Chirwa (EFF) (p 719)—Basic Education.

2097.

Ms N N Chirwa (EFF) (p 719)—Health.

2098.

Ms N N Chirwa (EFF) (p 720)—Health.

2099.

Ms A M Siwisa (EFF) (p 720)—Public Works and Infrastructure.

2100.

Mrs M R Mohlala (EFF) (p 720)—Water and Sanitation.

2101.

Mrs M R Mohlala (EFF) (p 720)—Water and Sanitation.

2102.

Mr M S F de Freitas (DA) (p 721)—Tourism.

2103.

Mr M S F de Freitas (DA) (p 721)—Tourism.

2104.

Ms P Madokwe (EFF) (p 721)—Mineral Resources and Energy.

2105.
2105.

Ms V T Malinga (ANC) (p 721)—Public Enterprises.

[257] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 889 2106.

Mr S H Mbuyane (ANC) (p 722)—Trade, Industry and Competition.

[261] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2107.
2107.

Ms K B Tlhomelang (ANC) (p 722)—Small Business Development.

[262] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2108.

Ms M M Ramadwa (ANC) (p 722)—Transport.

[263] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2109.

Mr A M Shaik Emam (NFP) (p 722)—Public Enterprises.
[264] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2110.

Ms B M van Minnen (DA) (p 722)—Public Enterprises.

[265] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2111.

Ms B M van Minnen (DA) (p 723)—Public Enterprises.

[266] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2113.
2113.

Mr F Essack (DA) (p 723)—Public Enterprises.

[271] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2114.

Mr F Essack (DA) (p 723)—Public Enterprises.

[272] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2115.

Mr G K Y Cachalia (DA) (p 723)—Public Enterprises.


[273] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2116.

Mr H C C Krüger (DA) (p 724)—Small Business Development.

[276] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2117.

Mr J N de Villiers (DA) (p 724)—Small Business Development.
[277] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2118.

Mr J N de Villiers (DA) (p 724)—Small Business Development.

[278] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2119.

Mr M S F de Freitas (DA) (p 724)—Tourism.

[280] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2120.
2120.

Mr M S F de Freitas (DA) (p 724)—Tourism.

[281] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2121.

Mr M Bagraim (DA) (p 725)—Small Business Development.

[282] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 890 2123.

Ms S J Graham (DA) (p 725)—Public Enterprises.


[284] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2124.

Ms S J Graham (DA) (p 725)—Public Enterprises.

[285] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2125.

Mr I S Seitlholo (DA) (p 725)—Public Works and Infrastructure.
[286] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2126.

Mr I S Seitlholo (DA) (p 726)—Public Works and Infrastructure.

[287] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2127.

Mrs W R Alexander (DA) (p 726)—Public Enterprises.

[288] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2128.
2128.

Inkosi B N Luthuli (IFP) (p 726)—Small Business Development.

[289] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2131.

Ms O M C Maotwe (EFF) (p 727)—Public Enterprises.

[295] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2132.

Ms A M Siwisa (EFF) (p 727)—Public Works and Infrastructure.
[297] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2134.

Mrs N J Nolutshungu (EFF) (p 727)—Transport.

[299] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2135.

Mr A Matumba (EFF) (p 727)—Tourism.

[301] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2136.

Mrs E N Ntlangwini (EFF) (p 728)—Electricity.


2137.

Mrs E N Ntlangwini (EFF) (p 728)—Electricity.

2138.

Dr P J Groenewald (FF Plus) (p 728)—Police.† 2140.

Ms S A Buthelezi (IFP) (p 729)—Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs.

2141.

Ms S A Buthelezi (IFP) (p 729)—Water and Sanitation.

2142.

Inkosi B N Luthuli (IFP) (p 729)—Small Business Development.

2143.

Prof C T Msimang (IFP) (p 729)—Mineral Resources and Energy.

2144.

Prof C T Msimang (IFP) (p 729)—Justice and Correctional Services.
2145.

Prof C T Msimang (IFP) (p 730)—Justice and Correctional Services.

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 891 2146.

Ms M D Hlengwa (IFP) (p 730)—Health.

2147.

Ms M D Hlengwa (IFP) (p 730)—Health.

2148.

Ms M D Hlengwa (IFP) (p 730)—Health.

2149.

Mr S S Zondo (IFP) (p 731)—Higher Education, Science and Innovation.

2150.

Mr S S Zondo (IFP) (p 731)—Public Works and Infrastructure.

2151.

Mr S S Zondo (IFP) (p 731)—Public Works and Infrastructure.

2152.
2152.

Mr K P Sithole (IFP) (p 731)—Tourism.

2153.

Mr K P Sithole (IFP) (p 731)—Tourism.

2154.

Mr K P Sithole (IFP) (p 731)—Transport.

2155.

Ms Z Majozi (IFP) (p 732)—Communications and Digital Technologies.

2156.

Ms Z Majozi (IFP) (p 732)—Police.

2158.

Mr S L Ngcobo (IFP) (p 732)—Basic Education.

2160.

Inkosi R N Cebekhulu (IFP) (p 733)—Defence and Military Veterans.

2161.

Ms T Breedt (FF Plus) (p 733)—Public Works and Infrastructure.

2162.
2162.

Ms T Breedt (FF Plus) (p 733)—Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development.

2163.

Ms T Breedt (IFP) (p 733)—Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development.

2164.

Mr B N Herron (Good) (p 734)—Water and Sanitation.

2165.

Mr M Hlengwa (IFP) (p 734)—International Relations and Cooperation.

2166.

Mr M Hlengwa (IFP) (p 734)—International Relations and Cooperation.

2167.

Mr M Hlengwa (IFP) (p 734)—International Relations and Cooperation.

2168.

Mr E M Buthelezi (IFP) (p 735)—Public Enterprises.


2169.

Dr W J Boshoff (FF Plus) (p 735)—Police.

2170.

Mr F J Mulder (FF Plus) (p 735)—Justice and Correctional Services.

2171.

Mr H C C Krüger (DA) (p 735)—Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development.

2172.

Mr M S F de Freitas (DA) (p 735)—Transport.

2173.

Mr N P Masipa (DA) (p 736)—Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development.

2174.

Mr N P Masipa (DA) (p 736)—Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development.
INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 892 2175.

Mr N P Masipa (DA) (p 736)—Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development.

2176.

Ms H Ismail (DA) (p 737)—Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs.

2177.

Ms H Ismail (DA) (p 737)—Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs.

2178.

Mrs V van Dyk (DA) (p 737)—Police.

2179.

Mrs V van Dyk (DA) (p 737)—Police.

2180.

Mrs V van Dyk (DA) (p 737)—Health.

2181.


Ms T Bodlani (DA) (p 738)—Communications and Digital Technologies.

2182.

Mr B B Nodada (DA) (p 738)—Basic Education.

2183.

Mr B B Nodada (DA) (p 738)—Basic Education.

2184.

Mr B B Nodada (DA) (p 738)—Basic Education.

2185.

Mrs M O Clarke (DA) (p 739)—Health.

2186.

Mrs M O Clarke (DA) (p 739)—Health.

2187.

Mrs M O Clarke (DA) (p 739)—Health.

2188.

Mr H C C Krüger (DA) (p 739)—Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development.

2189.
2189.

Mr H C C Krüger (DA) (p 739)—Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development.

2190.

Mr N G Myburgh (DA) (p 739)—Finance.

2191.

Mr N G Myburgh (DA) to ask the Minister in the Presidency: [Interdepartmentally transferred from Finance with effect Tuesday, 6 June 2023] With regard to the figures released by Statistics SA on 16 May 2023, what are the reasons that there is a large gap between the unemployment figures for the Western Cape at 21,6% as opposed to the national figure of 32,9%?
NW2488E 2192.

Mr N G Myburgh (DA) (p 740)—Sport, Arts and Culture.

2194.

Mrs N W A Mazzone (DA) (p 740)—Communications and Digital Technologies.

2195.

Mrs N W A Mazzone (DA) (p 740)—Communications and Digital Technologies.

2196.

Ms A L A Abrahams (DA) (p 741)—Social Development.

2197.

Ms A L A Abrahams (DA) (p 741)—Social Development.

2198.

Ms A L A Abrahams (DA) (p 741)—Social Development.

2200.

Ms S J Graham (DA) (p 742)—Electricity.


INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 893 2201.

Ms S J Graham (DA) (p 742)—Electricity.

2202.

Ms S J Graham (DA) (p 742)—Electricity.

2204.

Ms A M van Zyl (DA) (p 743)—Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs.

2205.

Mrs A M M Weber (DA) (p 743)—Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment.

2206.

Mrs A M M Weber (DA) (p 743)—Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment.

2207.
2207.

Mrs A M M Weber (DA) (p 743)—Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment.

2208.

Mr A G Whitfield (DA) (p 744)—Justice and Correctional Services.

2209.

Ms H S Winkler (DA) (p 744)—Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment.

2210.

Mrs C Phillips (DA) (p 745)—Finance.

2211.

Ms H S Winkler (DA) (p 745)—Forestry, Fisheries and the 2212.

Ms H S Winkler (DA) (p 745)—Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment.

2213.

Mr T W Mhlongo (DA) (p 745)—Sport, Arts and Culture.

2214.
2214.

Mr T W Mhlongo (DA) (p 746)—Sport, Arts and Culture.

2215.

Mr T W Mhlongo (DA) (p 746)—Sport, Arts and Culture.

2216.

Mr M Bagraim (DA) (p 746)—Small Business Development.

2220.

Mr A C Roos (DA) (p 747)—Home Affairs.

2221.

Mr A C Roos (DA) (p 747)—Home Affairs.

2223.

Mr D W Macpherson (DA) (p 748)—President of the Republic.

2224.

Ms O M C Maotwe (EFF) (p 748)—Public Enterprises.

2225.

Ms O M C Maotwe (EFF) (p 748)—Public Enterprises.

2226.

Mr V Pambo (EFF) (p 748)—Police.

2227.


Mr S Tambo (EFF) (p 748)—Communications and Digital Technologies.

2228.

Mr S Tambo (EFF) (p 749)—International Relations and Cooperation.

2229.

Mrs T P Msane (EFF) (p 749)—Justice and Correctional Services.

2230.

Ms P Marais (EFF) (p 749)—Water and Sanitation.

2231.

Ms P Marais (EFF) (p 749)—Water and Sanitation.

2232.

Mr K Ceza (EFF) (p 749)—Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs.
INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 894 2233.

Mr K Ceza (EFF) (p 749)—Human Settlements.

2234.

Mrs L F Tito (EFF) (p 749)—Justice and Correctional Services.

2235.

Mr A Matumba (EFF) (p 750)—Tourism.

2236.

Mr A Matumba (EFF) (p 750)—Tourism.

2237.

Mrs T P Msane (EFF) (p 750)—Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs.

2238.

Mr M K Montwedi (EFF) (p 750)—Home Affairs.

2239.

Mr M K Montwedi (EFF) (p 750)—Public Works and Infrastructure.

2240.
2240.

Mr B S Madlingozi (EFF) (p 751)—Sport, Arts and Culture.

2241.

Ms L H Arries (EFF) (p 751)—Police.

2242.

Ms L H Arries (EFF) to ask the Minister of Basic Education: [Interdepartmentally transferred from Social Development with effect Monday 19 June 2023] What measures has she put in place to audit, monitor and evaluate services of early childhood development centres in the Republic to ensure that they operate according to set standards?

NW2544E 2244.

Dr S S Thembekwayo (EFF) (p 751)—Health.


2245.

Ms A M Siwisa (EFF) (p 751)—Public Works and Infrastructure.

2246.

Ms A M Siwisa (EFF) (p 751)—Public Works and Infrastructure.

2247.

Mrs M R Mohlala (EFF) (p 752)—Water and Sanitation.

2249.

Mr M N Paulsen (EFF) (p 752)—Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment.

2250.

Mr M N Paulsen (EFF) (p 752)—Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment.

2251.

Mr M N Paulsen (EFF) (p 752)—Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment.

2252.
2252.

Mr N S Matiase (EFF) (p 752)—Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development.

2253.

Mr V Pambo (EFF) (p 752)—Transport.

2254.

Mr V Pambo (EFF) (p 753)—Water and Sanitation.

2255.

Mr A Matumba (EFF) (p 753)—Health.

2256.

Dr S S Thembekwayo (EFF) (p 753)—Health.

2257.

Mrs K N F Hlonyana (EFF) (p 753)—Water and Sanitation.

FRIDAY, 9 JUNE 2023 INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 895 (REPLY BY 26 JUNE 2023) 2259.
Ms P Madokwe (EFF) (p 792)— Higher Education, Science and Innovation.

2260.

Ms N N Chirwa (EFF) (p 792)— Health.

2261.

Ms N N Chirwa (EFF) (p 792)— Health.

2262.

Ms N N Chirwa (EFF) (p 792)—Higher Education, Science and Innovation.

2263.

Ms A M Siwisa (EFF) (p 792)— Communications and Digital Technologies.

2264.

Mrs M R Mohlala (EFF) (p 793)— Water and Sanitation.

2265.

Mrs M R Mohlala (EFF) (p 793)—Water and Sanitation.

2266.

Mr B N Herron (Good) (p 793)—Mineral Resources and Energy.

2267.
2267.

Ms A L A Abrahams (DA) (p 793)—Social Development.

2268.

Rev K R J Meshoe (ACDP) (p 794)— Police.

[304] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2269.

Prof C T Msimang (IFP) (p 794)— Justice and Correctional Services.

[305] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2270.

Prof C T Msimang (IFP) (p 794)— Justice and Correctional Services.
[306] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2271.

Inkosi R N Cebekhulu (IFP) (p 794)— Defence and Military Veterans.

[308] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8).

2272.

Ms L L van der Merwe (IFP) (p 795)— Home Affairs.

[309] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2273.
2273.

Ms L L van der Merwe (IFP) (p 795)— Home Affairs.

[310] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2274.

Mr A C Roos (DA) (p 795)—Home Affairs.

[312] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2275.

Mr A G Whitfield (DA) (p 795)— Police.


[313] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2276.

Mr A G Whitfield (DA) (p 795)—Police.

[314] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2277.

Ms D Kohler (DA) (p 796)—Defence and Military Veterans.
[316] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 896 2278.

Adv G Breytenbach (DA) (p 796)— Justice and Correctional Services.

[318] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))] 2279.

Adv G Breytenbach (DA) (p 796)— Justice and Correctional Services.
[319] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2280.

Ms H Ismail (DA) (p 796)— Home Affairs.

[320] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2281.

Ms H Ismail (DA) (p 796)— Home Affairs.

[321] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2282.
2282.

Mr J Engelbrecht (DA) (p 797)—Justice and Correctional Services.

[322] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2283.

Mr J Engelbrecht (DA) (p 797)—Justice and Correctional Services.

[323] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2284.

Mr S J F Marais (DA) (p 797)—Defence and Military Veterans.
[324] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2285.

Mr S J F Marais (DA) (p 797)— Defence and Military Veterans.

[325] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2286.

Mr M L Shelembe (DA) (p 797)— Defence and Military Veterans.

[326] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2287.
2287.

Mr M L Shelembe (DA) (p 798)— Defence and Military Veterans.

[327] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2288.

M. Gen O S Terblanche (DA) (p 798)— Police.

[329] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2289.

M. Gen O S Terblanche (DA) (p 798)—Police.


[330] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2290.

Mr W Horn (DA) (p 798)— Justice and Correctional Services.

[331] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2291.

Ms S Patrein (ANC) (p 799)— Police.


[335] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2292.

Ms M A Molekwa (ANC) (p 799)— Police.

[336] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 897 2293.

Mr A M Seabi (ANC) (p 799)— Police.


[337] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2294.

Ms G P Marekwa (ANC) (p 799)— Police.

[339] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2295.

Ms A Ramolobeng (ANC) (p 799)— Justice and Correctional Services.
[341] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2296.

Ms N H Maseko-Jele (ANC) (p 800)—Justice and Correctional Services.

[343] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2297.

Mr X Nqola (ANC) (p 800)—Justice and Correctional Services.

[344] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2298.
2298.

Mr T N Mmutle (ANC) (p 800)— Defence and Military Veterans.

[345] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2299.

Ms P A Phetlhe (ANC) (p 800)—Defence and Military Veterans.

[346] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2300.

Ms T I Legwase (ANC) (p 800)— Defence and Military Veterans.
[347] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2301.

Ms A J Beukes (ANC) (p 801)— Defence and Military Veterans.

[349] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2302.

Ms A H Mthembu (ANC) (p 801)— Defence and Military Veterans.

[350] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2303.
2303.

Mr X Nqola (ANC) (p 801)—International Relations and Cooperation.

2304.

Mr M Hlengwa (IFP) (p 801)—International Relations and Cooperation.

[356] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2305.

Mr B N Herron (Good) (p 801)—Police.

[357] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2306.

Mr A M Shaik Emam (NFP) (p 802)— Justice and Correctional Services.
2307.

Mr A V Khoza (EFF) (p 802)— Police.

[359] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2308.

Mr P A van Staden (FF Plus) (p 802)— Health.

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 898 2309.

Mr Y Tetyana (EFF) (p 802)— Home Affairs.

[361] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2310.
2310.

Ms T Breedt (FF Plus) (p 802)— Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment.

2311.

Mrs Y N Yako (EFF) (p 803)— Justice and Correctional Services.

[363] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2312.

Mrs T P Msane (EFF) (p 803)— International Relations and Cooperation.

[364] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2313.
2313.

Mrs T P Msane (EFF) (p 803)—International Relations and Cooperation.

[365] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2314.

Mr W T I Mafanya (EFF) (p 803)— Defence and Military Veterans.

[366] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2315.

Mr W T I Mafanya (EFF) (p 803)— Defence and Military Veterans.
[367] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2316.

Mrs L F Tito (EFF) (p 804)— Home Affairs.

[368] [Question submitted for oral reply now placed for written reply because it is in excess of quota (Rule 137(8))].

2317.

Ms L L van der Merwe (IFP) (p 804)— Social Development.

2318.

Ms L L van der Merwe (IFP) (p 804)— Home Affairs.

2319.

Mr N Singh (IFP) (p 804)—Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment.

2320.
2320.

Ms Z Majozi (IFP) (p 804)— Police.

2321.

Mr S S Zondo (IFP) (p 804)— Higher Education, Science and Innovation.

2322.

Mr S S Zondo (IFP) (p 805)—Public Works and Infrastructure.

2323.

Ms M D Hlengwa (IFP) (p 805)—Health.

2324.

Ms M D Hlengwa (IFP) (p 805)— Health.

2325.

Prof C T Msimang (IFP) (p 805)—Mineral Resources and Energy.

2326.

Inkosi B N Luthuli (IFP) (p 805)— Sport, Arts and Culture.

2327.

Ms S A Buthelezi (IFP) (p 805)—Water and Sanitation.

2328.
2328.

Mr K P Sithole (IFP) (p 806)— to ask the Minister of Tourism.

2329.

Mr K P Sithole (IFP) (p 806)— Transport.

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 899 2330.

Ms Z Majozi (IFP) (p 806)—Police.

2331.

Ms Z Majozi (IFP) (p 806)—Police.

2332.

Mr S L Ngcobo (IFP) (p 806)— Basic Education.

2333.

Mr S L Ngcobo (IFP) (p 806)— Basic Education.

2334.

Mr E M Buthelezi (IFP) (p 806)— Finance.

2335.

Mr E M Buthelezi (IFP) (p 807)—Public Enterprises.

2336.
2336.

Inkosi R N Cebekhulu (IFP) (p 807)— Defence and Military Veterans.

2337.

Mr B B Nodada (DA) (p 807)— Basic Education.

2338.

Mr B B Nodada (DA) (p 807)—Basic Education.

2339.

Mr B B Nodada (DA) (p 807)— Basic Education.

2340.

Ms H Ismail (DA) (p 807)— Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment.

2341.

Ms H Ismail (DA) (p 808)— Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment.

2342.

Ms H Ismail (DA) (p 808)—Tourism.

2343.

Mr M S F de Freitas (DA) (p 808)— Transport.

2344.
2344.

Mr M S F de Freitas (DA) (p 808)— Transport.

2345.

Mr M S F de Freitas (DA) (p 808)—to ask the Minister of Transport.

2346.

Mr N P Masipa (DA) (p 809)—Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development.

2347.

Mr N P Masipa (DA) (p 809)—Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development.

2348.

Mr N P Masipa (DA) (p 809)— Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development.

2349.

Mrs M O Clarke (DA) (p 809)— Health.

2350.

Mrs M O Clarke (DA) (p 810)—Health.

2351.

Mrs M O Clarke (DA) (p 810)— Health.


2352.

Mr N G Myburgh (DA) (p 810)—Sport, Arts and Culture.

2353.

Mr N G Myburgh (DA) (p 810)—Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development.

2354.

Mr N G Myburgh (DA) (p 810)—Water and Sanitation.

2355.

Mr D W Bryant (DA) (p 810)—Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment.

2356.

Mr D W Bryant (DA) (p 810)— Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment.

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 900 2357.
Mr D W Bryant (DA) (p 811)— Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment.

2358.

Ms E R J Spies (DA) (p 811)—Finance.

2359.

Ms A M van Zyl (DA) (p 811)— Justice and Correctional Services.

2360.

Ms A M van Zyl (DA) (p 811)— Basic Education.

2361.

Ms A M van Zyl (DA) (p 812)— Basic Education.

2362.

Ms B S Masango (DA) (p 812)— Social Development.

2363.

Ms B S Masango (DA) (p 812)— Social Development.

2364.

Adv G Breytenbach (DA) (p 812)—Justice and Correctional Services.

2365.
2365.

Ms A M M Weber (DA) (p 812)— Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment.

2366.

Ms A M M Weber (DA) (p 813)— Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment.

2367.

Ms A M M Weber (DA) (p 813)—Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment.

2368.

Ms A L A Abrahams (DA) (p 813)—Social Development.

2369.

Ms A L A Abrahams (DA) (p 814)—Finance.

2370.

Ms B S Masango (DA) (p 814)— Social Development.

2371.

Ms S J Graham (DA) (p 814)—Electricity.

2372.

Ms S J Graham (DA) (p 814)—Minister in The Presidency.
2373.

Ms S J Graham (DA) (p 815)— Minister in The Presidency.

2374.

Ms H S Winkler (DA) (p 815)— Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment.

2375.

Mr T W Mhlongo (DA) (p 815)—Sport, Arts and Culture.

2376.

Mr T W Mhlongo (DA) (p 815)—Sport, Arts and Culture.

2377.

Mr T W Mhlongo (DA) (p 815)—Sport, Arts and Culture.

2378.

Mr J F Smalle (DA) (p 816)—Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs.

2379.

Mr J F Smalle (DA) (p 816)—Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs.

2380.
2380.

Ms H S Winkler (DA) (p 816)— Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment.

2381.

Ms H S Winkler (DA) (p 816)—Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment.

2382.

Ms D Kohler (DA) (p 817)—Defence and Military Veterans.

2383.

Mr A C Roos (DA) (p 817)— Police.

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 901 2384.

Mr A C Roos (DA) (p 817)—Home Affairs.

2385.

Mr W Horn (DA) (p 817)—Justice and Correctional Services.

2386.
2386.

Mr W Horn (DA) (p 817)—Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs.

2387.

Mr F Essack (DA) (p 818)—Public Enterprises.

2388.

Ms D Kohler (DA) (p 818)—Minister in The Presidency.

2389.

Adv G Breytenbach (DA) (p 818)—Justice and Correctional Services.

2390.

Ms C V King (DA) (p 818) Higher Education, Science and Innovation.

2391.

Ms C V King (DA) (p 818)— Justice and Correctional Services.

2392.

Ms C V King (DA) (p 819)—Home Affairs.

2393.


Mr G K Y Cachalia (DA) (p 819)—Public Enterprises.

2394.

Mr G K Y Cachalia (DA) (p 819)—Public Enterprises.

2395.

Mr G K Y Cachalia (DA) (p 819)—Public Enterprises.

2396.

Mrs V van Dyk (DA) (p 819)—Mineral Resources and Energy.

2397.

Mrs V van Dyk (DA) (p 819)—Mineral Resources and Energy.

2398.

Mrs V van Dyk (DA) (p 819)—Mineral Resources and Energy.

2399.

Mr D Joseph (DA) (p 820)—Basic Education.

2400.


Mrs T P Msane (EFF) (p 820)—International Relations and Cooperation.

2401.

Mr K Ceza (EFF) (p 820)—Water and Sanitation.

2402.

Mr K Ceza (EFF) (p 820)— Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs.

2403.

Mrs L F Tito (EFF) (p 820)—to ask the Minister of Health.

2404.

Mr A Matumba (EFF) (p 821)—to ask the Minister of Tourism.

2405.

Ms R N Komane (EFF) (p 821)—Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs.

2406.
2406.

Ms R N Komane (EFF) (p 821)—Transport.

2407.

Mr M K Montwedi (EFF) (p 821)—Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development.

2408.

Ms P Madokwe (EFF) (p 821)—Mineral Resources and Energy.

2409.

Ms P Madokwe (EFF) (p 821)—Mineral Resources and Energy.

2410.

Ms A M Siwisa (EFF) (p 821)—Public Works and Infrastructure.

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023 Thursday, 15 June 2023 902 2411.

Ms A M Siwisa (EFF) (p 822)— Public Works and Infrastructure.

2412.
2412.

Mrs M R Mohlala (EFF) (p 822)— Water and Sanitation.

2413.

Ms C N Mkhonto (EFF) (p 822)— Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development.

2414.

Mrs N J Nolutshungu (EFF) (p 822)— Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment.

2415.

Ms M Makesini (EFF) (p 822)—Human Settlements.

2416.

Ms M Makesini (EFF) (p 822)—Human Settlements.

2417.

Ms M Makesini (EFF) (p 823)— Human Settlements.

2418.

Mr W T I Mafanya (EFF) (p 823)—Defence and Military Veterans.

2419.
2419.

Mr N S Matiase (EFF) (p 823)—Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development.

2420.

Mr P A van Staden (FF Plus) (p 823)— Health.

2421.

Mr P A van Staden (FF Plus) (p 823)—Health.

2422.

Ms T Breedt (IFP) (p 823)—Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment.

2423.

Ms T Breedt (FF Plus) (p 824)—Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment.

2424.

Mr M Hlengwa (IFP) (p 824)—International Relations and Cooperation.

2425.

Mr M Hlengwa (IFP) (p 824)—International Relations and Cooperation.

2426.
2426.

Mr M Hlengwa (IFP) (p 825)—International Relations and Cooperation.

2427.

Ms L L van der Merwe (IFP) (p 825)—Social Development.

INTERNAL QUESTION PAPER: NATIONAL ASSEMBLY NO 24 - 2023