Source document: https://docs-lawep.s3.us-east-2.amazonaws.com/1697804331754.pdf (Ireland)
Bille an Bhainc Ceannais (Morgáistí Ráta Athraithigh), 2016 Central Bank (Variable Rate Mortgages) Bill 2016 Mar a tionscnaíodh As initiated [No.

24 of 2016] BILLE AN BHAINC CEANNAIS (MORGÁISTÍ RÁTA ATHRAITHIGH), 2016 CENTRAL BANK (VARIABLE RATE MORTGAGES) BILL 2016 Mar a tionscnaíodh As initiated CONTENTS Section 1.

Definitions 2.

Section 2 Assessments 3.

Factors to which Central Bank shall have regard 4.

Formation of conclusion 5.

Power to issue direction to lender 6.

Enforcement Orders 7.


Prohibition on discrimination against existing customers 8.

Rectification Orders and Compensation Orders 9.

Defrayal of legal costs or stamp duty not to constitute discrimination 10.

Publication of Section 2 Assessments 11.

No appeal from decision of Central Bank 12.

Short title and commencement [No.

24 of 2016] ACT REFERRED TO Central Bank Act 1942 (No.
22) 2 BILLE AN BHAINC CEANNAIS (MORGÁISTÍ RÁTA ATHRAITHIGH), 2016 CENTRAL BANK (VARIABLE RATE MORTGAGES) BILL 2016 Bill entitled An Act to provide for measures to address market failures in the market for principal dwelling house mortgage loans, and to provide for related matters.

5 Be it enacted by the Oireachtas as follows: Definitions 1.
In this Act— “Central Bank” means the Central Bank of Ireland; 10 “Compensation Order” shall have the meaning ascribed to it by section 8(3); “Enforcement Order” shall be interpreted with regard to section 6; “lender” shall include any regulated financial service provider within the meaning of the Central Bank Act 1942 or any company, partnership, business or other entity engaged in the provision, management or administration of principal dwelling house mortgage loans; 15 “principal dwelling house mortgage loan” shall mean a loan for the primary purpose of purchasing a principal dwelling home for the borrower (and if relevant the family of the borrower) on an owner-occupier business; “Rectification Order” shall have the meaning ascribed to it by section 8(1); “Section 2 Assessment” shall mean an assessment carried out pursuant to section 2; 20 “variable interest rate” shall— (a) include any interest rate which is transient or otherwise not fixed and which is not set or calculated by reference to an interest rate set or otherwise determined by the European Central Bank, (b) in relation to a lender, include a reference to different variable interest rates being charged by a lender in respect of different principal dwelling house mortgage loans or categories of principal dwelling house mortgage loans.
25 Section 2 Assessments 2.

The Central Bank shall carry out assessments on the state of competition in the market for principal dwelling house mortgage loans on at least a quarterly basis.

30 3 Factors to which Central Bank shall have regard 3.
In carrying out a Section 2 Assessment, the Central Bank shall have regard to the following factors: (a) the variable interest rates being charged by lenders; (b) the ease with which borrowers can switch their principal dwelling house mortgage loans between lenders or between products offered by the same lender; 5 (c) the extent to which borrowers are switching their principal dwelling house mortgage loans between lenders or between products offered by the same lender; (d) the relationship and proportionality between the variable interest rates being charged by each lender and the cost of funds of that lender; (e) the trend in variable interest rates being charged in the principal dwelling house mortgage loan market over time; (f) lenders’ cost of funds and the trend in lenders’ cost of funds over time; (g) lenders’ weighted average cost of capital and the trend in lenders’ weighted average costs of capital over time; (h) the risk profiles of individual lenders in respect of variable interest rate principal dwelling house mortgage loans; (i) lenders’ reasonable profit expectations in the prevailing market conditions; (j) the proportion of the principal dwelling house mortgage loan market accounted for by each lender; and (k) such other matters as the Governor of the Central Bank may certify as being of relevance.
Formation of conclusion 4.

(1) Upon completion of a Section 2 Assessment, the Central Bank shall form a conclusion as to whether the state of competition in the market for principal dwelling house mortgage loans is such that a market failure exists.
(2) For the purposes of this Act, “market failure” shall mean a situation in which market conditions are such that a lender is, or lenders are, charging a variable interest rate or variable interest rates for principal dwelling house mortgage loans which are higher than the Central Bank considers can be reasonably and objectively justified by reference to the factors set out in section 3.

Power to issue direction to lender 5.
Where the Central Bank forms a conclusion pursuant to section 4 that a market failure exists, the Central Bank may issue a direction to a specific lender or lenders (or lenders in general) not to charge a variable interest rate or variable interest rates in respect of principal dwelling house mortgage loans generally, or specific principal dwelling house mortgage loans or categories of principal dwelling house mortgage loans, which exceeds— (a) a rate or rates specified by the Central Bank, 4 10 15 20 25 30 35 (b) a margin or margins specified by the Central Bank above that lender’s cost of funds (as determined by the Central Bank), (c) a margin or margins specified by the Central Bank above a rate set by the European Central Bank nominated by the Central Bank, and/or (d) a proportion, being not more than one-third, specified by the Central Bank above the average variable interest rate charged in the market for comparable principal dwelling house mortgage loans as determined by the Central Bank.
5 Enforcement Orders 6.

(1) A direction pursuant to section 5 shall state the duration for which the direction shall remain in force, which may be an indefinite period, but such a direction may subsequently be extended, varied or brought to an end by the Central Bank at any time.
(2) A lender shall comply with a direction pursuant to section 5 (or any variation of such a direction) within 56 days from the date of the direction (or variation as the case may be) and shall thereafter continue to comply with the direction until such time, if any, that it is varied or brought to an end by the Central Bank.
(3) Where the Central Bank believes that a lender is in breach of subsection (2), it may apply to the High Court on notice to the lender in question for an Enforcement Order requiring the lender in question to comply with the direction in question.

(4) Upon hearing an application pursuant to subsection (3), the High Court shall grant an Enforcement Order if it determines that the lender in question is in breach of the relevant direction.
(5) Where the High Court makes an Enforcement Order in accordance with this section, it shall impose a fine on the lender in question in the sum of twice the amount that the court determines the lender derived in profits in breach of the relevant direction, unless the court determines that it would be unjust to impose such a fine, in which case it may impose a lesser fine or dispense with the requirement to impose a fine.

10 15 20 25 Prohibition on discrimination against existing customers 7.
In setting a variable interest rate for a group, class or category of principal dwelling house mortgage loans, a lender may not discriminate between existing borrowers and new borrowers.

30 Rectification Orders and Compensation Orders 8.


(1) Where the Central Bank believes that a lender is in breach of its obligations pursuant to section 7, the Central Bank may apply to the High Court on notice to the lender in question for a Rectification Order requiring the lender in question to cease the relevant discriminatory practice prohibited by section 7.
35 (2) Upon hearing an application pursuant to subsection (1), the High Court shall grant a Rectification Order in such terms as the court deems appropriate if it determines that the lender in question has acted in breach of section 7.
(3) Where the High Court makes a Rectification Order in accordance with this section, it 40 5 shall make a Compensation Order in such terms as the court considers appropriate requiring the lender to compensate any borrower or former borrower (or class of borrowers or former borrowers) of the lender affected by the discriminatory practice in question unless the court believes it would be unjust to do so.
(4) Where the High Court makes a Rectification Order in accordance with this section, it shall impose a fine on the lender in question in the sum of twice the amount that the court determines the lender derived in profits on foot of the discriminatory practice in question, unless the court determines that it would be unjust to impose such a fine, in which case it may impose a lesser fine or dispense with the requirement to impose a fine.
Defrayal of legal costs or stamp duty not to constitute discrimination 9.
A lender shall not be regarded as discriminating between existing borrowers and new borrowers for the purposes of section 7 as a consequence of providing new borrowers with a once-off payment or discount for the purpose of defraying on a bona fide and vouched basis— (a) the borrowers’ legal costs in taking out the loans in question or switching between loan products, and/or (b) the borrowers’ liability for stamp duty in the purchase of the principal dwelling house in question.
Publication of Section 2 Assessments 10.

The Central Bank shall publish each Section 2 Assessment publicly in such a manner as it considers appropriate.

No appeal from decision of Central Bank 11.


Notwithstanding the provisions of the Central Bank Act 1942 or any other enactment, no appeal shall lie to the Irish Financial Services Appeals Tribunal or the High Court in respect of a Section 2 Assessment, a direction pursuant to section 5 or a decision by the Central Bank to seek an Enforcement Order or a Rectification Order.

Short title and commencement 12.

(1) This Act shall be cited as the Central Bank (Variable Rate Mortgages) Act 2016.
(2) This Act shall come into effect immediately.

5 10 15 20 25 30 6 7 Bille an Bhainc Ceannais (Morgáistí Ráta Athraithigh), 2016 Central Bank (Variable Rate Mortgages) Bill 2016 BILLE (mar a tionscnaíodh) dá ngairtear BILL (as initiated) entitled Acht do dhéanamh socrú maidir le bearta chun aghaidh a thabhairt ar mhainneachtana margaidh morgáiste ar sa mhargadh d’iasachtaí phríomhthithe cónaithe, agus do dhéanamh socrú i dtaobh nithe gaolmhara.
An Act to provide for measures to address market failures in the market for principal dwelling house mortgage loans, and to provide for related matters.

An Teachta Micheál Mac Craith a thíolaic, Presented by Deputy Michael McGrath, 16 Bealtaine, 2016 16th May, 2016 BAILE ÁTHA CLIATHARNA FHOILSIÚ AG OIFIG AN tSOLÁTHAIRLe ceannach díreach óFOILSEACHÁIN RIALTAIS,52 FAICHE STIABHNA, BAILE ÁTHA CLIATH 2.
(Teil: 01 - 6476834 nó 1890 213434; Fax: 01 - 6476843)nó trí aon díoltóir leabhar.——————DUBLINPUBLISHED BY THE STATIONERY OFFICE To be purchased fromGOVERNMENT PUBLICATIONS,52 ST. STEPHEN’S GREEN, DUBLIN 2.

(Tel: 01 - 6476834 or 1890 213434; Fax: 01 - 6476843)or through any bookseller.€1.27Wt.

71843.

614.

5/16.

Essentra.

(59050).

Gr.30-15.