"Premise 1 : God lives in another universe ( Heaven ) and therefore can not be detected in this universe . ( Definition of God ) Premise 2 : If something exists , then it can be detected/sensed . ( Definition of Existence ) Contrapositive of Premise 2 : If something can not be detected/sensed , then it does not exist . Conclusion : God does not exist . The reason that this doens't prove Atheism is that it can not disprove the existence of , say , the Hindu gods , which are defined as beings in this world that can be seen . It just disproves theism ."
"I hate to break this to you but this is racked with illogic . Well , ok it 's `` logical `` but the premises rely on things that are pure assumptions . Just because something ca n't be detected does n't mean that it does n't exist . And , of course , if god is god the way we think about it , then God is everywhere , including in this universe . He is the universe ( but we ca n't detect him ) . Does he exist now or not ?"
"God lives in another universe ( Heaven ) and therefore can not be detected in this universe ."
"I hate to break this to you but this is racked with illogic . Well , ok it 's `` logical `` but the premises rely on things that are pure assumptions . Just because something ca n't be detected does n't mean that it does n't exist ."