"The validity of the violinist arguement might change if the analogy is to the fetus becoming a person some time into the pregnancy . Then the violinist analogy might be go something like this :"
"How about : A woman wakes up to find herself connected to a body . A body without a brain , which is using her own organs to be alive . Doctors are preparing to transplant a brain from a dying violinist into this new one connected to her and the date is set in the future . Would it be morally correct to disconnect herself and kill this body that has no identity , mind , consciousness or existence in actuality ?"
"The validity of the violinist arguement might change if the analogy is to the fetus becoming a person some time into the pregnancy ."
"A woman wakes up to find herself connected to a body ."